3 ms·
I don't see any reason to take the "so be it" comment of a defeated, distraught Hitler as a deeper expression of his philosophy than his proclamations of a "tho
by notahacker 11y ago
I don't see any reason to take the "so be it" comment of a defeated, distraught Hitler as a deeper expression of his philosophy than his proclamations of a "thousand year Reich" or the motor cars and holiday camps planned for a peaceful post-war Germany.
The other problem this theory has is that whilst the Jews have at various times been accused of conspiring to impose ideologies as conflicting as capitalism and communism, the notion that they were in fact responsible for maintaining the ideas of peace between nation states and love for ones neighbours is actually the polar opposite of the usual anti-Semitic narrative of them being destabilising, war-profiteering Christ-killers. Was Hitler's anti-Semitism that different from the anti-Semitism of his contemporaries, including many responsible for actually implementing his Holocaust?
Then again, I've always thought that attempts to "understand Hitler" in isolation from other expansionist military leaders might be missing the point. Hitler was exceptional in the number of simultaneous wars he managed to start and people he managed to kill (and unusual in his activities taking place in many living people's memory) but that seems to have as much to do with geography and technology as his worldview being more inherently destructive. The general mixture of personality cult, rigid organization of domestic society and accelerating expansionism and ethnic cleansing fits a pattern of empire builders that stretches back across millennia, as do other things. Indeed Hitler fits this pattern far better than most of the other butchers of the 20th century, not least when you consider his obsession with monumental architecture and fondness for Speer and his "theory of ruin value"[1].
The bigger cause for concern for humanity might be that many of these admired earlier empire builders - their victims dead in some cases for millennia - are as admired today as they were in Hitler's day.
[1]Of course Snyder can posit an alternative explanation for that last bit.
- emp_zealoth 11y agoExcept he wasn't exceptional when it came to killing, his contemporary, Stalin, beat him by a mile, not even counting excessively unnecessary manpower losses during the actual war. He caused a massive famine. Executed thousands, was an avid fan of various genocides. Deported hundreds of thousands of people to Siberia, which was more often than not just a more cruel death sentence. Decimated tens of thousands of polish intelligentsia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre Was plannig a massive war as well https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov%E2%80%93Ribbentrop_Pact https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov%E2%80%93Ribbentrop_P... One could pile it up. I find it rather mystifying that Hitler is the epitome of evil, when Stalin takes it all to next level