3 ms·
> In the process they have inflicted enormous harm to our economy and lives, but they have not shared a proportionate share of the costs. The costs they impose
by stephenr 11y ago
> In the process they have inflicted enormous harm to our economy and lives, but they have not shared a proportionate share of the costs. The costs they impose hardly justify the veritable monopolies banks are afforded by the laws and regulations which are very effective at preventing competitors from entering the market.
I'll just guess you're American.
America's obsession with "free market" is why you have terrible banks, terrible health care, terrible conditions for low income workers.
Governments are intended to serve the whole of society. If you elect a government that decides society is best served by private enterprises which are solely interested in making a profit and aren't bound by laws saying they have to serve the entire community responsibly, what do you expect?
And here's a tip for you: "disrupting" banks isn't going to work out well either. If banks are taxi's, what will the bank equivalent of Uber look like?
A company that hires thieves to run it's operations, and every 100th customer has their funds stolen by a member of staff.
Banks don't need more competition to be better. They need to be legally required to operate in a way that is financially reliable, and held accountable when they don't.
- dsfsdfd 11y agoI disagree, the structure is inherently centralised. What you are describing is more centralised control as the fix for too much centralisation. Centralisation concentrates power, that power is always going to be manipulated and perverted by those in the right places. You can't fix this with extra layers. You need an entirely new system, tear it down and start again - all of it - it's not fit for purpose. In it's place you need a decentralised systems whose intrinsic dynamics give rise to the properties we desire. Which is exactly what human social structure provides - when operating on the small scale - a balance between selfishness and altruism. Scale it up to it's current size and degrade the role of altruism and you end up in this catastrophic fuck up.
- humanrebar 11y ago> America's obsession with "free market" is why you have terrible banks, terrible health care, terrible conditions for low income workers. America's lack of free markets more like. Between the bailouts and increased regulations, bad behavior has been rewarded and good actors (including small community banks) have been hit pretty hard. > If you elect a government that decides... The problem with thinking government is the solution is that popular opinion is cyclical: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Presidents_of_the_United_States#Timeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Presidents_of_the_Unit... So whatever power you give to government to "set things right" and "ensure fairness" will be used (in probably less than 10 years) by someone else do do something "unfair" and "corrupt". > They need to be legally required to operate in a way that is financially reliable, and held accountable when they don't. I reject that the dichotomy is government on one side and corporations on the other. Most of the time, they are on the same side. Corporations campaign and get regulations and handouts friendly to their business models and push out competition. On a local level, sure, you have taxi lobbies getting strict rules that eliminate competition. On the federal level, we have laws on the books that allow jail time for violating copyright, which is basically violating a business model. I could see civil penalties, but jail time?
- DanBC 11y ago> America's lack of free markets more like. The good bits of US healthcare are the bits provided and paid for by the government. It's a weird combination of expensive (the US government pays more per capita than any other healthcare system; and insurance is expensive) and hard to access. > On the federal level, we have laws on the books that allow jail time for violating copyright, which is basically violating a business model. I could see civil penalties, but jail time? I agree that jail should be avoided for non-violent criminals. Isn't copyright law a combination of civil penalties (for people who just download stuff) and criminal penalties (for people who operate a business based on downloading stuff)? So if I download a bunch of movies they can sue me for loss of earnings of those DVDs, but if I burn those movies to DVDs and sell them it becomes criminal?
- humanrebar 11y ago> The good bits of US healthcare are the bits provided and paid for by the government. Like the part where I have to spend hundreds of dollars to see a doctor for something silly? Most of the time I go to the doctor, he doesn't tell me anything any nurse couldn't (and it's probably something I knew myself, walking in). So costs go up. That's all government. See also the basically unchanging pay-for-treatment model with is more-or-less mandated by acts of Congress. Want to create a medical retail startup that charges flat rates based on outcomes somehow? List all of the risks in that plan. How many of them are due to government regulations? To be fair, maybe medical regulations are fair, but acting like the private sector ruined healthcare is ignoring the tradeoffs of those kinds of regulations. > loss of earnings of those DVDs Exactly. Violating a business model. So the company should be able to recoup their losses in civil courts if it's unfair competition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_Copyright_Law_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_Copyright_Law_in_the_...
- stephenr 11y agoI know I shouldn't bite, but fuck it. > Like the part where I have to spend hundreds of dollars to see a doctor for something silly? Most of the time I go to the doctor, he doesn't tell me anything any nurse couldn't (and it's probably something I knew myself, walking in). So costs go up. That's all government. a) if it's something 'you already know yourself', why are you going to see a doctor? I've been to see a doctor (apart from return visits for a followup, or health certificates for my visa/work permit) a total of twice, in the last 10 years I'd say. Once I sliced my finger open (and it had to be cauterised) the other I had a weird allergic reaction to something and developed a rash. In that time I've had literally hundreds of cold's, the flu 3 times (in one year!) and plenty of small cuts bruises etc. Why didn't I go to the doctor for all of those? Because I don't need a doctor to tell me "drink fluids|take over-the-counter medicine|put a band-aid on it|keep warm" for basic health care. If you are visiting the doctor every time you have a cold or flu, maybe you need to stop complaining about your government being inefficient and start taking some personal responsibility. b) just because it costs 'hundreds of dollars' in America doesn't mean it has to. It's not a coincidence that your government is known around the world as being pretty ridiculous when it comes to getting shit done. Australia has universal health care, and there was recently a huge issue when the then-newly-elected government tried to introduce a $7 co-payment for each visit to a doctor. > How many of them are due to government regulations? American government regulations. Just because you have crazy laws, doesn't mean the rest of the world does.
- kuni-toko-tachi 11y agoYou buying into propaganda, none of the industries you cited are free markets. All of them are government run and regulated. All government does is centralize power, handling control to smaller and smaller groups of politicians who are bought and sold, replacing what should be millions of individual personal choices with one central corrupt authority. Time to stop drinking the leftist kook aid and think for yourself.
- tcfunk 11y agoI love how "being American" makes one somehow obsessed with free market and all that other hogwash that is apparently embedded in the hearts and minds of every American. I don't expect anyone to apologize for their place of birth, and I would ask that the same in kind.
- stephenr 11y agoNo one asked you to apologise. From an outside view, American society by and large seems to embrace unregulated 'free market' concepts and/or minimising the government's ability to have any kind of impact on society. The person I replied to claimed that Banks are the problem, and specifically mentioned the 2008 financial crisis, which was the result of banks doing things they never should have, because they are either not bound by laws about their behaviour, or they're not punished appropriately when they break said laws.