3 ms·
Little companies are rarely disruptive and disruption is what creates value and drives society forward.
by briandear 11y ago
Little companies are rarely disruptive and disruption is what creates value and drives society forward.
- hodwik 11y agoExactly, R&D requires capital. Capital comes from profits. Overly competitive markets destroys profits, destroying capital. Thus too much competition destroys R&D. Look at the airlines. There doesn't need to be this much competition in the airline industry (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airlines). They've had too many players for far too long, and it's caused them to compete to the bottom. Sure, flights are "cheap", but not as cheap as they would be if these companies could afford to upgrade their infrastructure, invest in more modernization efforts, and so on. In fact, the average airline makes about 1% return, or $100 in profit for every $10,000 they spend. That's not a recipe for a healthy business, or a healthy industry. By comparison, AMD and Intel have a duopoly on x86 processors and have for ages. Intel's profit margins waver between 1/4 and 1/3 of revenue. Simultaneously, processors get better and cheaper every single year.
- bobthechef 11y agoNot true at all. Indeed, it's the little companies that often can be "disruptive" (I hate that word; why is disruption necessarily good?). Indeed, large companies are in practice often invested in ways that prevent them from pursuing profitable business that smaller business can. Their business model can prevent them from pursuing profitable business because it would involve biting the hand that feeds them. Large companies become entrenched in a certain set of ties and a certain status quo. The last thing they want is to disrupt. It's very much a question of trade offs. Aside from that, your phrase "drives society forward". I always here this phrase thrown around in these discussions, but I have yet to receive a coherent explanation of what that means, or what this great lord of Progress consists of. I think one ought to remember what the aim is. Change is not the same as "better", chaos is also change (the article says we fear change at its core, which I think is stupid; we fear loss of something which change can entail; some are addicted to change for its own sake out of from psychological illness). There is the social dimension to consider, the psychological, the spiritual, the environmental, etc. The empty profit seeking and vacuous worship of tech or whatever is desolate.
- caskance 11y agoSurvivorship bias. Disruption isn't necessarily good. That's why most startups fail. The ones that thrive tend to be those that disrupted goodly.