3 ms·
"Let pi be a rational number" Using pi as a name is only a very weak cue for "proof by contradiction". The title of the paper gives enough hint to detect it, b
by Someone 11y ago
"Let pi be a rational number"
Using pi as a name is only a very weak cue for "proof by contradiction". The title of the paper gives enough hint to detect it, but I would still use "suppose pi is rational", because it is the dead giveaway for proof by contradiction.
And as to 'obtuse': how many C programmers comment their 'main' function to help people unfamiliar with the language learn that it is the entry point of the program and receives its command line arguments as input? At some time, you have to assume your audience knows some lingo.
My main objection to this proof is that I do not find it beautiful; it feels like one shouldn't need to do integrals over goniometric functions to prove it.
Because it uses such fairly heavy weaponry, it isn't immediately clear to me that the logic isn't circular.