6 ms·
The Temporarily Disappearing Estate Tax
- jcnnghm 17y agoThe obvious conclusion: The Dead Collector: Bring out yer dead. [a man puts a body on the cart] Large Man with Dead Body: Here's one. The Dead Collector: That'll be ninepence. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I'm not dead. The Dead Collector: What? Large Man with Dead Body: Nothing. There's your ninepence. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I'm not dead. The Dead Collector: 'Ere, he says he's not dead. Large Man with Dead Body: Yes he is. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I'm not. The Dead Collector: He isn't. Large Man with Dead Body: Well, he will be soon, he's very ill. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I'm getting better. Large Man with Dead Body: No you're not, you'll be stone dead in a moment. The Dead Collector: Well, I can't take him like that. It's against regulations. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I don't want to go on the cart. Large Man with Dead Body: Oh, don't be such a baby. The Dead Collector: I can't take him. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I feel fine. Large Man with Dead Body: Oh, do me a favor. The Dead Collector: I can't. Large Man with Dead Body: Well, can you hang around for a couple of minutes? He won't be long. The Dead Collector: I promised I'd be at the Robinsons'. They've lost nine today. Large Man with Dead Body: Well, when's your next round? The Dead Collector: Thursday. The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I think I'll go for a walk. Large Man with Dead Body: You're not fooling anyone, you know. Isn't there anything you could do? The Dead Body That Claims It Isn't: I feel happy. I feel happy. [the Dead Collector glances up and down the street furtively, then silences the Body with his a whack of his club] Large Man with Dead Body: Ah, thank you very much. The Dead Collector: Not at all. See you on Thursday. Large Man with Dead Body: Right.
- 3pt14159 17y agoEstate taxes are retarded to begin with, this is just ridiculous. Why don't these people just give as a gift all their stuff to their kids while they are alive? Canada might have a 5% GST tax, but we don't have any of this nonsense.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jsm386 17y agoThe amount you could gift away per year, at last count (and it has been rising, recently to 13K - let's assume per spouse). With the 2009 threshold for estate tax ticking in at 3.5 million, if you are subject it simply could not gift this stuff all to your children...and that assumes you were gifting the money every year.
- cwan 17y agoIn the US, all you pay is the inheritance/estate tax - you don't get double taxed on the actual inheritance that you file. In Canada, while there isn't an estate tax, you get taxed on the gain as if it is income and so you pay the income tax. If you're going to compare apples to apples, the top marginal tax rates are about 45-50%+ in Canada (http://www.aurorainternational.net/Maximum_Personal_Marginal_Income_Tax_Rates.htm http://www.aurorainternational.net/Maximum_Personal_Marginal...) - and given the estate taxes in the US apply to anyone inheriting above a million, it's relatively equivalent for those people while it's considerably worse in Canada for everyone else given that considerably more people inherit less than a million. Another point of comparison - highest marginal tax rates start at 126K (Canadian) while you have to make over 370K USD to start getting charged the highest marginal tax rates. Addendum - re: gifts - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_tax_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_tax_in_the_United_States - "the gift tax prevents avoidance of the estate tax should a person want to give away his/her estate."
- antidaily 17y agoDon't a lot of people establish a living trust to avoid it anyway? It would be interesting to see what percentage of people who qualify to pay an estate tax actually pay the full amount.
- grellas 17y agoA living trust serves primarily as a vehicle by which to avoid having one's estate pass through probate - it does not reduce any applicable estate tax that is otherwise payable on death.
- anguslong 17y agoArticle says 5500 average per year fall into current estate tax. Estates taxed at 45% beyond the $3.5 million threshold (2009). 2010, tax is 15% of all assets without further action by Congress (or retroactive action). In 2011, 55% tax beyond $1 million. Which impacts significantly more (cite?) than 5500 estates. $1 million includes property, fixtures, assets, cash. Shame that tax code will (no doubt) impact decisions of quite a few terminal patients.
- grellas 17y agoThe problem with the estate tax is that it was passed in the name of getting back at plutocrats but has worked over the years mostly to make it difficult to keep family businesses intact when the founder dies. Insane as was the political compromise that led to this final 1-year "repeal" of the tax, this compromise likely will lead (assuming half-reasonable action by Congress this next year) to having a more lasting exemption amount that gives significant relief to many in the middle class beyond 2010. The family business problem will remain. Thus, one should be able to pass, e.g., a $3M estate to heirs without problem but, if you get to $10M and up, there will be a high tax hit. Still a highly unsatisfactory situation for the public, and one that has the politicians squirming as well, especially since the estate tax (speaking in relative terms only) does not really raise that much in revenue for the federal government.
- pwnstigator 17y agoThe problem with the estate tax is that it was passed in the name of getting back at plutocrats but has worked over the years mostly to make it difficult to keep family businesses intact when the founder dies. From the article itself: "Currently, the tax applies to about 5,500 taxpayers a year." (Emphasis mine.) 5500. We're not talking about upper-middle-class family business owners. We're talking about people who are seriously rich. Still a highly unsatisfactory situation for the public, and one that has the politicians squirming as well, especially since the estate tax (speaking in relative terms only) does not really raise that much in revenue for the federal government. This is because the estate tax threshold has been getting higher in every year since 2001. If Bush had left it alone, this would not be the case. Also, there are good reasons for an inheritance tax aside from revenue generation.
- grellas 17y agoThere is an interesting thread here (including my detailed post outlining some of the history on this issue) on whether inheritance should even be allowed (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1009053 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1009053). You may find the relevant figures for the estate tax in 2001 here (http://gift-estate.com/article/tax2001.html http://gift-estate.com/article/tax2001.html). At that time, the exemption was $675,000 and everything beyond that basically got taxed at significant rates, obviously affecting a lot of middle class people. If the tax is allowed to revert to the old rates in 2011, there will likewise be a significant impact on middle class people. That is why the politicians are squirming and why the exemption amount will likely be increased for 2011 and beyond to something that excludes many such people from the impact of the tax. By the way, I have worked as a business lawyer with family businesses since 1984 and am pretty familiar with their concerns in this area (for example, in almost desperately trying to use vehicles such as family limited partnerships as a way of trying to avoid or minimize this tax and thereby preserve their businesses for their kids on death). Those concerns are real and they do not apply simply to the ultra-rich (who, by the way, have ample mechanisms available to them - e.g., foundations - to bypass the estate tax altogether).
- pwnstigator 17y agoOne wealthy, terminally ill real-estate entrepreneur has told his doctors he is determined to live until the law changes. "Whenever he wakes up," says his lawyer, "He says: 'What day is it? Is it Jan. 1 yet?'"... I've never felt so comfortable calling a dying man an asshole. His only concern is whether he can hand off a cozy life to his spoiled progeny. Amazing. May he live into 2011.
- logic 17y agoThat's an interesting take on it. I read it as a father desperately trying to make sure his affairs are in order so his children can have the benefit of what he worked for. My father (a teacher, so not a rich man by anyone's standards) made quite a few unusual financial moves, quietly, before he passed, to make sure my mother was in a safe place financially (who, given the social norms of their time, never really dealt head-on with the family finances prior to his death). The rest of my siblings and I had already moved on to build our own lives, he wanted to make sure his wife was cared for when he couldn't do it himself. That you'd so easily begrudge a dying man looking out for his family at the end of his life without reading more than a soundbite in an article like this says more about you than about him, I'm afraid.
- startingup 17y agoThis is one of those evil taxes - you pay a life time of taxes and accumulate stuff, and then when you die, it gets dinged another 55%.
- ajscherer 17y agoIt seems like one of the least evil taxes to me. $3.5 million or more worth of assets are absolutely irrelevant to a corpse. So the great evil is that the descendants of someone who amassed a great fortune only get $1.5+ million that they did absolutely nothing to earn, after presumably having every conceivable advantage growing up? To me that seems much less evil than taking a fraction of what a living person actually worked to earn and might still need. Of course, I usually reserve the word "evil" for killing, raping, arson, dragons, Satan and that kind of thing. Taxes seem to have a much less dramatic effect on their victims.
- riffer 17y agoThis looks at the tax from the perspective of those who will inherit, and concludes that since spoiled kids don't deserve big inheritances, the estate tax is fair, just and moral. But what about where the money goes? Does the government deserve it? I don't think so. One might be able to make an argument that the money should go to society, because the system is what made the creation of wealth possible. But that's not what the estate tax does, the estate tax takes the money to the government. Arguing that spoiled kids have not earned it is a lot easier than arguing that the government is deserving. What about looking at the tax from the perspective of the individual who created the wealth? What the tax does is encumber the creator of the wealth from deploying it as he/she sees fit. Why do we want to encumber creators of wealth? TO CLARIFY: the gift taxes that are part of the estate tax complex encumber creators, not just corpses. If you remove the gift tax, I have no problem with the estate tax because nobody would ever pay it.
- KC8ZKF 17y agoWhy want to encumber an aristocracy, not creators of wealth. The creators in question are dead. Thomas Paine covers this in his pamhlet _Rights of Man_.
- dou001 17y agowelcome to visit: http://www.wowhotsale.com http://www.wowhotsale.com We are wholesaler of Nike Jordan and Other Shoes. We are a professional exporting company . We supply many kinds of Shoes, such as Nike Shoes, Jordan 1-23, Air Jordan, AF1, DUNK, Air max series etc. Most of them are in stock and can be supplied surely on time. All these shoes are packed with original-boxes and cards. ====> free shipping <==== ====>competitive price<==== ====>any size available<==== ====>accept Credit Card payment<==== HTTP://WWW.WOWHOTSALE.COM jordan air max oakland raiders $34--39; Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $25; Christan Audigier BIKINI JACKET $30; gstar coogi evisu true jeans $35-39; coach chanel gucci LV handbags $36; coogi DG edhardy gucci t-shirts $18; CA edhardy vests.paul smith shoes $32; jordan dunk af1 max gucci shoes $37; EDhardy gucci ny New Era cap $16; coach okely Adidas CHANEL DG Sunglass $18; HTTP://WWW.WOWHOTSALE.COM http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s81 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s81 (Hoody) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s17 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s17 (Shox) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=n516 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=n516 (AF jacket) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s32 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s32 (women boot) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s74 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s74 (Tshirt) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s79 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s79 (Jean) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s72 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s72 (Handbag) http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s62 http://www.wowhotsale.com/productlist.asp?id=s62 (Tiffany_Ring)
- parenthesis 17y agoThe estate shouldn't be taxed at all, but the beneficiaries should pay tax on what they receive: at 0% for charities, a low rate for otherwise poor beneficiaries, a high rate for already rich beneficiaries.