6 ms·
Ad hominem is used all the time by very smart people. Try getting a theoretician to look at a proof of a famous conjecture written by an unknown.
by amichail 17y ago
Ad hominem is used all the time by very smart people.
Try getting a theoretician to look at a proof of a famous conjecture written by an unknown.
- wgj 17y agoTry getting a theoretician to look at a proof of a famous conjecture written by an unknown. That was an intentional ad hominem for humor/effect?
- btilly 17y agoI strongly doubt it because it is a well-known phenomenon. If you're a well-known mathematician then you'll get a constant stream of "solutions" to famous math problems that are a waste of time to read. Sure, it is possible that you'll find the great solution in that pile. It is more likely that you'll figure it out yourself in the time you save by not wading through that junk. If you actually take the time to read and respond to the solutions it can get much worse. There are some well-known cranks who, once they get a sense that they have an audience, Will Not Stop Writing. There are famous exceptions to the rule. Ramanujan being the best known. However they are famous because they are so exceptional.
- elblanco 17y agoA person's reputation has a strong quality signal associated with it.
- bmm6o 17y ago"He hasn't produced good work before, so there's a good chance it won't be worth my time to read his proof" is an imperfect way of allocating limited resources, not an ad hominem attack.
- amichail 17y agoAn ad hominem attack is a way of saving resources. Theoreticians use it to save time and effort.
- bmm6o 17y ago> An ad hominem attack is a way of saving resources That they are both ways of saving resources does not mean they are the same in any other way (e.g. both "wrong"). Choosing not to read your proof is not the same as declaring that the proof must be flawed because you wrote it. You seem to have a particular instance of this behavior in mind. Not being familiar with it, I can only argue the general case. I'm sure your proof is actually quite good!
- andreyf 17y agoHow a theoretician decides where to spend is time is irrelevant. If, however, anyone were to criticize the proof by saying "it is written by an unknown", that would be an ad hominem criticism of the proof, and hence, invalid.
- amichail 17y agoWhen a theoretician refuses to look at a proof because it is written by an unknown, he/she is implicitly saying that the proof is very likely to be hopelessly wrong because it is written by an unknown.
- CodeMage 17y agoYes, you're right about that, but that still doesn't make it an "ad hominem" argument. When a theoretician refuses to look at a proof because it is written by an unknown, he/she is implicitly stating his or her belief that the proof is very likely to be wrong. In this case, this belief is used as part of criteria for allocating time and effort. If the same theoretician was to state that the proof is wrong because it was written by an unknown, this would constitute an argument. Said argument would be fallacious, because ad hominem argument is invalid in this case. Incidentally, your claim that "PageRank is the biggest ad hominem attack of all time" is false precisely because of this distinction. PageRank does not constitute an argument, it's simply a sorting criterion. It's a value produced by an algorithm to determine approximate relevance of a page within the context of a search query. The value itself does not constitute an argument. However, if I were to claim that "page such-and-such presents false information on such-and-such topic because it's PageRank is bad" that would constitute a fallacious argument. However, it would still not be "ad hominem". Now can you please repeating the same claim over and over in different comments? Repetition does not make it true.
- amichail 17y agoYou are splitting hairs. We don't need to stick to the precise dictionary meaning of various terms. Sometimes you gain more insight when you don't do that.