5 ms·
Several of the commenters below the article do a pretty good job of pulling the article apart because its assumptions simply aren't very good even when faced wi
by notahacker 11y ago
Several of the commenters below the article do a pretty good job of pulling the article apart because its assumptions simply aren't very good even when faced with today's data (and in the case of aircraft efficiency, are simply wrong). It's so well established that growth in energy use and population have slowed sharply in the industrialised world, and that energy use per unit of real GDP is falling sharply that any argument based on the assumption of constant, exponential rates of growth that doesn't address these points is utterly facile. His assumption that "a certain, finite fraction" of the population must be engaged in agriculture also seems to overlook the fact that this fraction has fallen sharply over time, and has plenty of scope to continue doing so.
The assumptions fundamentally aren't reasonable; they're considerably less reasonable than Malthus' arguments that economic growth could never outpace population growth in the first place, which were at least written just before world per capita output started to accelerate.
If economics isn't a hard enough science, then getting physicists to do the theorising instead doesn't seem to be helping ;-)
- danbruc 11y agoThen just view it from a different angle - there is only a finite number of people on the planet, they have finite lifespans, they can only consume a finite amount of stuff.
- notahacker 11y agoA finite physical amount of stuff doesn't mean that people won't pay ever increasing amounts for stuff marketed as "better", which is all the growth that's needed for real economic growth patterns to continue, even if "better" requires the same or substantially less energy usage. It's probably a failure of imagination to assume that even the rich nearing the limits for stuff we want to consume too. The amount of GDP spent on healthcare is rocketing in developed nations, not all of that's all down to predatory companies and over-regulation, and it's perfectly rational for people to continue to spend ever-increasing amounts on factors which most significantly impact their quality of life. I also think we've barely scratched the service of what can be done there in future...
- danbruc 11y agoEconomic growth is not fundamentally measured in units of money and especially paying a larger amount for the same thing does not constitute economical growth. Adding an additional zero to all bills is just a rescaling of units, it has absolutely no substance.
- Retric 11y agoVideo video games are part of GDP when in game stuff can be sold. With player power inflation being a thing, GDP becomes unbound. Note this works even if computing resources stop increasing because introducing a blue ray gun that's better than the green Ray gun does not take more FLOPs.
- VLM 11y agoWouldn't the same level of rationality required to create and sustain that huge and complicated marketplace, when applied to a micro level prevent all the participants from wasting their lives trying to acquire blue ray guns?
- rwallace 11y agoIntuitively you would think so, but the world doesn't seem to work in accordance with our intuition.
- phkahler 11y ago>> video games are part of GDP when in game stuff can be sold. With player power inflation being a thing, GDP becomes unbound. I look forward to a future where most of the economy is optional and I can walk away from it and retire in complete comfort. Hint, we're getting there and if you're not building real wealth you're going to miss it and be FORCED to play video games to pay me rent on the physical world you take up space in.
- notahacker 11y agoLuckily, simply rescaling the bills is exactly what my post didn't propose. Buying Photoshop instead of using GIMP or Abercrombie instead of George consumes little or no more real resources, but by any regular measure of economic growth it's an increase in real output if people switch. Same applies to people buying shiny new Teslas that consume less real resources than the low-end Ford they used to drive. Or indeed, as I hinted I suspect will increasingly be the case in future, people spending sizeable proportions of their income on cures for chronic ailments that take an relatively trivial amount of energy to implement. Economic growth is fundamentally not measured in units of energy.