4 ms·
Is the blackboard really disappearing, though? First, while there are some subtly-different affordances between a whiteboard and a blackboard, they're not that
by jerf 11y ago
Is the blackboard really disappearing, though? First, while there are some subtly-different affordances between a whiteboard and a blackboard, they're not that different. Second, where powerpoint and presentations and slides are making inroads are in places where the blackboard was already simply being used for slide delivery. A professor can get up in front of a 500-person class and say whatever words they like about how they want this to be an interactive experience, but it's still by-and-large a bulk slide dispensing class by necessity. (I say this as one of the lunatics who would participate even so, so yes, I know it's possible. But on average, 496 people are passively sitting there.)
Once you clear away the essentially non-interactive uses, is it really "disappearing"? Except for maybe a few whiteboards instead of blackboards, it's not going anywhere any time soon, I think. I've never seen a digital replacement that even comes close.
All the blackboards they show that are plausibly snapshots from real classes (as opposed to the three or four that are being used just a political polemics) would still be blackboard-based today, quite likely.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 11y agoI don't really see blackboards disappearing. They just evolved into dry erase boards, then smart boards. The successors are still blackboards in function and form, but they are just better, cleaner technology. Now, my blackboard can be viewed in different places and at different times.
- detaro 11y agoI've yet to see a board that actually is better. Different, yes, but not better.
- ssharp 11y agoIf a whiteboard can be accurately captured digitally, I'd say that it's better. However, I'm not sure a basic whiteboard is any better than a chalkboard. I also found it amusing at how often the whiteboard pens in a classroom did not work. That certainly isn't a problem with chalk. I also prefer the contrast of light writing on a dark surface over the opposite.
- detaro 11y agoWhiteboard + pen tracking might actually be great, yes, but I've yet to see that in practice. the projection-based "smart boards" are not that great.
- baldfat 11y agoThe boards that are 50" HD TVs are much better with a touch matrix in front of them. Brighter, cleaner and no burnt out bulbs. Black boards are still better for certain uses. Most "Smart Boards" are just Power Point players.
- protomyth 11y agoChalk is a bigger pain than markers. The dust can cause reactions with some folks and chalk breaks and runs out too (its just a little more obvious). We have some smart boards and they do pretty well. People do go a bit wild with color and shapes though, much like people in the 80's using every font in a document when they got a Mac.
- dubya 11y agoChalk is more economical for sure. In elementary schools, I believe teachers are now required to provide their own markers, so parents are asked to bring in a pack of Expo markers as additional supplies. I prefer chalkboards when I teach because no one else disposes of their empty whiteboard markers, so the tray slowly fills with useless hunks of plastic that look identical to the marker you set down. And whiteboard erasers get disgusting pretty quickly.
- strmpnk 11y agoThe chalk allergy is real but quite overstated. There are many people with reactions to the chemicals in whiteboard markers and the cleaner that many whiteboards require is even worse. I still see no mention of those, even though I've had problems with it myself.
- tjl 11y agoI know a bunch of people who prefer chalk because of the dust from whiteboard markers. They found it more of a pain than chalk dust. At least it cleans up pretty easily.
- andrewflnr 11y agoI have a professor who uses OneNote on his Surface. projected onto a screen. I'd say it works at least as well as a whiteboard. Scrolling helps a lot.
- baldfat 11y agoI went on a classroom tour at Princeton. I was there for a confrence of Librarians. On the tour there was construction happening in all the classrooms. Princeton removed all their white boards and replaced them with black boards. Reason the professors kept using permanent markers on them and the person in-charge replaced all of them that summer. (2007)
- bpyne 11y agoOur professors used markers on our smart boards. Very expensive mistakes.
- marak830 11y agoOuch, i use one of those at work, i shudder to think the shitstprm id start if i did that.
- LgWoodenBadger 11y agoAll you have to do is trace over the permanent marker with a dry-erase marker, and then erase. Comes off as if it was all dry-erase ink. Works on a variety of surfaces (I removed permanent marker from a stainless steel coffee mug that I inherited using this technique)
- gabeio 11y agoThis works amazingly well! I had accidentally left a black sharpie inside a pants pocket of mine, when it hit the dryer it burst from the heat and managed to be fairly evenly distributed inside the white dryer. Using a dry-erase marker it all came off! (I would not suggest trying it on anything that isn't a "shiny" surface ie: un-treated wood, cloth, etc.)
- selestify 11y agoIf it were software, this would definitely have merited a bug report.
- baldfat 11y ago
- nickysielicki 11y ago> Once you clear away the essentially non-interactive uses, is it really "disappearing"? Except for maybe a few whiteboards instead of blackboards, it's not going anywhere any time soon, I think. I've never seen a digital replacement that even comes close. Using powerpoint slides to set up the problem and then a microsoft surface to work through it is what one of my current professors does. It's amazing. I used to feel the same way you did, but it is going away. To be able to record this with his voice is what makes it special.
- monochromatic 11y agoI may be turning into an old fart, but I'll always prefer a blackboard for doing math. I'm not sure why, but whiteboards just feel... wrong.