3 ms·
Stupid question: is this any differen from the "everyday" problem of information loss? That is, we know phase space is conserved, and yet, if you burn a piece o
by SilasX 11y ago
Stupid question: is this any differen from the "everyday" problem of information loss? That is, we know phase space is conserved, and yet, if you burn a piece of paper and mix up the ashes, you can't practically recover what was written on it.
Is there information loss (per the claim in the dispute) in a stronger sense for black holes? Is it a case where multiple start states map to the same final state, or just another case of in-practice irreversibility like in the burning paper example?
- akiselev 11y agoI am not a physicist but I believe it is similar in a superficial way. With a piece of parchment, the information is encoded based on the relative positions of molecules of ink and paper and if you use thermodynamically irreversible processes to decompose the constituent molecules you by definition lose any information encoded in higher layers of abstraction. The most fundamental piece of information is the identity of individual clumps of energy (subatomic particles). The reason black holes destroy information is that they are such an extreme environment that this identity no longer holds. Any energy, whether it is a photon or gluons making up a proton, that enters a black hole becomes a faceless part of the entire mass. Even if Hawking is correct and blackholes can radiate energy, anything they radiate will be made up of the same energy as the particles absorbed by the singularity but any information about what energy was before is entirely lost, as is any information stored in higher level patterns of that energy.
- reagency 11y agoThe article is saying that when an object is sucked into a black hole, all state information is squeezed back out in the form of vibrations. The brick wall analogy is very bad. It is more like flushing an object down a toilet: information about what it was is represented in variatons in the sound of the flush.
- richmarr 11y agoWhile from a human perspective information seems to be being destroyed, really it's just being obfuscated beyond our means of recovery. If you were to pause time, with enough analysis and knowledge of the present state of your burning parchment you could recover the state from a split-second prior to that. No-hair theory says that the event horizon of a black hole is different. One moment the information exists, the next moment it's just gone.
- akiselev 11y agoThis is a key point: recovery of the information requires some knowledge of time. If you were handed a pile of ashes (assuming ideal combustion of every molecule) you have zero chance of recovering any information but if you watched it burn, you can theoretically recover the initial state. Thats where the analogy breaks down with black holes: when a singularity absorbs a particle not only is any information about its identity lost, but also where it was in time. If you were to mix a bunch of ashes after watching several different documents burn you could still recover the initial state of each one but because of the extreme conditions in a singularity, even this basic axiom of cause and effect is no longer valid.
- SilasX 11y agoSo black holes really do shrink phase space, and it's not simply a matter of it being too computationally expensive to extract out "what went inside it" given the microstate of the black hole radiation?
- akiselev 11y agoYep. The big unanswered question as far as I know (from a layman's perspective) is whether the matter/energy in the singularity at the center of a black hole even follows the laws of nature as we have observe them or if all of that is out of the window past the event horizon. If you don't know the laws of nature describing what happens inside (and you can't study them due to the destructive nature of those forces), no amount of computation will be able to help.
- richmarr 11y ago> handed a pile of ashes... you have zero chance... I think I may disagree with you on the parchment, and think I agree with you on the singularity... but it's hard to tell for sure because we're all throwing half-cooked analogies around and it's been a long day. (disclaimer: I am a physicist)
- Qwertious 11y ago>you can't practically recover what was written on it. Keyword: Practically. In theory, the information is in the mixed up ashes though. Thus, the information is not lost, just scattered and made inconvenient. If you dropped the ashes in the black hole, the ashes would go into the same state as if you dropped ashes of a paper with different text on it - in other words, it's literally unrecoverable.