5 ms·
He's represented by law students? This puts the image in my head of Amanda Seyfried arguing in open court that a teddy bear has rights. I'm actually surprised h
by bitwize 11y ago
He's represented by law students? This puts the image in my head of Amanda Seyfried arguing in open court that a teddy bear has rights. I'm actually surprised his case got anywhere, never mind to this level of victory.
No disrespect to any law students, but if you're going to step to the national security state, your law game had better be "A".
- spacemanmatt 11y agoIt took them 10 years...
- TrevorJ 11y agoMy impression of the legal system is that that's movin' pretty quick.
- msandford 11y agoTrue, but still incredibly contrary to the Bill of Rights. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights#Sixth_Amendment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights#S... I wouldn't consider over 10% of one's life expectancy (at least for now) to be "speedy"
- michaelhoffman 11y agoThat section starts "In all criminal prosecutions" This is not a criminal prosecution. It is a civil suit.
- aqwwe 11y agoyou can't go to jail for violating a gag order then?
- DannyBee 11y agoIf someone did and it took 10 years to resolve, that'd be an issue (Note: A lot of states have deadlines on appeal resolution, etc, for criminal cases)
- JoshTriplett 11y agoSo they should have to actually break the law to get justice in a timely fashion? If you're being affected by a law that would see you face criminal charges, challenging it ought to be as timely as those criminal charges; otherwise, it's all too easy to set situations like this up. While I look forward to the first instance of someone standing up and very publically and broadly violating an NSL to get such an abomination into a real court, that shouldn't be a necessary step. The whole mess needs abolishing, but in the interim, 10 years is about 9.95 years too long.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>So they should have to actually break the law to get justice in a timely fashion? Kinda like how you have to show you've been harmed to sue someone. Nice rules in theory, but in practice the government will use them like loopholes to keep themselves out of trouble.
- DannyBee 11y agoThese rules do not exist because the government used them as loopholes, these rules exist because citizens used them as loopholes to sue other citizens :) The government was already protected. For example, you literally cannot sue the US government for torts without its permission. This has been absolute since day 1 of our government. The government has decided to abrogate immunity in a bunch of situations, but in general, the government was already protected from whatever it wanted to be.
- DannyBee 11y ago"So they should have to actually break the law to get justice in a timely fashion? " If you want to multiply the judiciary budget by a factor of 50 (which would be a lot of your tax dollars), yeah, i bet we could make this work, but as to the philosophical question: Yes. If you have no danger of actually being criminally charged, the courts should be free to resolve the issue at their leisure. Yes, there is a chilling effect, blah blah blah. That is not the same as "some guy gets the death penalty or thrown in prison for life". Courts resolve those issues first, and others second. Period. " that shouldn't be a necessary step." Sorry, but i completely disagree. Criminal charges involve possibility of being thrown in prison. Civil things do not. "The whole mess needs abolishing, but in the interim, 10 years is about 9.95 years too long." Remember this the next time the federal judiciary has to sit in front of congress and beg for money to fill the existing vacancies in appeals courts, let alone become large enough to make what you want happen. The pendency of appeals and length of lawsuits is directly related to docket sizes growing without bound.
- rayiner 11y agoHe's represented by Yale's legal clinic.
- ScottBurson 11y agoPerhaps this speaks to the weakness of the government's case. I don't know how long these gag orders should remain in force, but they clearly need to expire at some point, and 11 years is clearly long enough. I hope other NSL recipients are emboldened by this outcome to file similar suits.
- duskwuff 11y agoIf nothing else, there's absolutely no reason for a gag order to be allowed to outlive the investigation that it was supposed to protect.
- lsaferite 11y agoI'm fairly confident, in this case, they are using the gag order as a way to hide investigative methods. It's the same reason they try so hard to suppress stingrays being brought into the light. They don't want their opponent to know what they are looking for or how they find them.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>They don't want their opponent to know what they are looking for or how they find them. That is a tired old excuse. I think it's safe to say that cat is out of the bag now. The government wants to protect these methodologies from disclosure because they are in fact unconstitutional, and disclosure (as in part of the official public record) threatens existing convictions as well as present and future investigations. Additionally, there is probably more than a little bit of paranoia within gov't that someone might get in hot water over the illegal things they've been up to; though I'll believe that's a real fear after I see a gov't agent actually go to jail.
- s_q_b 11y agoThis really speaks to your ignorance regarding public interest law. Because cases that have little impact beyond pure Constitutional law often have little profit upside, law clinics are one of the mechanisms by which such cases reach the appellate level and the Supreme Court. The students that work on them often go on to prestigious Federal clerkships, major law firms, etc. The law clinic at Yale, as one would expect, is extremely well-regarded.
- hackuser 11y agoI understand that's the way it is. I think it's a problem; the most important issues should have the best attorneys.
- jljljl 11y ago"and supervising attorneys"
- jordanlev 11y agoWell, obviously it is if they won the case!