4 ms·
> If everyone called a tail a leg, it would be a leg. You are sorely confused. When mixing different languages, you need to keep track of which is which, other
by Camillo 11y ago
> If everyone called a tail a leg, it would be a leg.
You are sorely confused. When mixing different languages, you need to keep track of which is which, otherwise you just end up making a pun. In this case, "if everyone called a tail a leg" hypothesizes an alternate English where the distal portion of a dog's spine is called "leg" instead of "tail". We'll call this English Prime, and denote English prime words with a hash sign, to distinguish them from ordinary English words: #leg.
Obviously, the sentence itself is still written in English, not in English Prime. Otherwise it would be impossible to ascribe any meaning to it, since we have not defined the meaning of any English Prime words besides #leg - and we could not even define that one without using English.
The only words that are to be interpreted as English Prime are the ones that are explicitly quoted from the hypothetical scenario. Therefore, "if everyone called a tail a leg" can be written as "if everyone called a tail a #leg".
Now we have the following:
- If everyone called a tail a #leg, it would be called a #leg. Clearly true.
- If everyone called a tail a #leg, it would be called a #tail. Clearly false.
- If everyone called a tail a #leg, it would be a tail. Clearly true.
- If everyone called a tail a #leg, it would be a leg. Clearly false.
- tomlock 11y agoYou're right, I am confused. The concept of there being a central authority that determines what is English, what is a dialect of English, and what is pidgin, is ridiculous. Language is an ever-evolving construction with fuzzy edges that defies anyone's ability to ascribe definite true or false values to it. Words have different meanings to different people. #literally :) Is d'oh a word? When did it become a word? Which dictionary defines what a proper word is? Yolo? Swag? As an Australian, swag has a very different meaning to me than the meaning you are probably, in your current state of mind, ascribing to it.