4 ms·
> Read more carefully. I did not forget the money being paid to the government. Instead I was describing a net effect and ignoring the H1B holder, which is why
by anamax 17y ago
> Read more carefully. I did not forget the money being paid to the government. Instead I was describing a net effect
and ignoring the H1B holder, which is why I provided an example.
Very few H1B holders who have skills that a US company values at $120k will take a job for $20k without some angle.
You suggest one such angle, namely that such employees go to another employer who doesn't pay the fee to govt, and suggest that original employers will therefore pay more to avoid losing the benefit from paying the fee.
Let's extend that example. Suppose that it takes $100k/year to keep an H1B holder from jumping ship. Add that to the $100k fee and that employee costs the original employer $200k. Since the agreed-on market rate for that job was $120k, the original employer isn't going to pay $100k year. Instead, they'll avoid the risk of losing the $100k fee and hire locally.
That's why the fee will discourage H1Bs for low-wage jobs.
If the fee is paid by all employers (and presumably refunded when an H1B jumps ship), there's no poaching bonus so every employer is essentially the first employer.
- btilly 17y agoFirst a pretty obvious point. The point of the H1B visa is to make it easier to import specialty workers whose skills are in high demand. By definition those jobs are going to be high wage jobs. Therefore not covering low wage jobs is a benefit - it ensures that the visa is only covering the kind of people it is supposed to cover. Moving on, where did you ever get a $100K figure from? I haven't even really thought through what the bond should be. I kind of like the idea of setting a cap on the numbers then letting the figure be set in an auction. But that said your extension makes a pretty big mistake. You're adding a $100K one time fee to the $100K/year salary and are coming out to $200K. But you're adding apples and oranges. If the employer only expects to keep the H1B for 1 year, your math is right. But suppose the employer reasonably expects to keep the H1B for 4 years. Now we're at $125K, which is only $5K over the market rate. Now an obvious question is how long the employer can expect to keep an employee for. There are two possible attitudes here. One is that turnover is out of your hands. The other is that it is under your control. I submit that the proposal is going to appeal more to companies that think the second and believe they can keep people happy. I happen to think that this is a good thing because I prefer companies with that trait and like rewarding them. Furthermore I believe that the proposal is going to be more appealing for companies with candidates that they reasonably believe are better than the local applicant pool. Again I believe that this is a good thing since that is exactly the kind of person and situation that this program is theoretically for. Except that today we verify this based on the testimony of the hiring company, whereas my proposal makes it in the best interest of the company to act this way.
- anamax 17y ago> Moving on, where did you ever get a $100K figure from? It came from the example.... As to whether it's reasonable, it came from an auction, which is the premise of the whole discussion. The number of H1B slots to be auctioned is a decision. We could set that number low enough such that only those companies that are willing to pay a lot to hire H1Bs will be able to. Yes, the employee may stay longer than a year. Or not. Your arithmetic doesn't make sense. If the employee stays 4 years, that's $25k/year. It's a $120k job, so the employer won't be willing to pay more than $95k. Now we're getting into the range where someone might be willing to take it, but there's a lot of employer risk in that number.
- btilly 17y ago>> Moving on, where did you ever get a $100K figure from? > It came from the example.... As to whether it's reasonable, it came from an auction, which is the premise of the whole discussion. Let me review your logic here. You got $100K from your example based on your theoretical auction and then you're arguing that $100K is too much and no company in their right mind would pay that much. From that you conclude that my proposal is bad. Well if no company in their right mind would pay that much, then they wouldn't bid up the auction that much. Therefore what you've just argued is that your hypothetical auction came up with an unrealistically high number. At which point you're arguing against a straw man that you set up rather than my actual proposal.
- anamax 17y ago> Let me review your logic here. You got $100K from your example based on your theoretical auction and then you're arguing that $100K is too much and no company in their right mind would pay that much. Not at all. I showed that the auction would raise the threshold at which companies would choose H1Bs. The amount clearly depends on what the auction price turns out to be. And, yes, we could restrict the number of H1Bs being auctioned so the price ends up around $100k. Or, we could set the number so the price is $100. > From that you conclude that my proposal is bad. Not at all. I merely accurately explained how things would work.