6 ms·
The "past" link is a nice feature, but what I'd really like to see is a way of weeding out duplicate stories before they're posted. For example, today there wer
by greenyoda 11y ago
The "past" link is a nice feature, but what I'd really like to see is a way of weeding out duplicate stories before they're posted. For example, today there were 9 similar stories posted (so far) about Facebook's new "dislike" button[1], causing none of them to receive a significant numbers of upvotes. Could we have a feature in the "submit" dialog that displays similar stories in the last 24 hours and then asks the user if they really still want to submit theirs?
[1] https://new-hn.algolia.com/?experimental&sort=byDate&prefix=false&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story&query=dislike https://new-hn.algolia.com/?experimental&sort=byDate&prefix=...
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoSecond this. I feel like I've seen more dupes lately as people rush to get a hot story in. The past and web links will help for sure but it won't stop the submitter unless they're prompted. That being said, these are all great features. More information access without being overly cluttered is a huge win for everyone.
- dang 11y ago> I feel like I've seen more dupes lately as people rush to get a hot story in Hard to say, of course, but this might be sample bias, not counting a bug we had briefly yesterday. From what we see, the community has been doing a lot more to track down duplicates lately. That's what inspired this new work.
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoThat's fair. I tend to browse /newest so I'm probably seeing them before they get cleaned up from on high.
- dang 11y agoWhen a story gets posted in many versions, most are knockoffs. If a knockoff has made it to HN first, I wouldn't want someone to hesitate to post a more solid article. I'm also not sure how to define "similar stories". Your link picks out the word "dislike" to search for, but that essentially encodes the answer to the hard part in the question. I do agree that it would be good to weed out variants of the same story (or better, merge them), and we're open to working on that. But today's features are more modest—nothing more than a way of easing the manual work that many of us are already doing. Not least yourself!
- Natsu 11y agoWhat about this for a sketch of an idea: Give us the ability to cite 'other sources' for the same story (ideally it should be smart enough to dereference other HN submissions if that's passed in). Then mods can, if they so desire, merge comments from separate discussions into one pool. Finally, for the alternate links, you could consider allowing users to vote the best source. I say 'consider' because I'm a bit iffy as to how it might work out. I don't remember any significant controversy over which story was best and mod rule might be for the best. There are also issues with how you score a poll when some options may not have existed during any given vote and HN tends to use approval voting in polls.
- eevilspock 11y agoHow about grouping stories covering the same current event/topic and ranking them by an aggregate score? This would keep the front page clean while also giving the event/topic a more appropriate rank (i.e. one higher listing rather than 2 or 3 separate lower ones). 6. SOPA making a comeback 217 points | guardian.com 46 comments | eff.org 27 comments | motherboard.vice.com 13 comments or perhaps: 6. SOPA making a comeback 217 points 76 comments SOPA Lives on for the International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition (www.eff.org) 113 points by DiabloD3 2 hours ago | flag | 41 comments Google, Facebook, Twitter and Yahoo Claim MPAA Is Trying to Resurrect SOPA (www.theguardian.com) 89 points by runesoerensen 3 hours ago | flag | 23 comments An Undead SOPA Is Hiding Inside an Extremely Boring Case About Invisible Braces (motherboard.vice.com) 12 points by lizzard 15 minutes ago | flag | 12 comments Groupings would be created on-demand by the editors in response to user flags. Within the group you could list the links in order of their individual scores. The title of the group could come from the highest ranked or could be manually chosen by editors. You could have separate comments pages, but also a group comment page which is just the union of all the comments. Later you could take this a step further and include historical posts in the list, thus avoiding redundant comment streams (but only use new votes and new comments for ranking the group -- it has to freshly earn any reappearance on the front page).
- krapp 11y agoIf and or when they add thread folding, folding for the story links themselves might be a logical extension of that. You could have the top ranked story and under the fold the last, say, five related.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoWhat is the difference between new-hn.algolia.com/?experimental, and just regular hn.algolia.com ?
- greenyoda 11y ago"Experimental" changes the layout a bit. You can try it by going into the settings (icon at upper right) and changing "Style" to "Experimental". I think that at this point, "hn" gives you the same thing as "new-hn". I just have an outdated link in my bookmark.