3 ms·
Yes, but Bitcoin is a full system already designed for this exact purpose. The only real issue is the waste of proof-of-work, but that's proportional to the has
by icebraining 11y ago
Yes, but Bitcoin is a full system already designed for this exact purpose. The only real issue is the waste of proof-of-work, but that's proportional to the hashing power given to it; if the chain is private, a single server per bank would suffice.
- repomies691 11y agoWhat is the point of doing any mining at all, if it is unnecessary? Adds just extra complexity to the system. These bankers are idiots.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoNone of what you said makes any sense. No bitcoin isn't designed for private ledgers, it's the exact opposite, an innovation to make global, public, decentralised/distributed (you can argue the semantics a bit here), trustless system without a dependency on any particular set of gate keepers, while keeping alive some semblance of privacy/pseudonymity. This private banking database requires none of that and is the opposite of what bitcoin was designed for. And the gigantic waste of proof-of-work is completely unnecessary, and forcing the use of it regardless by keeping a 'single server per bank' is insane, it's literally a waste of money. Not only that but it doesn't even achieve anything you want as it creates a false sense of security, after all what stops a bank from simply having more than 1 server and blowing all the proof of work from anyone else out of the water and dictating the entire database? Well guess what, the exact same thing that obviates the need for a proof of work system in the first place. Bitcoin is the dumbest possible technology outside of the context for which it was designed, in which it appears to be the only viable technology and works incredibly well. Running a private blockchain with a set bunch of gate keepers is simply ridiculous.
- icebraining 11y agoI agree. My point is: Bitcoin is a well-tested shared ledger, with plenty of eyeballs trying to exploit and secure it. Does it make technical sense to run Bitcoin for a private ledger? No, it does not, you're absolutely right. But does it make business sense to waste a few CPU cycles mining, compared to wasting probably hundreds of thousands of dollars developing custom software for this purpose, which will still be less tested and probably more insecure? I'd say it does.