3 ms·
> and has resulted in an exclusion zone And how many of those can we afford to have in the world? How much liquid contaminated waste can we put into the ocean
by grecy 11y ago
> and has resulted in an exclusion zone
And how many of those can we afford to have in the world?
How much liquid contaminated waste can we put into the ocean?
- slacka 11y agoHow often do we get 9.0 earthquake + tsunamis? I'm sure the earth and humanity would be much better off if every nuclear reactor was hit by one of these then the catastrophic damage caused by global warming. How many countries can afford to feed their population when their farmlands have turned to arid deserts and their coastal cities are all underwater? Just look at all the recent super storms and California's drought. Compare that to fukushima. And this is only the beginning. Global warming is the threat you should be worried about.
- p1mrx 11y ago> if every nuclear reactor was hit by one of these I don't know, if Iowa and Nebraska got hit by a 9.0 earthquake and tsunami, I would be pretty fucking terrified.
- slacka 11y agoha. To clarify my point. The end game of a runaway greenhouse effect is far more terrifying than thousands of nuclear accidents. Sure the local effects of a melt down are scary, but it takes the worst earthquake in the Japan's history to cause that kind of disaster on an obsolete, ancient reactor. Every generation of reactor get safer. Even if they weren't, we learn from every accident. Fukushima could have been prevented. In fact, Onagawa a nearly identical reactor under similar circumstances was spared by the heroic efforts of its operators.[1] [1] http://thebulletin.org/onagawa-japanese-nuclear-power-plant-didn%E2%80%99t-melt-down-311 http://thebulletin.org/onagawa-japanese-nuclear-power-plant-...
- mrep 11y agoHow much pollution and c02 can we put into the atmosphere? The total effects of pollution and c02 i would say are worse than the occasional meltdown. It's just that meltdowns are so much more high profile so everyone notices and freaks out. (Definitely not saying meltdowns are good though)
- brc 11y agoWell, the world is a big place, and the exclusion zones are pretty small. The ocean can take a lot of contimination. Obviously nobody wants that, but a tiny bit of somewhat radioactive water is going to dilute quite substantially.
- pdonis 11y ago> How much liquid contaminated waste can we put into the ocean? A lot. The Wikipedia article [1] quotes a flow rate of 400 tons per day. Let's suppose that that flow rate was maintained for 30 years, a typical reactor lifetime (which is far longer than anyone is claiming a flow of contaminated waste from Fukushima). That comes to 400 * 365 * 30 = 438,000 tons of contaminated water, or 4.4 x 10^8 kg. According to the Physics Factbook, the mass of water in Earth's oceans is about 1.3 x 10^21 kg. So 30 years' worth of contaminated water from Fukushima amounts to about 0.3 parts per trillion of contaminated water in Earth's oceans. That's not even comparable to naturally occurring trace radioactive elements. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_disaster_cleanup#Radioactive_contamination_of_the_Ocean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_disaster_cleanup#Rad... [2] http://hypertextbook.com/facts/1998/AvijeetDut.shtml http://hypertextbook.com/facts/1998/AvijeetDut.shtml
- iofj 11y agoThat is of course what the safest way of disposing nuclear waste would be : disperse it sufficiently, and spread it everywhere. That is, after all, what nature has been doing for billions of years, and it doesn't bother anyone because we evolved under background radiation levels. Accumulation is what makes these things dangerous, and what do we do ? We put them all together, behind a thin layer of metal, guaranteeing that a localized problem bad enough to pierce a 3mm layer of metal and a dozen centimeters of concrete becomes a complete catastrophe. But good luck defending that one politically, no matter how much you've got physics on your side.