3 ms·
Your land didn't depend on any other land in order to be created, for one thing. If you want perpetual copyright, go live on a deserted island and work without
by CamperBob2 11y ago
Your land didn't depend on any other land in order to be created, for one thing. If you want perpetual copyright, go live on a deserted island and work without any outside influence.
- rayiner 11y agoSure, creative works may be influenced by other creative works, but those are also protected by copyright and bought and paid for. I don't see how your argument justifies anyone else having rights to your creative works.
- magicalist 11y ago> I don't see how your argument justifies anyone else having rights to your creative works. Considering that they are intangible, I think you'll have to justify your exclusive rights to your creative works and why the government should enforce them. Fortunately (in the US) the constitution has you covered, and notably does not root it in an abstract right of ownership but as a means toward "the progress of science and useful arts".
- rayiner 11y agoI agree that the rival nature of physical property tends to cut in favor of stronger protections for physical versus intangible property. On the other hand, given the moralistic undertone of "rights" I think it doesn't make sense to ignore the other distinction, which is that intangible property is much more the product of human will and effort than many kinds of tangible property, particularly land. I think that cuts the other way--in favor of stronger protections for created property than not-created property.
- CamperBob2 11y agoYou can't afford to pay for every creative influence you've ever had. Neither can J. K. Rowling or Stephen King.
- Retra 11y agoYou don't pay for your language or your culture. You have them because you are a social being, and because your brain is built to absorb that information. You can't regulate exclusivity on it. If you want perpetual exclusive rights to your creative works, then don't share them with anybody. Because you don't actually have a right to get paid. You have a right to participate in your society and its economy.
- SilasX 11y agoIt would have physically existed (just as the artistic creation would have had a platonic existence), but it would have no economic value unless people could use other land to get to it, so it seems the two are the same in this respect.