3 ms·
No, the key innovation of Bitcoin is that it enables establishing a consensus in a distributed system. That's what the blockchain does. Pseudononymity, by con
by CydeWeys 11y ago
No, the key innovation of Bitcoin is that it enables establishing a consensus in a distributed system. That's what the blockchain does. Pseudononymity, by contrast, is nothing special, and arguably all electronic systems can trivially have pseudononymity because how can you really say which real-world entity something virtual corresponds to anyway? Bitcoin is no more pseudononymous than if I generate some random PGP keys with fake names and start signing and sending messages with them.
- tacotime 11y ago>Bitcoin is no more pseudononymous than if I generate some random PGP keys with fake names and start signing and sending messages with them. That sounds like a very anonymous way of distributing messages. Bitcoin's anonymity is more like having an unregistered bank account whereas BB (before bitcoin) all bank accounts were registered in one way or another. You don't even need an 'account' to accept a payment, u just need a magic number, though there is arguably not a difference. I feel like you're talking about network layer anonymity and everyone else is trying to talk more basic protocol.
- danbruc 11y agoConsensus in a distributed system is not the innovation of Bitcoin, just propose a new block and let all parties digitally sign the block if they consider it valid. If more than half of the parties have signed the block it is considered accepted. This of course requires knowing the parties because otherwise a single party could just cast arbitrarily many votes. And here lies the innovation of proof of work schemes, preventing one party from casting arbitrarily many votes by making votes expensive. This also is no innovation of Bitcoin, Bitcoin just put all the pieces together. But if you don't need pseudonymity and can know the involved parties there is no need for proof of work, i.e. you can easily replace mining with an identity verification process. And you get a system that is in some sense better because you remove the possibility to obtain more voting power by buying more hardware.
- CydeWeys 11y agoThe system you're describing is not distributed, though. There has to be some centralized arbiter of which keys are considered valid members of the system. This list of keys is vetted and is kept up to date on all end systems. It doesn't work without that centralized arbiter because then you'd end up with situations where each party has their own separate list of other parties that they consider vetted, and this falls out of sync, and the blockchain completely falls apart as there is no longer consensus on whether any given block is valid or not. I will agree that the banks can probably come up with a centralized arbiter that works for them, and thus they don't need blockchain technology, but that isn't a counter to my assertion that the blockchain's key innovation is that it allows decentralization in a way that was never before possible.
- danbruc 11y agoYou could and probably should just include the information about parties joining, leaving or changing keys in the blocks so that there is no ambiguity about the involved parties. The fundamental issue is really making sure that a new party is authentic and not the equivalent of a fake account of an existing party. You could come up with something like the process when verifying a domain for a certificate, creating a special DNS entry or serving some specific content at a specific address. This doesn't really work because nobody stops you from registering arbitrarily many domains, it is just meant as an example that the process does not necessarily require a central authority. But there is a hard problem here, who is a party and gets one vote? Could a bank just create ten shell companies and then obtain eleven votes? Bitcoin kind of sidesteps this problem by implicitly declaring you a separate party if you possess some mining hardware and weighs your voting power by the hash rate of your hardware. So you are definitely right, Bitcoin achieves a degree of distribution that is probably really hard to do without a trusted central authority that has the power to decide who is a separate party and who is not. If the number of parties is small you could maybe still do it in a distributed way with some manual work. If a new bank wants to join they broadcast a request, use something like the mentioned DNS record to prove that the request is genuine and then all existing parties have to manually decide whether to accept or reject the new party and cast a corresponding vote. But this obviously doesn't scale well.
- exo762 11y agoThere are existing algorithms that do that. E.g. Paxos, Raft, 2PC. Real breakthrough of Nakamoto is devising a scheme where whole network is protected against Sybil attack. I.e. there is no need to don't trust or register parties who participate in the network. All elements of Bitcoin, such as proof of work, crypto ledger, merkle trees, etc were already known. Nakamoto combined them in a way which solves an unsolved problem.