7 ms·
Can HN folks help me come up with a catchy name for something here? In particular, when somebody enriches themselves in a way that's a net negative when you loo
by wpietri 11y ago
Can HN folks help me come up with a catchy name for something here? In particular, when somebody enriches themselves in a way that's a net negative when you look at the whole system.
Here, for example, the guy says he "earned" €3k in a way that was almost perfectly wasteful. I'm not so worried about him; crazies gonna cray, and he knows that this is ridiculous. But there are so many people who have jobs that are equally wasteful but don't know it. E.g., all those people flooding in to the US mortgage industry to help inflate the 2004-2008 housing bubble with dodgy loans.
I want a punchy word or phrase that can a) help the rest of us talk about the problem, and b) at least occasionally puncture the bubble of self-justification that lets this go on. "Quack" and "scam artist" are good examples of what I'm after, but I want one specific to this phenomenon.
- marcusgarvey 11y agoIt's called "bullshit jobs." https://libcom.org/library/phenomenon-bullshit-jobs-david-graeber https://libcom.org/library/phenomenon-bullshit-jobs-david-gr...
- arnehormann 11y agoIt's a non-classical example of arbitrage.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoAnd both this and more-classical arbitrage is just someone enforcing the Law of One Price (by profiting from the price difference). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_one_price https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_one_price
- forgetsusername 11y agoMethinks you miss the OP's point. It isn't the name of the actual mechanism for the financial gain. It's a title for the idea of doing something wasteful, perhaps even net negative for society, for a very minor personal surplus. In this example, the guy wasted gas, created traffic, occupied employees time, put wear and tear on vehicles and roads and spent two days driving in circles...all for $2000. People are free to do what they want, and the "exploitation" is fair game, but it seems odd to me too.
- dublinben 11y agoI think you're being unnecessarily negative. This gentleman took a three day vacation, participated in his hobby, and earned $2000 for the pleasure.
- wpietri 11y agoNo, forgetsusername has me exactly right. My point is that he didn't earn anything. He was given something worth €3000 after performing assorted actions. But earning is about an exchange of value. He did nothing valuable for Avis; he instead wasted their time and resources. He only earned this money to the extent that pickpockets earn what they take out of wallets, or what con artists take from their victims. Sure, they work hard, and sure, they get money from it. That's not earning, that's taking.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- saurik 11y agoSo, I can sort of appreciate where you are coming from: if someone doesn't buy salt and instead keeps going to the fast food restaurant down the street grabbing handfuls of salt packets, they are being a pretty awful leech, as the reason salt packets are free and just available like that is because we trust people to not abuse the process like that. The alternative turns into what we have to do with packets of BBQ sauce, carefully limiting how many people are allowed for various food purchases, and then charging them $0.25 for extra. I can also see an argument that this person has discovered a security exploit that they are taking advantage of, akin to someone stealing wifi from an airplane hotspot. Whether because the person figured out an SQL injection attack in the website or because they figure out they can tunnel TCP over DNS, the more ethical thing to do is probably to report the bug to the company instead of abusing it to steal resources. This, however, is a different situation: AVIS seems to seriously be mis-pricing their core product, and in a way that is kind of sketchy to begin with. Here we have a company that is doing something I can't imagine many of us actually like: they have built a ludicrous time wasting procedure by which they abuse human psychology to encourage specific buying patterns, and they did it in a way that is well-known to be dumb. The way they have done this is by manipulating prices of products and providing an alternative currency with incentives for specific behaviors. If you want to see threads worth of people hating on this, search Hacker News for SkipLagged (the site that was sued for finding open jaw flight segments being priced incorrectly by airlines). Let's say I go into a Walmart, and they have decided to offer a $40 off discount on jeans, but they sell a pair of one of their brands jeans for $30, and the register treats the $10 as a credit. I tell the person at the counter about this, and they tell me "yeah, it's dumb; I just work here". And then I go to the checkout with a massive pile of jeans, and the people at the register at first give me a funny look, but then a wave of realization hits them and they start laughing. And then every day I come in and they have a basket of jeans sitting at the counter waiting for me. And they just don't care. In fact, the way you should model this is "Walmart seriously believes the price of jeans to be -$10", not "we are stealing money from Walmart". Sure, we think they are daft for valuing jeans at -$10, but we even told the people there and no one cared. They helped us do this. If you want a real world example, Sony sells Playstations at a loss. Some people would buy Playstations, install Linux on them, and then use them as nodes in Beowulf clusters, or as cheap fileservers for their house. Sony does this as an exploit against our buying behavior, making us more willing to put down the initial investment for the game console so we are more likely to buy games later. They then put a ton of DRM on their hardware, require companies who want to distribute software for their platform to pay them a royalty fee, and extract their rent from game developers. I see why they do this, but I hate it. It means that their entire business model is built in a way that encourages them to do things like sue people who jailbreak their consoles, as their profit is now tied to their ability to get paid for people developing and distributing software. If you ever wonder why Apple is so benign against jailbreakers while Sony sues them to death, it is because Apple has a business model where they make all their money on hardware (the App Store pretty much breaks even), making them only care about what you do with your device after you pay for it due to a combination of a control fetish, a strong aversion to bad PR, and a feeling of responsibility to protect their beginner userbase. But like, even barring these indirect effects, Sony has incorrectly priced something they have put on the market. They haven't done anything fundamentally different from someone willing to sell stock at a price higher than the market rate. When people here talk about arbitrage, it is because that is exactly what has happened: someone is pricing their product in a way that has encouraged someone to figure out how to extract value from it. Maybe you also hate high frequency traders, but it isn't quite fair to equate them to pick pockets and con artists. If we found out the people selling the stock were doing it at a loss, it makes them dumb, not the high-frequency traders evil. So while I can't imagine spending time finding these pricing mistakes, much less making all these phone calls and doing all this traveling to take advantage of them, the idea that this guy did is something I am totally fine with: "more power to him", I say. The usual worst case scenario that could come out of this is the "that's why we can't have good things" result of "no more stupidly complex promotional programs" (a similar situation to "no more free BBQ sauce packets"), but again: that would be a good thing, so I am having a difficult time feeling like this was due to someone doing something bad for humanity. (For my part, I run a marketplace, and I have a strict policy against illogical pricing promotions: I stare at every single discount a developer wants to have me apply to sales made via my platform, and I verify they don't have pricing paradoxes that would lead customers to have to waste their lives trying to figure out how to get the software they want at the cheapest possible price. And I really do consider doing anything else, as is all too typical in the travel industry, kind of scummy :/.)
- 6502nerdface 11y agoArbitrage in general is not a "net negative." It's a net positive, which is why arbitrageurs earn a profit; they are compensated for a service that generates value for someone else. To quote from Larry Harris' textbook [1]: "Arbitrageurs ensure that prices do not vary much across markets. When prices diverge, they buy in cheaper markets and sell in more expensive markets. The effect of their trading is to connect sellers in cheaper markets to buyers in more expensive markets." Arbitrageurs effectively "port" liquidity from one market to another. This is the value they provide to others. Thus I'm not sure I would describe this as arbitrage; or at least it's not the term the GP is looking for. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Trading-Exchanges-Market-Microstructure-Practitioners/dp/0195144708/ http://www.amazon.com/Trading-Exchanges-Market-Microstructur...
- peter303 11y agoArbitrage is when you exploit inequalities in the system. High frequency stock traders look for one millisecond inequalities between but-sell orders.
- Dwolb 11y agoIn economics we might also say his actions have 'negative externalities'
- mikeash 11y agoThat would be called Bandit behavior, according to The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity: http://web.archive.org/web/20031008123504/http://www.truestupidity.com/basic.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20031008123504/http://www.truestu...
- colinprince 11y agoHyper-pricing. You know, like hyper-miling.
- dlss 11y agoI would assume AVIS worked out the 5,000 bonus miles based on average profit levels across all rentals. When they used that measurement to inform policy, they violated an implicit assumption of their metric derived model. This is quite literally Goodhart's law: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law I also think you've got it entirely backwards to call OP crazy... he was not the person who built the system, but rather was exceptionally sane in responding to the incentives AVIS created (assuming he earns less than ~$2k/day). The only improvement I can see beyond simply renting more cars would be hiring someone to do the manual work of opening and closing his AVIS contracts.... well, that and selling miles for 1 euro-cent a pop. I have a name for what you're trying to talk about: "policy-created arbitrage", and I agree this is a great example. To me the issue was not people flooding the market with cheap mortgages in 04-08, but rather that pension funds and AIGFP were so willing to buy. Why where they buying? It's too long to cover in an HN comment, but the repeating pattern is substituting ground-level intelligence for top-down rules, and creating those rules in violation of Goodhart's law.
- mseebach 11y ago> hiring someone to do the manual work I don't know what the terms of the Avis deal was exactly, but FF miles will generally only post to the personal named account of same person doing the activity (taking a flight, renting a car etc) -- this is to protect against the 'improvement' you suggest, but in another shape: Requiring employees to post their miles to the company account instead of to their personal account.
- gpvos 11y agoWhat would be wrong with posting air miles to the company account? It seems like an extremely logical and good thing to do to me, and I don't understand why airlines would want to discourage it.
- malft 11y agoIt would remove the incentive for employees to pay $2k of company money to get $100 worth of (personal) free stuff.
- wrsh07 11y agoWould this include the screwy behavior during a drought? http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/07/22/425392169/episode-640-the-bottom-of-the-well http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/07/22/425392169/episo... > the screwed-up economics of drought, and why the rational thing to do in California right now is use more water.
- filleokus 11y agoDo you think that perhaps rent-seeking might be a good term? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking: "In economics and in public-choice theory, rent-seeking involves seeking to increase one's share of existing wealth without creating new wealth."
- datr 11y ago> when somebody enriches themselves in a way that's a net negative when you look at the whole system It sounds like you're describing the Tragedy of the Commons [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- aggronn 11y agoThis is a well known concept in economics called rent seeking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking Depending on how this works on Avis' end, this may or may not qualify, but rent seeking is definitely a thing. The wikipedia article has good examples of pervasive examples of rent seeking.
- arcticbull 11y agoSure. Arbitrage. Basically everything that happens over at flyer talk is arbitrage.
- roymurdock 11y agoQuacks and scam artists intentionally deceive others, generally by taking advantage of their lack of sophistication/knowledge of a particular subject matter for which they need a product. The classic example is the "Snake Oil Salesman" who claims to sell elixirs that can cure just about any type of health issue. He is in fact selling worthless junk with no curative properties in order to make a quick buck from a medically unsophisticated crowd. This 37rentals guy did not take advantage of an old woman with tuberculosis - he arbitraged AVIS' willingly extended offer. This is a company that knows how to run a car rental business, and it would seem that intentionally omitted rental length from the terms and conditions of the offer. What he did was not unethical, nor was it a net negative on "the whole system". He simply transferred value from AVIS to himself in a risk-free manner. The 2007 financial crisis was fueled by a lot more than "all those people flooding in to the US mortgage industry to help inflate the 2004-2008 housing bubble with dodgy loans." The underwriters behind the increasing number of subprime loans between 2004-2007 fit the description of Snake Oil Salesmen more accurately, with around 80% knowingly signing off on defective mortgages during 2007. [1] Mortgages, like medicine, can be complex and hard to understand for the average consumer. That is why we have the FDA & SEC to regulate these markets. The SEC failed to regulate the subprime lending market, and it failed to regulate all of the secondary and tertiary derivative markets where bundles of these toxic assets would be sold at leverage to investors who did not do their due diligence. The whole system should have been allowed to fail, and then been restructured under bankruptcy. It's completely unfair to compare what 37rentals did to what the underwriters and investment bankers did leading up to the financial crisis, but it was fascinating thinking about why they are different...thanks for the food for thought. [1] http://cybercemetery.unt.edu/archive/fcic/20110310183217/http://www.fcic.gov/hearings/pdfs/2010-0407-Bowen.pdf http://cybercemetery.unt.edu/archive/fcic/20110310183217/htt...
- wpietri 11y agoThe quacks I have met are often quite sincere. So I'm not interested in awareness that the behavior is bad, just that the behavior is a net systemic negative. I agree there are differences between what this guy did and mortgage brokers. In particular, this guy is shamelessly and consciously exploiting others to his profit. Some mortgage industry people were like that, but many others really thought they were doing something good, or at least didn't think very hard. They were wrong, though. This guy was of course a net negative on the whole system. Imagine that no money ever changed hands. What happened? A guy spent 2 days driving back and forth between two rental car companies. Other people spent time filling out pointless paperwork. Gasoline was burned. Wear and tear was put on the car. Substantial costs for no intrinsic benefit. If the guy had just gone into the Avis branch nearest his house and stolen $3k from their office safe, everybody would have been better off. That one happens to be currently legal and the other currently not doesn't change the wastefulness of it.
- devbug 11y agoIt's plain and simple a market externality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality "...an externality is the cost or benefit that affects a party who did not choose to incur that cost or benefit."
- wpietri 11y agoThanks, but that's not quite what I'm after. Both because externalities are positive and negative, and here I'm talking about negatives. And because participants in scams generally choose to participate, so it's not really an externality.
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoHarmitrage