3 ms·
All these words about how publishers need to jettison the legacy baggage of their print mindsets, and make the simplest thing that could possibly work, and how
by smacktoward 11y ago
All these words about how publishers need to jettison the legacy baggage of their print mindsets, and make the simplest thing that could possibly work, and how The Magazine is the canonical example of someone who has accomplished that feat.
And yet both the essay and The Magazine (which folded last year: http://the-magazine.com/faq http://the-magazine.com/faq) organized themselves around the idea that content is best organized as articles bundled into issues, which is a completely print-centric notion!
Why do articles have to be bundled into issues? The only reason for that bundling is because the economics of print require it. But the economics of online publishing are completely different. So why take it as written that "issues" have to be a thing?
For that matter, why do articles have to be a thing? If we're really trying to get back to first principles, maybe the idea of corralling facts into a narrative structure that's a certain number of words long should be challenged, too. Maybe content is best delivered online like a stock ticker instead, brief bursts of new material completely unmoored from each other, with the reader left to tie them together however she wants to.
(Hey, we just invented Twitter!)
I don't want to bag on TFA too much, it was written in 2012 and it's easy to take predictions from a few years back and poke holes in them with the information we have that the predictor didn't. But it does feel like it's part of a broader problem in publishing, which is people thinking they're making bold decisions and burning the bridges that connect them to the past, when in fact they're still carting around tons of legacy baggage that they don't realize is legacy baggage because they've lived with it for so long they just take it to be part of the environment. Which is why so many of publishing's Great Big Online Experiments (such as, ahem, The Magazine) end up feeling more like hedges against the future than daring attempts to seize control of it.
- Turing_Machine 11y ago"Why do articles have to be bundled into issues? The only reason for that bundling is because the economics of print require it." Not at all. An important function of magazines for readers is to hedge the risk. When you buy a copy of Popular Science or Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine or Good Housekeeping, you know pretty well what kind of content you're going to get. Even if you don't like every article or story, the chances are you're going to enjoy most of them (assuming you're a fan of the magazine to begin with). Granted, there's still some risk. Magazines do decline or change focus. The risk is still smaller than what you'd get with an unknown author. Also the price is usually less than you'd pay for a stand-alone work. For the writers, the magazine exposes their work to an audience that might not have heard of them before. We're actually seeing a mini-boom in magazine-like entities in the indy publishing world. Often they're called "bundles", but they're really not much different than a classic magazine -- except that you don't need expensive Manhattan real estate, printers, paper, postage, or any of the other factors that have put so many traditional magazines on the skids.