3 ms·
Doesn't some of the blockchains security come from having a large number of players maintaining the chain? Isn't there a vulnerability that depends on someone t
by phkahler 11y ago
Doesn't some of the blockchains security come from having a large number of players maintaining the chain? Isn't there a vulnerability that depends on someone taking over a large enough percentage of the infrastructure? Wouldn't having a handful of entities doing the majority of the transactions allow them to commit fraud, or alter the ledger?
- gleenn 11y agoIf they do end up using something like Ethereum, the network would be the same network that everyone uses, so the number of users would hopefully be much larger than, i.e. the 5 banks listed or whatever.
- this_user 11y agoIf only trustworthy entities are part of the network, this isn't much of a problem. No large financial institution will launch an attack against their own network.
- csomar 11y agoMaybe the attack will be external then? (Thieves, Hackers, Foreign govs...)
- dogecoinbase 11y agoNo large financial institution will launch an attack against their own network. Hayes's LIBOR rigging scheme would seem to indicate otherwise.
- icebraining 11y agoI think there's a difference between rigging numbers and launching an attack on the network. All that it would happen is that the other peers would detect the increase on hashing power and shut down the nodes. The problem with a public blockchain is that you don't know who is hashing. On a private network, you can tell each node to only hash at a certain rate, and monitor the total rate to detect cheats.
- aianus 11y ago> If only trustworthy entities are part of the network Then you don't need a blockchain at all, just use a centralized ledger.
- eru 11y agoOr even decentralized.
- elektromekatron 11y agoThey will if they think they can make money from doing so.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 11y agoThis is basically the path you go down when you start to consider 'non-bitcoin' blockchains. Sure, you can do it, but if you want security, you go where the hashing power is. Network effect = one blockchain to rule them all Well, at least you'll have to connect in with the 'one blockchain'. Sidechains would be a great way to address this. It's important to remember how early days Bitcoin is, and cryptography and blockchains in general. They're still well within a research phase; it's hard to say what sort of solution they'll come up with.
- kang 11y agoI was talking to one of the bitcoin core devs and his opinion was that purely in terms of power consumed, litecoin could be more secure than bitcoin. Bitcoin certainly has the network effect in terms of usage going for it.
- icebraining 11y agoMaximizing hashing power is only needed in a public blockchain. If the pool is closed, you can force each node to provide a fixed power, and monitor the total power. If it increases over nodes*power-per-node, all nodes shut down automatically.
- maaku 11y agoBitcoin's security is not due to hash power alone, it is due to the decentralization of that hash power.