2 ms·
I do like that he is being honest about how historians think and reason. Start with the conclusion and then work backwards.
by danieltillett 11y ago
I do like that he is being honest about how historians think and reason. Start with the conclusion and then work backwards.
- pron 11y ago> Start with the conclusion and then work backwards. That's just not true (I studied history in graduate school). It is true, however, that sometimes you look at the facts and a certain pattern emerges, and you then go back to find further evidence for that pattern. But you full-well realize that you're by no means providing an absolute and complete model of reality -- just an aspect of it. The reason is that in a complex system, it's very hard to build models that are both "predictive" and descriptive. So you settle for an approximation, with the assumption that your readers understand it as such. Few historians claim that their model is complete.