5 ms·
I was hoping this was about the Blackboard software; some of the worst product I had the displeasure of working with in my life.
by tluyben2 11y ago
I was hoping this was about the Blackboard software; some of the worst product I had the displeasure of working with in my life.
- pathy 11y agoThis was my initial reaction as well but I was pleasantly surprised. This is a lot more interesting than any replacement software for BB.
- almightysmudge 11y agoEven the install is a mishmash of voodoo and arcane knowledge. Horrible horrible thing.
- danso 11y agoI came here just to say the same exact thing.
- hippich 11y agoA lot of issues were because of laws/policies required to install software on the premises... And making such complex software to perform well, when school sysadmin manages it, can be hard to make bulletproof. As laws and mindset changes, Blackboard moves to SaaS model with much more precise control over configuration, deployment, etc. As for software itself, if you are interested, google "new learning experience blackboard". This is 1 year old initiative to bring friendlier UI and as much as possible focus on student, instead of schools. And with acquisition of MyEdu there is push towards students owning their data, not schools. It is hard from both political (schools hate idea of not owning data) and technical standpoints, but we are slowly getting there :)
- jules 11y agoI just watched their promo video, and it's still terrible, but with a less ancient looking skin. Interesting how they can so completely miss the point.
- hippich 11y agoWould you mind explaining what is it missing? I work at Blackboard and would love to get honest feedback :)
- jordigh 11y agoBlackboard is institutionally bad. The company is rotten to the core. It's pushed onto universities and schools through bribery, corruption, and deceit. I have seen this first-hand at two different places. The admins choose because it looks enterprisey and expensive. They figure they've spent the money, so the problem is solved. They also frequently get some very nice kickbacks for accepting to buy this piece of crap. It's buggy, hard to use, horrible to modify, expensive. The most honest feedback I can get you is this: for your own moral rectitude, quit this job and find yourself a more ethical job.
- hippich 11y agoThanks for hateback, but i choose to stay. Otherwise if all good people leave, who going to develop good software? (because blackboard will not die even with bad software per your post :)) I will fix it from inside.
- jordigh 11y agoYou won't solve the problem as a software developer. It's not a software problem. Try to climb the ranks into management and weed out corruption as you see it.
- hippich 11y agoMe and other good devs will solve software side of problems, and other good people will fix managerial one :)
- gress 11y agoAre you saying that everyone in management and engineering had been replaced and Blackboard is essentially a startup which happens to have inherited all the exciting contracts? If so, then maybe you stand a chance. Otherwise, I'm sure you'll learn a lot from the attempt.
- vinceyuan 11y agoI am surprised to see the bad comments about Blackboard software. I never use it. But my ex-manager and several ex-colleagues (software developers and QA) are now working for Blackboard. They are confident in their company's future.
- hnal943 11y agoThat doesn't mean that they make good software.
- niels_olson 11y agoThat's because blackboard is a lot like Oracle they have more lawyers than programmers.
- megaman22 11y agoBlackboard has wicked lock-in, and contracts with the kinds of organizations that just keep paying their support and maintenance contracts for year after year after year. They could sit on their hands for the next half-decade and have a bright future.
- tdaltonc 11y agoI spent a lot of time a few years ago trying to build a BB replacement [0] that we ended up abandoning. Here's what I learned: The LMS (learning management system) sales decision in made by either the university administration or the office for information technology (using a checklist made by the administration). Neither of these groups have significant contact with the UX, so they don't really care about it. And the people that do have contact with the UX (teachers/students) all want different things, but have no way of having their concerns heard by the decision makers. One of the very important checklists items is that there be thorough documentation provided on how to preform every course relevant action. This is so that the computer illiterate art teacher can be hander a 500 page manual and be told that he now has no excuse not to use the LMS. This has the side effect of making UX improvement basically impossible, because the improvement would likely break the manual (that no one actually uses) and thereby violate the terms of the sale contract. From the perspective of a UX designer, working in this space has all of the downsides of designing for enterprise plus all of the downsides of designing for multiple user groups that all want different things. I really wish I had understood this when I started that project. EDIT: I got an email asking if there are any ways to make this market work from a designers perspective. One that I've seen work quite well is to borrow the textbook business model: Ignore the administration, cater to faculty, fuck the students. TopHat [1] has had a lot of success with this model. Just like with text books, a teacher deicides to use a tool, and then forces all of the students to pay for it. Your 2 users personas are tech-savvy teachers and college students. Both of these groups are prepared for frequent UX tweaks and UX improvements are rewarded with more repeat business instead of indifference. So it's a big win from a designers perspective. The business model is borderline immoral, but the more I learn about the higher ed market, the more convinced I become that it is the least bad option for operating in a very broken system. [0] http://rootlearn.com/ http://rootlearn.com/ [1] https://tophat.com/ https://tophat.com/
- arenaninja 11y agoAhhh yes. The joys of not being to make UX improvements because the manual already printed @_@
- jules 11y agoThe best option for Blackboard higher education is, IMO, fuck the decision makers, ignore the faculty, cater to the students. Let students edit all the info, faculty will get on board when they see students using it, decision makers want control when faculty and students are using it -> $$$. The reason is teachers only care about Blackboard insofar as they are forced to use it by the administration. They don't really get anything out of it. This is different than interactive lecture software like TopHat, which teachers like. Students on the other hand do get something out of a working Blackboard: they get info they want to see such as homework due dates, what to study for exams, homework help from other students, etc. Unlike with TopHat there is also a strong network effect necessary, which you would get out of focusing on students.
- ScottBurson 11y agoIn case anyone else is wondering, the comments are evidently referring to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackboard_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackboard_Inc. and not this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackboard_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackboard_system
- tmwh91 11y agoWe use this: https://www.learnium.com/about/ https://www.learnium.com/about/
- amyjess 11y agoI've encountered worse. When I was in college, we used WebCT. I'm fairly sure students could've written a better tool as a senior project. (edit: oh, hey, Blackboard bought WebCT a while back. Eww.)