4 ms·
It is always sad when I read this sort of screed. I can assure you that Universities are not a 'scam' in the general sense (and yes there are actual scams by so
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
It is always sad when I read this sort of screed. I can assure you that Universities are not a 'scam' in the general sense (and yes there are actual scams by some of them but it doesn't sound like Bristol is such a university).
There are three things a University/College education provides you -
1) Is a rapid exposure to many of the typical problems, techniques, and understanding of a particular major subject. Generally this is about 3x the rate you could get exposed to that in a work for hire situation. So for each year of college you end up exposed to the variety of problems it would have taken 3 years of on the job experience to get to.
2) The people who go to college constitute the majority of leaders in the community. It takes a while to realize this but as a young adult there are "the leaders" and "the followers", and the young adult is generally in the follower group. But over time folks move into the leader group and, by and large, those are the people you went to school with. So you are more naturally considered a part of that group.
3) A personal sense of what you can do, for many folks they reach a point where the requirements on them exceed their natural ability to "wing it"[1], and depending on how "smart" they were in high school this can come as a rude awakening. But once past it, people are much more mature about their skills and how to work at things. My experience has been that people who haven't gone to college rarely allow themselves to be pushed pass this wall as the other side is quite reasonably scary. Without the immovable force of 'you must do this or you will not graduate' the temptation to run away can be more powerful. Without that fundamental understanding of your abilities, and how to get more done than you think you can, often limits how successful you can be.
[1] Take things as they come and complete them without preparation.
- 1971genocide 11y agoI beg to differ. What is the expected salary of a MIT engineer ? Last time I checked it was 72,000 dollars per year. What is the typical tuition in MIT ? I do not remember the exact number but it would take a while before students are able to pay back the amount. For 4 years of study its more than 4 years to pay back - that is how I look at it. Its bad enough for home students and astronomical for international ones. Yes, there are some students who make it really big. But that is essentially a lottery and we should ignore them. The most useful skills I learnt were all self taught - as paul graham pointed out - if you put a bunch of motivated people in a closed chamber they will figure out get things. University life consisted of learning how to game the exams and not really learn anything of sustainable value. I knew that from high school and also what Paul wrote about education in general. But I didn't fully accept that our education system is so fundamentally broken. Lets put what you are saying in monetary prespective. 3x - while just working. so if you study for 3 years you get 9 years of experience ? But then you need to spend more than 3 years paying back the debt and you also were not able to earn anything during that time. And also there is no iterative improvement. you do not know how good you are until you have crossed the 3 years period. You might be terrible at your job and there is no way of knowing. The upfront cost and risk is too high for the expected outcome. Some people I know who are studying medicine spend until their 30 to finish. How is this sustainable ?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI realize I can't convince you, its part of what makes it sad for me. > The upfront cost and risk is too high for the > expected outcome. I understand this is your thesis but you don't have the data to actually argue it. And those who have done the research have come to a different conclusion than you have, so its a good place to start to understand what they considered relevant versus what you consider relevant. There has been a lot of work done on this so its easy to find papers and articles to read.
- 1971genocide 11y agoI completely understand what you mean - As Neil Degrass Tyson said - you cannot put a price on ignorance. But the argument I am making is the same argument that people make about healthcare cost. For example its hard to put a price on life but at the same time we need to be realistic. Also I think there is a stronger argument for fairness. If you consider me - with parents who were willing to pay for everything - vs students who are much more apt candidate but are unable to find the funding or get the loan. Do you think society should run like that ? I would hope the best candidate gets placement in all the top schools regardless of their socio-economical background. But all I noticed while in university are super rich kids. No one is arguing that average expected value over a lifetime for better higher education is positive when subtracted from the investment. But is that what it comes down to ? Do we want young people to waste their life's surplus produce paying back their debt ? Even besides those things - it seems there is increased financialization of education. Should we allow students to gamble with 6+ years of their best years. Obama famously finished paying back his student debt when he was in his 30s. Its not so much of question of net positives and net negatives in terms of pure monetary outcome. Its a question of what we want education to be - a public good or a private purchase like a car. Vacuuming out surplus produce from young people also means less new young business / startup / etc. Ben Bernarke is trying to understand why inflation is not rising - its simple, our generation has lost any faith in buying their own homes, cars or having more than 2 kids.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoOk, there are some interesting statements here that I would like to challenge. First there is this one: > If you consider me - with parents who were willing to > pay for everything - vs students who are much more apt > candidate but are unable to find the funding or get > the loan. This implies there are students "much more apt candidate" who are unable to get funded. But really there are two things here, one is getting into a college and the other is paying for it. In the US there are a lot of colleges, and in my personal experience I got into MIT but there was no financial aid available, and I also got into USC and they offered me a full scholarship. So I went to USC rather than MIT (my first choice). Four years of "in state" tuition, (tuition at a state school where you already live) is generally less than $30,000 which is the cost of a nice car. Graduate school it gets even better since you can often trade tuition for teaching the undergrads or a lab or two. Combining that knowledge with the experience of working with people from a wide variety of collegiate backgrounds and you will find that good people are good people, regardless of the status of the school they attended. What is more, smaller colleges tend to recruit people with similar values so when you find someone from a college who fits well with your company, chances are other people from that college will as well. > Do you think society should run like that ? And yes, it works as expected. Your statements seem to indicate that if you didn't go to a "good" school you can't get a "good" job, but in the STEM field that really isn't the case. And after you've worked for 3 years folks have a record of what you've done to start referring too and the pedigree of your school becomes less and less important as a discriminator. And if you go to graduate school (which can be cost neutral) you may find you "upgrade" your school pedigree. So this seems to be your key pain point -- > Do we want young people to waste their life's > surplus produce paying back their debt ? And it's a fallacy. We don't want students to feel like they have to go to a "top" school to succeed, because they don't. As a student you have a choice of schools from the very expensive to the very modestly priced. That is a healthy market. And there will always be people who will try to make a status symbol out of where they live or where they went to school Etc. But as you get older you will see that those "values" are entirely artificial. Five years from now you will look back and say, "Gee, I really could have gone to any school and arrived at this same point in my career." The cost of an undergraduate engineering degree in the US spans the range of $12,000 - $300,000. Everyone who graduates gets to be an engineer, depending on the size and influence of their school they may know people already in their chosen field. But I cannot find any examples of someone who was "held back" from their potential by graduating at a less well known school. I'm really sorry you got so little value out of the money your parents spent on your education. And I know how "real" your personal experience is relative to your world outlook. However, there are other experiences out there which are very very different than yours and they are very common. You will meet these people in the places you work, and the communities you visit. I'm hoping you will find it isn't as bad as you might think.