26 ms·
Essentially, a Land Value Tax is a property levy with exemptions for development. So let's say you buy a house, not because you are a speculator, but because y
by gaius 11y ago
Essentially, a Land Value Tax is a property levy with exemptions for development.
So let's say you buy a house, not because you are a speculator, but because you want a home. You live there for 50 years, raise your family there, and are enjoying your retirement. Someone over that time period, your property happens to become more valuable, as say a city expands.
Then along come some carpetbagger in a shiny suit and says, your home is not a "productive" use of this land, and he's going to tax you more than your pension is worth if you want to stay there, you should make room for his new development of "executive apartments" or whatever. No normal person would think that is just or right.
- jacobolus 11y agoThis scenario of yours is used to justify policies such as California’s Prop 13. But realistically, the primary beneficiaries aren’t retired middle-class homeowners on fixed incomes, but large corporations who own commercial property that now have their property taxes permanently frozen at 1970s levels, costing local governments huge amounts of money and encouraging poor land uses.
- shaftoe 11y agoI love when people pretend that money not taken in in taxes is lost money, as if the government has default claim to it and is missing out by not confiscating it.
- jacobolus 11y agoIn this case, the losers are local roads, public transit, public utilities, schools, police and fire departments, social services, emergency management, parks, libraries, museums, street sweeping, garbage collection, food inspectors, building inspectors, city planning, other city hall offices, election infrastructure, etc. Or, at the county level, judges and court officials, district attorneys, public defenders, the county sheriff’s office, county fire department, animal control, emergency rooms, county parks, public health officials, etc.
- gaius 11y agoIn this case, the losers are local officials FTFY.
- jacobolus 11y agoIn the kinds of places we’re talking about in this thread, dense urban areas where land is scarce and expensive, and extensive public infrastructure is required for basic survival, that’s pure horseshit. Go look up the budget for any city or county you like. You clearly aren’t interested in a respectful or intellectually honest discussion. Why are you here?
- gaius 11y ago"Clearly", eh, well we are all talking on a thread I started, no? This "corporations" thing that you have come up with is a completed red herring. A government exists to serve its people, not some abstract notion of "productivity". If it's your home and your property, why should you be forced to give it up so that someone else - be they a property developer, or a local government - can profit? Every transaction requires a seller as well as a buyer and if the seller doesn't want to sell for any reason then the deal is off. But your position is that people can be compelled to sell for what reason exactly?
- jacobolus 11y ago> your position is that people can be compelled to sell for what reason exactly Now you’re putting words in my mouth. I never advanced this position.
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoAn intellectually honest person could give serious consideration to your argument while also acknowledging the possibility that higher revenue to local government won't necessarily be used in ways the residents expect. Just look at the City of Bell scandal[1]. As it relates to your earlier comment "This scenario of yours is used to justify policies such as California’s Prop 13," you should consider that Prop 13, which amended the California constitution, was adopted overwhelmingly by voters in California in 1978. If Californians don't like it today, they can repeal or change it. That's how our system works. Why haven't Californians done away with or amended Prop 13? Polls consistently show that the majority of Californians continue to support Prop 13's limits and interestingly, even proposals that would eliminate Prop 13's tax treatment for non-residential properties are losing steam[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_Bell_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_Bell_scandal [1] http://www.latimes.com/local/political/la-me-ln-support-proposition-13-20150603-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/political/la-me-ln-support-prop...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIt's not pretending, it's truth. You never own your land; you're just renting it from the local government with ownership entailing a bit more control over what you can do while it's "yours".
- codingdave 11y agoBut so what? If you start to reject the concept of ownership, you may as well go one more step deeper, and realize that it is only held by the government via threat of force. Unless you are advocating for staging a revolution, you may as well just be a willing participant in society. You could even run for you local city council and become part of the decision making process for the government, being an active participant in it.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> You could even run for you local city council and become part of the decision making process for the government, being an active participant in it. This is the only way to ensure your goals or objectives are realized; constant vigilance.
- elektromekatron 11y agoEven basic ownership of small objects comes through force. Otherwise you'd drop them.
- HiYaBarbie 11y agoCute, but where would you draw the line? "You see, the government owns your car too, because you're driving on roads built by the government" "Oh but you see, clearly, based on the government deciding under what conditions you're allowed to leave the country, the government owns your body too, and is therefore within its rights to torture and kill you on a whim." Do you really see no problem at all with the idea that governments own everything and are just graciously "renting" things to us? Do you sincerely see nothing as your own legitimate property? When you buy a new phone, is that actually the government's property instead of yours?
- walshemj 11y agoWhere did gaius state or imply that his comment was related at all to commercial property
- jacobolus 11y agoHe didn’t: I was talking about Prop 13, which is not about land value taxes, but was sold to voters using an equivalent scenario as a rhetorical frame. However, the same is generally true for land value taxes. The people who stand to lose most from land value taxes are large land owners who for whatever reason are sitting on unimproved or under-improved property. Often, property just sits because the owner expects the value to continue rising, and wants to make sure to flip the property for as high a price as possible. There’s no pressure to immediately do anything useful with the property, so in extreme cases you end up with 50% parking lots. This image of Denver in the 70s would never occur with a proper land value tax: http://1p40p3gwj70rhpc423s8rzjaz.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Picture-11.png http://1p40p3gwj70rhpc423s8rzjaz.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-... A hard core libertarian might argue that all those property owners should have the right to build parking lots if they want to, and it’s nobody else’s business. In my opinion though, a city where blanketing downtown in parking lots is the rational behavior has a pathologically broken city planning / tax system. Yeah, it’s too bad that under a land value tax some individual homeowners who really like the tiny house they bought 40 years ago for $50,000 now need to sell it for $1,000,000 because they can’t afford the tax anymore. But these folks are actually pretty rare, and they just received a giant cash windfall, so they probably won’t get too much sympathy. If they really want to stay, they can surely take out a loan against the property, as evgen suggested. There are plenty of other folks in our society who get screwed much worse, and are more worthy of public attention and concern.
- walshemj 11y agoThere is more to the issue than local politics in California.
- HiYaBarbie 11y agoWhat's the connection between this: > A hard core libertarian might argue that all those property owners should have the right to build parking lots if they want to, and it’s nobody else’s business. .. And this: > In my opinion though, a city where blanketing downtown in parking lots is the rational behavior has a pathologically broken city planning / tax system. You might also want to consider whether a property owner would "blanket downtown in parking lots", if there were no reason to believe that would be a good investment. If someone makes a bad investment, that's his problem. If there are way too many parking spots operated by a private enterprise, some of them will be removed to make way for more productive uses of the land.
- evgen 11y agoSo since your home, which by your own admission is primarily a domicile and not an investment vehicle, is now worth more you can take out a loan based on the increase in value over what you paid for the house and use that to pay the additional taxes. You are being taxed on the appreciation in value to your home that you basically had nothing to do with and therefore have a very weak claim regarding a just right to this increase in value. tl;dr is "boo hoo, cry me a river"
- gaius 11y agoThat is clearly nonsense; why should anyone be forced to monetize their assets? The increase in value is entirely "on paper".
- imrehg 11y agoAs much as I understand, that "forced monetization" can exist, such as in the case of stock options - those can incur tax right away (alternative minimum tax), and usually will have to sell some of your just got stocks to be able to pay for that (if you don't have other assets to cover it). For example, point 2 at http://www.forbes.com/2010/03/10/10-tax-tips-stock-options-personal-finance-robert-wood.html http://www.forbes.com/2010/03/10/10-tax-tips-stock-options-p...
- walshemj 11y agoWell that is why the USA's laws on taxation of options need to be reformed.
- terryf 11y agoSo you're basically saying it's ok to tax people on gains, that are entirely theoretical and over which they had no control themselves? You might have a point if you consider a home something that is entirely fungible - but for a lot of people it is not.
- gaius 11y ago
- Spooky23 11y agoYou're missing the real root cause here, which is the deep subsidy of mortgages. Housing prices would be 1/3 of current levels without tax exemptions, direct loan subsidy and various guarantees. There should be limits on these things to prevent the type of situations we see in SFO, Boston, etc.
- gaius 11y agoThere hasn't been a mortgage tax exemption in the UK for decades.
- hanoz 11y agoBuy to let landlords have enjoyed 100% tax relief on mortgage interest for decades and only now, well in April 2017, are they finally about to start losing some of that unfair advantage over would be owner occupiers.
- gaius 11y agoI'm not sure that it is unfair - since if a landlord's property is empty, they are liable for the council tax on it. It's a risk/reward scenario. Consider a world with no landlords. You live with your parents until you can afford to buy, or you wait in line for social housing, which won't magically appear from nowhere...
- Spooky23 11y agoLand is a finite resource, always in demand. I have zero sympathy for rent-seekers, and the government shouldn't be subsidizing the value of their assets.
- collyw 11y agoAnd "emergency" low interest rates for 7 years or so. I imagine a fair fw of those would need to be sold if interest rates were at 5%.
- ktothemc 11y agoGaius, you could defer the payment of the tax until the sale so that the homeowner retains the right to stay there as long as they wish.
- gaius 11y agoWe have that already in this scenario; inheritance tax.