4 ms·
> Or changing employee referral networks. When I ask if companies have employee referral networks, most say yes. But if I ask whether they’d have a structure fo
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> Or changing employee referral networks. When I ask if companies have employee referral networks, most say yes. But if I ask whether they’d have a structure for referrals of underrepresented groups, people often think that’s discriminatory and unfair.
Because it is. You can only remove bias by removing bias, not by introducing counter-bias. Removing names from resumes works, imposing quotas doesn't.
The problem with trying to counter bias with bias is that you can't make a shift on one axis without affecting five others. A bias in favor of e.g. racial minorities exacerbates the bias against everyone else of an underrepresented sex, economic status, religious minority, country of origin, disability, etc. But trying to enumerate all of the underrepresented groups is not only impossible because there are innumerably many of them, it leads to tokenism. Get yourself a couple of employees who each check multiple boxes and the numbers look good even when most of your employees are still white or asian male christian americans from middle class families.
By contrast, the bias in referral networks is the status quo. Hiring the people your existing employees know doesn't make a lack of diversity worse in any direction, it only fails to improve it by making future employees look like current employees. In theory there is an argument that when the status quo is unbalanced, anything that continues the status quo is also unbalanced, but that doesn't actually point to any solution. The status quo is the continuation of the status quo. Figuring out what will make positive change takes more than objecting to things that make no change.
And one way or another you still have to get 'em while they're young.
- kelukelugames 11y agoI agree with your criticism of affirmative action. The last company I worked at had a strong Women in Tech program, but one of the women of color described it as "white feminism." The company favored one axis, which was enough for it to become self-congratulatory. But I don't think this quote is about quotas. At least not quotas for employment. The program is merely for getting resumes of underrepresented groups. If the employee referral network only produces resumes from homogenous candidates then this is a positive change.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> But I don't think this quote is about quotas. At least not quotas for employment. Quotas for resumes don't in principle work any differently than quotas for hiring. And I still don't see how that solves the pipeline problem. The problem in 1950 was that middle class jobs were unavailable to qualified women and minorities. The problem in tech in 2015 is that qualified women and minorities are unavailable to middle class jobs. You can't solve it in the same way because it isn't the same problem.
- kelukelugames 11y agoYour principles are different from mine. And if you believe the pipeline is the only problem then our principles are irreconcilably different. Of course you are right that this doesn't solve the pipeline problem. No single thing can. At least it gets the company to interview someone they normally wouldn't. I can't find the link now, but the EEOC gives an example. If a company only hires by referrals and all of the candidates are Mexican because all of the employees are Mexican then that is discriminatory.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Your principles are different from mine. Then state what they are so we can figure out why. > And if you believe the pipeline is the only problem then our principles are irreconcilably different. There is a difference between a problem being the only problem and being the biggest problem. Amdahl's law. You can't fix more of the problem than the thing you're changing represents. The pipeline problem is not the entire problem but it's a huge proportion of it. It's the sine qua non of fixing the overall problem. Without addressing it you're just rearranging the deck chairs. > Of course you are right that this doesn't solve the pipeline problem. No single thing can. It isn't that it doesn't solve it, it's that it hardly even addresses it. By the time you're at the interviewing stage you're already at the end of the pipeline. > At least it gets the company to interview someone they normally wouldn't. Do the math on this. There are nine overrepresented candidates for every underrepresented candidate and you would normally interview five people. Now everybody decides to make the fifth candidate the underrepresented candidate. The underrepresented candidate would have to do ~twice as many interviews to allow all the employers to make their quota but can still only be employed by one of them. The only way this even does anything other than waste everybody's time doing interviews at companies where the underrepresented candidate won't end up working anyway is if in the alternative the underrepresented candidate wouldn't have found employment in the industry. But the demand for programmers is such that if you're qualified you can almost always find work. It's a solution aimed at a very small corner of the problem that rarely occurs, but has significant costs because everyone ends up doing many fruitless interviews when they could be interviewing candidates more likely to actually work there. > I can't find the link now, but the EEOC gives an example. If a company only hires by referrals and all of the candidates are Mexican because all of the employees are Mexican then that is discriminatory. Now you're talking about a different scenario where the makeup of the existing employees differs from the makeup of the overall pool of qualified applicants, both the employees and the referred candidates are completely homogenous, and the company hires only by referrals. That scenario is a completely different kind of problem. It's an internal company problem vs. the industry-wide problem we have in tech. The internal company problem is easily solved by considering candidates from the broader pool of qualified applicants. The industry-wide problem is not helped by that at all because the skew is present in even the broadest pool of qualified applicants.