3 ms·
The primary reason is that material goods are of exclusionary use. If I'm farming an acre of land, you can't. You are no poorer if I sing a song you wrote tha
by aidenn0 11y ago
The primary reason is that material goods are of exclusionary use. If I'm farming an acre of land, you can't. You are no poorer if I sing a song you wrote than if I don't.
A lesser argument is from history:
Organized societies that consume resources faster than they are provided (so essentially all societies that aren't sparsely populated hunter-gatherers) need some form of restriction on use of exclusive goods such as land.
Organized societies have existed with essentially no restrictions on what we today call intellectual property. Some copyright is good, as we couldn't have 9 figure budget films without it, but if we were to restrict copyright to 40 or even 20 years, we would affect that not at all.
After typing all this out, I recognized your nick, so suppose that you know all of this; what is your counterpoint?
- rayiner 11y agoIf the exclusionary nature of physical property was the rationale, then borrowing property when someone else wasn't using it, or analogous non-conflicting activities like squatting, it wouldn't be considered infringement of property rights.
- Bjartr 11y agoInterestingly some countries, such as Scotland, have "Freedom to Roam"[1] laws that codify that very idea. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam
- nitrogen 11y agoSquatting would remain problematic because the owner of physical property would no longer be able to start and stop using their property as they pleased; they would have to wait for the squatter to vacate, and would be subjected to the sight of their property in use by a squatter (humans are territorial). As well, squatting often results in damage to the property. If these concerns could be addressed, why wouldn't squatting be okay?