4 ms·
Near miss? It's a near hit! A collision is a near miss! sound of explosions "Aw, will you look at that, Dave. They nearly missed." "Yes. But not quite!" --
by peterwwillis 11y ago
Near miss? It's a near hit! A collision is a near miss!
sound of explosions
"Aw, will you look at that, Dave. They nearly missed."
"Yes. But not quite!"
-- George Carlin
- mikeash 11y agoI greatly enjoy that bit, but it's also totally wrong. "Near" is not the same as "nearly." It's "near" as opposed to "far." It's a miss which is near.
- throwaway1967 11y agoThat is correct, but the frog died in the process. :)
- peterwwillis 11y agoI don't buy it. What if the miss wasn't near? Would it be a far miss? An average miss? What exactly is the point at which you go from colliding to a near miss, to any other kind of miss? It's redundant language.
- mikeash 11y agoSure, if you miss by a huge amount it could be a "far miss" or a "distant miss" or similar. The point where you go from colliding to a near miss is the point where the two things don't touch. There's no exact point where you go from a near miss to a regular sort of miss, since it's not a precision term.
- peterwwillis 11y agoBut they don't far miss or distant miss. They weren't aiming for each other. "Near miss" is the only way you would ever refer to planes almost colliding with the word "miss", so the "near" part is redundant. They missed. If you wanted to say they were close, you could say they almost hit, which is not only more accurate, it's not redundant, because you can't take out either word and still express the same idea. This isn't just to be pedantic; there's lots of redundant or incorrect language out there which Carlin talks about at length.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoSo "near miss" is redundant if it's an accident, but not redundant if you're actively trying to collide with the other plane? Having different terminology for the two cases seems like a lot more trouble than it's worth. In any case, this doesn't change the wrongness of "A collision is a near miss!"
- Nadya 11y agoIt's all about reading. e.g "near dead" means "I was almost, but not quite dead." Therefore "near miss" could be read as "close to, but not quite a miss" and it would be more accurate to say a "near hit" meaning "close to, but not quite a hit". In this context, a "near miss" is a collision - that almost didn't happen and a "near hit" would be a collision that almost happened but didn't. Edit: If trying to collide, it would be appropriate to call a collision that almost didn't happen a "near miss".
- dragonwriter 11y ago> there's lots of redundant or incorrect language out there which Carlin talks about at length. While Carlin -- as comedians often do -- used the manner in which natural language idioms are irregular as the basis for some of his humor, the irregularity of natural language idioms is not incorrectness. It may be aesthetically displeasing to people who have a strong preference for regularity -- a preference which is probably overrepresented in the HN audience -- but that's a different issue.
- peterwwillis 11y agoI'm not concerned with aesthetics. I'm concerned with incorrect language which leads to incorrect thinking. I could talk at length about a single word and how its misinterpretation by a huge subculture leads to bad decision making, but let's just say words are very important.