4 ms·
That's why there's such focus now on small modular reactors, with a bunch of startup companies attempting to develop them. The main impediment is the NRC, which
by DennisP 11y ago
That's why there's such focus now on small modular reactors, with a bunch of startup companies attempting to develop them. The main impediment is the NRC, which has been slow to come up with licensing rules appropriate for small reactors or advanced designs (some of which have very good passive safety).
- mmmBacon 11y agoHere's a recent article from IEEE Spectrum that argues that small reactors will never be cost competitive. http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/the-forgotten-history-of-small-nuclear-reactors http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/the-forgotten-histor...
- DennisP 11y agoThat's an argument based on a lot of old reactors, mostly light-water variations. Solar wasn't economically viable back then either, but technology improved. The same is happening with nuclear. In particular, simple molten-salt reactors like those designed by Terrestrial Energy and ThorCon look very promising.
- mmmBacon 11y agoThe article is from this year. What about these advanced designs makes them more cost competitive? I think the arguments in the article point out that there are lots of costs associated with these small reactors. Not the least of which is that they require decommissioning sooner than their larger counterparts and that the cost of decommissioning alone can make the reactor non-viable economically. It's not clear how changing the working fluid would reduce decommissioning costs.
- DennisP 11y agoIt was written this year, but the reactors it mentions are old. Here's a good rundown of ThorCon's cost projections: http://thorconpower.com/costing http://thorconpower.com/costing It doesn't use any technology that wasn't proven in the 1970s: http://thorconpower.com/features/no-new-technology http://thorconpower.com/features/no-new-technology The reactor cores are in sealed replaceable "cans." They run for four years, cool for four years, and then shipped back to a processing facility. Terrestrial Energy has a similar design: sealed factory-built units with a simple liquid fueled design, based on the Oak Ridge molten salt reactor: http://terrestrialenergy.com/imsr-technology/ http://terrestrialenergy.com/imsr-technology/ Safety is completely passive, based on the inherent physics of the fuel and coolant. It's at atmospheric pressure, with no possibility of a chemical explosion like we saw at Fukushima. Fission products mostly plate out or are chemically bound in the salt. In ThorCon's case, if the reactor lose electricity, a frozen plug of fuel melts, and all the fuel drains out to a tank designed to passively cool it.
- Gibbon1 11y agoI tend to think the 'push' for small reactors, fifth generation reactors, and alternative designs is same as the 'push' for 'clean coal'. A political ploy to keep the government subsidies coming and forestall the eventual taxing of the industries externalities. And to hopefully prevent alternatives like solar from getting funding. Seriously, solar is already at cost parity and the economics are getting better with time. Plus externalities are minimal. Compared to nuclear power which gets less economic over time and has very open ended externalities.
- DennisP 11y agoSolar's at cost parity if you don't consider the overproduction and storage you'd need to run civilization on it, without fossil backup.
- brc 11y agoSolar is a niche technology with a limited role to play. You need to double production in the day and add storage just to get 24hr supply. If you want more than 12 hours backup you need to double again. If you want 48 hours backup you need 4x production and storage. The numbers get quite unfeasible quite quickly. You cannot have an energy generation system that is unable to cope with a multi-day weather event, right when you need it to be producing energy. As a load following, top-up power source for peak daytime usage, or for charging storage based devices like cars, it's great. But you cannot compare solar and nuclear because they are entirely separate classes of energy production.
- zurn 11y agoCheap power by day, expensive by night can shift a lot of demand to daytime. Like water/building heating, cooling, battery charging, etc.
- 3pt14159 11y agoI agree that solar is already at cost parity, but not after battery costs. Furthermore I live in Canada, in the winter our solar power generates only 1 / 80th of the power, and unless we're going to tie our energy security to the United States, we're going to need alternatives. Nuclear power in Canada is a complete success. We generate at 6 to 7 cents per kilowatt hour in the first 30 years, and the amortized cost continues to decrease after that. Yes there are maintenance costs, but do you know what else there are? Medical isotopes that the world desperately needs to keep our diagnostics working. You can make nuclear cheap and safe. The problem is cultural, not scientific. If a society is too greedy and corrupt or too deferent to authority, then nuclear won't work. But in places like Canada, Sweden, and France they work very, very well. Also, Thorium reactors are much less likely to cause problems and they are part of the fifth gen reactor designs. We need both nuclear and solar.