5 ms·
This is a tiny bit odd. So they have issued their first certificate, but they don't have cross-signing in place yet? So between now and november 16th they'll be
by Someone1234 11y ago
This is a tiny bit odd. So they have issued their first certificate, but they don't have cross-signing in place yet? So between now and november 16th they'll be issuing a whole bunch of effectively broken certificates unless people manually install their root CA?
Why even push this today if you don't have cross-signing available? Without that Let's Encrypt is effectively broken out of the box.
PS - I actually like Let's Encrypt and the work they're doing. I will be all queued up when they go live to grab one (and, yes, will put my money where my mouth is and donate). But doing this today without cross-signing seems strange.
- skorecky 11y ago> A cross-signature will be in place before general availability. https://letsencrypt.org/2015/08/07/updated-lets-encrypt-launch-schedule.html https://letsencrypt.org/2015/08/07/updated-lets-encrypt-laun...
- collinmanderson 11y agoWhat about after general availability?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoBaby steps. This is a huge step forward, and I'm willing to cut them some slack considering they're about to shake up an entire industry. EDIT: Kudos everyone working on Let's Encrypt. You're doing awesome work.
- ErikRogneby 11y agoFor real. This is so damn awesome I feel like letting out a Howard Dean like yell.
- willejs 11y ago+1, this is a huge step in the right direction.
- phire 11y agoIt's a bootstrapping process, I don't think they can be accepted as a root certificate until they have proved their automated issuing system it working. One way to prove that their automated issuing system is working, is to turn it on. Looks like they have set it up to only issue certificates for white-listed domains in the beta program, and they will switch to General availability in the Week of November 16th.
- _wmd 11y agoYou should read back over their blog to see how much planning has gone into this so far. This isn't a single-file LAMP app running on a VPS, they're setting up a CA trustworthy enough to have its roots in all the major browsers
- IgorPartola 11y agoAccording to TFA, Firefox already trusts this cert.
- callahad 11y agoIncorrect. Inclusion into the Firefox root store is being tracked in https://bugzil.la/1204656 https://bugzil.la/1204656 and has not yet been resolved. Firefox trusts the cert on TFA because letsencrypt.org itself is using a certificate signed by IdenTrust.
- IgorPartola 11y agoLooking at http://helloworld.letsencrypt.org/ http://helloworld.letsencrypt.org/ I see: > Let's Encrypt hasn't yet been added as a trusted authority to the major browsers (that will be happening soon), so for now, you'll need to add the ISRG root certificate yourself. Specifics will depend on your browser. In Firefox, just click the link.
- aroch 11y agothe iSRG root is not in FF[1][2]...you're visiting the http version of that URL. 1 http://idzr.org/y1pg http://idzr.org/y1pg 2 http://idzr.org/ee91 http://idzr.org/ee91
- callahad 11y agoAh, that is a bit misleading. When it says "just click the link," it's referring to the process for installing the root certificate. It should read "specifics will depend on your browser. In Firefox, just click the link [to the .der file, and you will see a prompt allowing you to trust it.]" It looks like this: http://imgur.com/dzC89xI http://imgur.com/dzC89xI Without importing the root, Firefox absolutely distrusts https://helloworld.letsencrypt.org/ https://helloworld.letsencrypt.org/, and will do so until Bug 1204656 is marked RESOLVED FIXED. :)
- schoen 11y ago
- joshmoz 11y agoWe need to demonstrate proper issuance under our root and gain confidence in our live systems before getting cross-signed. Issuing without a cross-signature for a bit is how we do this.
- dragonwriter 11y agoYou keep saying the word "broken" when nothing is broken at all, just the certificates are only useful in limited contexts.
- stevewilhelm 11y agoEven a "useful in limited contexts" clock is right twice a day.
- kcbanner 11y agoExcept this isn't a clock, it is an SSL certificate.
- mattdeboard 11y agooh
- yuvipanda 11y agoThey aren't making it generally available to the public yet, only to certain beta folks who know what they are getting. It isn't broken out of the box since it isn't 'out of the box' yet.