4 ms·
> But IMHO it's another thing to behave like a parasite. Is the name calling/vilifying really helpful? Also companies remind us all the time that they're amor
by Someone1234 11y ago
> But IMHO it's another thing to behave like a parasite.
Is the name calling/vilifying really helpful?
Also companies remind us all the time that they're amoral, but when people treat companies in an amoral fashion suddenly everyone gets upset about it.
The ironic thing is that Avis as a company has TONS of complaints. Just google "Avis is a scam" and read all the stories about hidden charges, misleading headline figures, and so on. Pages and pages of them... Because they're amoral and only care about the bottom line.
Why is it wrong for people to only care about the bottom line?
- wpietri 11y agoThat isn't "name calling". It's just naming. What he did is very precisely parasitical. If it's wrong for Avis to be an amoral, predatory agent that focuses only on what they get without regard to the costs, then it is equally bad for this person to do the same. In one way it's worse: he knows he's being exploitative, where a lot of large-organization negative externality is due to clueless systems, not conscious individual choice. Approving of it because you don't like Avis and identify with this guy makes the problem worse. Because now you've helped normalize exploitation as a behavior, and people inside Avis will feel just as justified in their bad behavior because they can see themselves as responding to "those awful scamming customers".
- Someone1234 11y ago> That isn't "name calling". It's just naming. When applied to a specific individual, it is name calling. As in this case. > What he did is very precisely parasitical. Nope: > par·a·site; an organism that lives in or on another organism (its host) and benefits by deriving nutrients at the host's expense. Nothing precise about it. More like a slang insult for behaviour you disapprove of. > If it's wrong for Avis to be an amoral, predatory agent that focuses only on what they get without regard to the costs, then it is equally bad for this person to do the same. But when companies do it everyone ignores it, or screams "buyer beware." When an individual does it people start name calling, villifying, or using moralist arguments. It is a double standard. When Avis does it it is Avis' customer's fault, when a customer does it to Avis, it is still the customer's fault. > In one way it's worse: he knows he's being exploitative, where a lot of large-organization negative externality is due to clueless systems, not conscious individual choice. You're now literally playing the "Avis is amoral so it is ok" card. Why is it inherently wrong for individuals to act amoral towards an entity which also acts amoral? > Approving of it because you don't like Avis and identify with this guy makes the problem worse. For the record, I approve of it because Avis would do exactly the same thing in his place, and does to their customers all of the time. I think Avis should be treated the way they treat others. It isn't because I dislike Avis, it is because I like to see equal treatment, and if Avis is treating people badly then they too deserve to be treated just as well (or not). If companies are flexible or show loyalty, I genuinely believe customers return that in kind. Look at Costco. This is not one of those companies. > Because now you've helped normalize exploitation as a behavior, and people inside Avis will feel just as justified in their bad behavior because they can see themselves as responding to "those awful scamming customers". Companies have already normalised the behaviour. So much so that we don't even talk about it anymore. In fact we teach kids that companies will try and exploit them if allowed, or take advantage of them, and then teach them a bunch of tricks to look out for when booking or buying (e.g. resort fees, baggage fees, location fees, un-included taxes, et al). It is laughable to suggest that this guy treating Avis just once like Avis treats their customers daily and for many years, has somehow caused Avis to act this way. You're clearly applying one set of standards to companies and a completely different set to individuals (i.e. effectively companies are beyond repute in your mental model, but individuals deserve your disdain for being as bad as companies even if occasionally).
- dlss 11y ago> That isn't "name calling". It's just naming. I see, fair enough. It was clearly wrong to assume you viewed his actions as either moral or immoral. > Avis [is] an amoral, predatory agent > Approving of it [...] makes the problem worse. > you've helped normalize exploitation as a behavior On second thought, I'm pretty sure "name calling" was spot-on. OP bought a good for the lowest price he could find. If you want to call that exploitation, more power to you, but please don't try to pass off your moral opinions as objective truths. It's slimy.
- wpietri 11y agoThat it is parasitic is factual. That parasitism is immoral is my opinion.
- dlss 11y agoProgress! Let's keep going. I think you meant to say "That it is parasitic is factual if I make a bunch of assumptions about AVIS' profit margin and intent, as well as OP's past and future business dealings with AVIS. That hypothetical parasitism is immoral is my opinion." As you get more practice making distinctions between what's true and what's opinion, I think you'll find it easier to interact with different viewpoints from your own :)
- wpietri 11y agoThere is no progress; my view has not changed. Nor will being anonymously snotty do a lot to change it.
- dlss 11y agoI didn't ask you to change your opinion, I merely asked you to become better at expressing it as such. Think of it like asking a Christian to say "X is what I believe" rather than "you're going to hell"... it's more respectful to other viewpoints :)
- 11y ago
- monksy 11y agoI'm not going to defend Avis, but all of the rental companies have tons of complaints. For some of the complaints Avis in the right. (There are people who treat rental cars as completely trashable) However, rental cars have a strong desire to completely disregard their customers. (Theres no sense of loyality, and they'll "find" damages that don't belong to you) The hilarious thing is that they're allowed to operate on airport property. (They have no flexibility in the way they operate to account for irrops or delays in travel for consumers)