4 ms·
I salute your sentiment: the world would be better off without companies like HT. It is in fact probably unlawful for them to do so I realize that the patriot
by bediger4000 11y ago
I salute your sentiment: the world would be better off without companies like HT.
It is in fact probably unlawful for them to do so
I realize that the patriotic employees of the NSA work within a legal framework, and seemingly pride themselves on doing so. But they haven't bothered to share that framework with the rest of us. So my first response was to snicker to myself, and that's unfair to you.
Also, Hacking Team was Italian, not US, so would it really be illegal to slurp up all of HT's exploits? That is, if you want to stay within the bounds of the law, if not the bounds of ethical behavior.
- tptacek 11y agoI tried to acknowledge that HT is jurisdictionally complex; they are probably allowed, under the same charter that allows CIA to conduct HUMINT missions, to attack Italian security companies (modulo treaties, I guess). The issue though is that those attacks have direct impact on US companies, who (again) may rely on HT products for "zero day pentesting" (among other things).
- HiYaBarbie 11y ago> they are probably allowed, under the same charter that allows CIA to conduct HUMINT missions, to attack Italian security companies They are definitely not allowed, under the Constitution, to monitor everyone, but they do it anyway. You know this too. So why do you discuss legislation as if it mattered to the NSA, when their actions show it clearly doesn't?
- ikeboy 11y agoThe NSA consists of many parts. Some people within it breaking the law does not mean that laws don't matter there.
- HiYaBarbie 11y agoLook, the NSA as an organization, as a whole, is blatantly violating the Constitution, which is supposedly the most sacrosanct law of the nation. The fact that they don't care about what laws say doesn't get any clearer than that. The fact that no one from NSA has gone to jail for the NSA violating the Constitution shows.. well, pretty much that the government doesn't bother punishing itself for violating its own laws. To be fair, that would be kind of silly, after all.
- ikeboy 11y agoHas any court ruled NSA actions to be against the Constitution?
- HiYaBarbie 11y agoHow does it matter?
- ikeboy 11y agoIf years after the Snowden revelation, no one has gotten a court to rule that blatant widespread constitutional violations took place at the NSA, you might want to reconsider your claim that there were blatant violations.
- HiYaBarbie 11y agoYou're disingenuous so I'll just not bother anymore.
- flyryan 11y agoYou're stating that the organization "as a whole" is "blatantly" violating the Constitution. Don't you see why your statement is being challenged? It's largely baseless. At most, a small number of programs that the NSA has used have been shown to maybe be unconstitutional.
- 11y ago