3 ms·
Flying cars have been part of science fiction since road-going cars and flight were a relative novelties, and the sentence in the original article is obviously
by notahacker 11y ago
Flying cars have been part of science fiction since road-going cars and flight were a relative novelties, and the sentence in the original article is obviously referring to flying cars "we predicted we would" quite some time ago. I don't think pointing out that fantastical views of the far future written in the nineties didn't place quite so much emphasis on them really contradicts his point.
On the contrary, I'm sure he'd argue that all the emphasis in more modern space operas like Banks' on the extent to which liberal civilisations with few other worries should impose their cultural norms on very different aliens is probably a reflection of contemporary preoccupations[1], much like the softer side of late nineteenth century proto-futurism was preoccupied with eugenics and utopian socialism, and by the early twentieth century it had become preoccupied with war and dystopian socialism.
It's not the most tightly-written article, but it's full of social as well as technological innovations missed by the last generation of futurists. We're a long way from the world of the Culture so it's not really the job of the author to identify exactly what that's missing, but I think it's fair to say that if we ever enter a spacefaring age, we might find even the most thought-provoking late twentieth century space opera to be more a reflection of contemporary liberal foreign policy concerns than a reflection of the biggest changes that have happened and challenges they face.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoLiberal foreign-policy concerns? Why does everyone always forget that the Culture are anarcho-communists?
- Kalium 11y agoProbably because the books are mainly concerned with how the Culture meddles with others to amuse themselves. And I'd say that they're only anarcho-communists in name. Really, they're ant farms, kept by the Minds.
- psb217 11y agoThe minds are the Culture and the minds are anarcho-communists (at least as far as I can tell).
- Kalium 11y agoEh... I'm not sure notions of government work at that level. The Minds don't need to work together in any way. They're each perfectly fine on their own.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>And I'd say that they're only anarcho-communists in name. Really, they're ant farms, kept by the Minds. People seem to get really butthurt about this, but it is actually series canon that much more thoroughly "posthuman" lifestyles were "in-fashion" at some previously point, and will be again, at some future point. The author was just focusing on the period of time that happened to be easiest to understand for his readership. And there are always those who make Unusual Life Choices. Oy.