3 ms·
There's basically two competing interpretations of the Western US drought: 1. It's a storage problem (i.e., most farmers): those damn environmentalists blocked
by jcranmer 11y ago
There's basically two competing interpretations of the Western US drought:
1. It's a storage problem (i.e., most farmers): those damn environmentalists blocked us from building more dams so we lost the ability to store more water when wetter years happened in the past, and now we've got almost nothing left to draw water from.
2. It's a throughput problem (i.e., most environmentalists): those damn farmers are using more water per annum than nature is providing on average. They desperately need to cut their water.
When major constituencies can't agree on the problem, how do you get them to agree on a solution?
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoThis is an easy problem to solve with our friend, data. Just run some models and simulations and calculate where water usage is heaviest.
- thaumaturgy 11y agoThat data pretty well exists, though it could always be improved. There are charts you can find that give the annual water usage per tree for different varieties of trees. But, as much as I'm a complete raving lunatic fan of data-driven politics, there's still politics involved. The data doesn't really tell you what to do, which was jcranmer's point, and mine. At best it just tells you what not to do.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoBut isn't that the case with any kind of thing people use? You need to create/store it, and you need to deliver it. I go to the supermarket shelves and there are hundreds of items with similar issues. We don't debate the hoarding of pickles. Or the production capacity of peanut butter. This is a serious problem, and I'm not trying to belittle it. But as I recall, you can give people a gallon of water anywhere in California for just a few pennies, maybe less. To interested outsiders, the issue here seems to be almost entirely a political one.