3 ms·
> I think the graph speaks for itself. That's never the case with data visualization. Explanation helps remove ambiguity, and the lack of explanation behind th
by minimaxir 11y ago
> I think the graph speaks for itself.
That's never the case with data visualization. Explanation helps remove ambiguity, and the lack of explanation behind the data source is why there is an excessive amount of criticism in the HN comments.
Regardless, the graph does not certainly speak for itself. There's no obvious correlation between which professions have a better gender pay split than others. If you're trying to make the point that most professions pay women less than men, then you need to justify that. (And provide evidence that the chart represents "most professions.")
- Kalium 11y agoPersonally, I've found that any time someone declares that a given visualization "speaks for itself" what they mean is that they want you to not ask questions about it. Occasionally this is justified, but more often it's a stunt of some sort.
- RA_Fisher 11y agoPRs welcome! The source code is here: https://github.com/statwonk/paygap https://github.com/statwonk/paygap
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 11y agoI appreciate the gesture. Unfortunately, statistics is not my strong suit and R is not a language I am familiar with. That said, did you consider the social and media context into which your work is being injected before you did so?
- gdix 11y ago"Here's some misinformation for everyone! Fix it for me or keep your comments to yourself."
- belorn 11y agoI am noticing that the pulled list of occupations and the generated output differed in size. Why is that? For example I would like to see the data for "Automotive Body and Related Repairers".
- RA_Fisher 11y agoThe difference are non-published values. Really wish we had raw surveys, but I do understand the ethical challenges BLS deals with.
- Pengwin 11y agoI have a feeling this graph is going to be reposted across various social medias with less context and incite more people spreading misinformation.
- RA_Fisher 11y agoThat most occupations pay women less than men is a fact, the graph is just a reformulation of this table: http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat39.htm http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat39.htm
- minimaxir 11y agoFacts do not absolve a data visualization from being potentially misleading.
- RA_Fisher 11y agoI'm sorry you feel that way. I sincerely find it very informative. Before I got first glimpse of it, I thought there would be at least 10-15 professions where women edged out men.
- Kalium 11y agoThis isn't just a feeling. The existence of phenomenon such as Simpson's Paradox mean that this is something that any data analysis must be very careful about. Presentations of aggregate data are particularly vulnerable.
- daenz 11y agoAbsolutely agreed. It's irresponsible to present incredibly nuanced data at such a shallow face value without making any attempt to show the full story, especially on such an incendiary and divisive topic. How is this helping clear up disinformation and progress gender wage gap dialogue?