4 ms·
One problem is what demographics futurists tend to be. White men are less likely to imagine a future with full gender equality and black liberation than black w
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
One problem is what demographics futurists tend to be. White men are less likely to imagine a future with full gender equality and black liberation than black women are, I would imagine. People living in the West will think less about the rise of the rest of the world.
- m0v_eax 11y agoUnnecessary generalizations..
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoUnnecessary? This is not a novel suggestion about the problems with futurists. It may be a generalisation, but it's pretty accurate generally. People privileged in some way aren't going to think much about that privilege. The rich won't envision a future with less (or more) poverty.
- stillsut 11y agoCheck out "The Other Foot" [0] by Ray Bradbury. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Illustrated_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Illustrated_Man
- m0v_eax 11y agoWhat data or study do you have to backup your baseless generalizations? It may be a generalisation, but it's pretty accurate generally. — [citation needed] The rich won't envision a future with less (or more) poverty. — [citation needed] White men are less likely to imagine a future with full gender equality and black liberation than black women are — [citation needed] People living in the West will think less about the rise of the rest of the world. — [citation needed]
- klagermkii 11y agoOr perhaps it's the reverse. If you ask "white men" about the liberation status of women/minorities, you're probably going to find them MORE likely to say that equality has already been achieved. So when they write stories, they'll write them as if everyone is equal and living the same utopian dream they are. On the other hand if someone comes from a background where they feel oppressed, they're going to write that into their work. That's part of the point of the article. People continue to extrapolate from what they view culture currently is, as if it continues indefinitely into the future. I think based on that "white men" are going to view it as being more pleasant and fair (i.e. their own experience) than minorities.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThat's true. People from oppressed groups are more pessimistic about the future. Or, well, pessimistic at all. One of the weird things about the post-war West is most people honestly expect the future to be better.
- ManFromUranus 11y agoWhy don't more non-white people become futurists then? Why don't they write their own stuff? If white people do something why is there the implication that they are simultaneously suppressing that output from everybody else? You know why you don't find more black futurists? My guess is they spend their time on anti-white rhetoric, and hypothesizing about fictional oppression. Frankly speaking, black people in the western world have it better off than almost everybody else. I'm really getting sick of reading these type of comments. Black people in the west have it better than black people in Africa. Where else but European countries, or North America would they be better off? Maybe if they spent more time DOING things and less time complaining about white people there would be more futurists/engineers/painters/doctors etc instead we have BlackLivesMatter doing die-in's in shopping malls or protesting the deaths of career criminals...
- drumdance 11y agoThis is a non-sequitur. The point is not "they should get their own futurists." It's that one particular perspective is often wrong.
- ManFromUranus 11y agoNon it's not a non-sequitur as I am not replying to the article but to another poster. My reply is relevant to theirs. The point of the article is that we get cultural changes wrong or don't account for changes in culture the way we anticipate changes in technology. The comment I am replying to makes racist generalizations about white people and what the white people and western world are able to imagine. I imagine if one goes to Thailand you would find media and cultural creations that relate to Thai people and their future, or in China the same thing, Chinese people and their future. Would the parent poster make a similar stupid comment about Chinese men can't imagine the future of women or black liberation?
- gress 11y agoSo your response was to write a comment filled with obviously racist invective attacking black people in general. Quote: "Maybe if they spent more time DOING things and less time complaining about white people there would be more futurists/engineers/painters/doctors etc instead we have BlackLivesMatter doing die-in's in shopping malls or protesting the deaths of career criminals..." Perhaps the original commenter is accidentally committing a subtle act of prejudice, but you are being overtly racist. Noting that the original commenter may or may not be black, Your choice to attack black people is independent of your concern about the potential prejudice in the original comment. At least this makes it clear where you stand; your comment was not about fighting prejudice.
- forgottenpass 11y agoI don't know that I can agree with this assessment. Large-scale social norms change always seem impossible N years before they become so ingrained to seem unshakable. So "impossible to imagine" strikes me as an uncharitable characterization. I can imagine that vegetarianism becomes a moral norm, and I can imagine how the change could happen, but that's entirely disconnected from my doubt it will happen. I also remember the time in my life when gay rights weren't the foregone conclusion they've been for the last 10 years. If we look at the distribution of shifting societal attitudes, there is going to be some threshold that turns things from "wishful thinking" to "probably going to happen." Without knowing what the information available at the time, and methodology used was generate the prediction, lying any blame at the feet of white/male/rich strikes me as applying a currently politically fashionable one size fits all explanation.