3 ms·
While I generally agree with you: 1) Youtube is a large publisher 2) Youtube runs ads and profits on posted videos. 3) Copyright predates the ability for ind
by aidenn0 11y ago
While I generally agree with you:
1) Youtube is a large publisher
2) Youtube runs ads and profits on posted videos.
3) Copyright predates the ability for individuals to make millions of copies for essentially zero-cost, so some updating to the rules for the digital era makes sense.
- cookiecaper 11y agoCopyright has also been taken to its logical extreme in recent history, granting copyright terms that, in many cases, won't expire for 150 years or more from the date of publication, well beyond the lifespan of any human. Copyright was supposed to be a compromise between the public and the rightsholder, where the public was willing to give up some of its natural right to copying and sharing in order to incentivize creativity. We've left all that in the dust now, and our copyright laws are currently based solely on scare tactics from massive media conglomerates. IP reform is badly needed but I think we've still got a little ways to go before it seems so "common sense" that it occurs. Once the generation that grew up on Napster and its successors gets into their 50s, we might see some substantive change.
- aidenn0 11y agoUnfortunately I've seen the opposite result so far. I've seen authors literally balk at the suggestion that they shouldn't have full control over their creations for perpetuity, and upon further digging, their point of view was that anything less is immoral, not just illegal.
- rayiner 11y agoI think that's a really compelling viewpoint. Why should society have any rights to an artistic creation? I can have perpetual rights to some land that my ancestors (well not my ancestors since I'm an immigrant) stole from native Americans, which existed long before any human was alive, but somehow my right to something that I created that never existed before is subject to a social balancing? I don't buy it.
- CamperBob2 11y agoYour land didn't depend on any other land in order to be created, for one thing. If you want perpetual copyright, go live on a deserted island and work without any outside influence.
- rayiner 11y agoSure, creative works may be influenced by other creative works, but those are also protected by copyright and bought and paid for. I don't see how your argument justifies anyone else having rights to your creative works.
- magicalist 11y ago> I don't see how your argument justifies anyone else having rights to your creative works. Considering that they are intangible, I think you'll have to justify your exclusive rights to your creative works and why the government should enforce them. Fortunately (in the US) the constitution has you covered, and notably does not root it in an abstract right of ownership but as a means toward "the progress of science and useful arts".
- rayiner 11y agoI agree that the rival nature of physical property tends to cut in favor of stronger protections for physical versus intangible property. On the other hand, given the moralistic undertone of "rights" I think it doesn't make sense to ignore the other distinction, which is that intangible property is much more the product of human will and effort than many kinds of tangible property, particularly land. I think that cuts the other way--in favor of stronger protections for created property than not-created property.
- CamperBob2 11y agoYou can't afford to pay for every creative influence you've ever had. Neither can J. K. Rowling or Stephen King.
- 11y ago
- gnaritas 11y ago> I've seen authors literally balk at the suggestion that they shouldn't have full control over their creations for perpetuity, and upon further digging, their point of view was that anything less is immoral, not just illegal. Their opinion is biased, of course they think that; they're wrong, but they're free to think that. Intellectual property is unnatural, allowing people to claim to own ideas forever is absurd.