3 ms·
Every other country on the planet have lower health care costs than the US by a large margin. US public healthcare spending alone, excluding private payments a
by vidarh 11y ago
Every other country on the planet have lower health care costs than the US by a large margin.
US public healthcare spending alone, excluding private payments and insurance, places the US in the top 20, possibly top 10, in government spending on healthcare.
In other words, Americans pay more than citizens of most developed countries over their taxes, and then pay about the same again to private insurers...
- rational-future 11y agoThat's an interesting argument, but it misses the fact that the US is effectively subsidizing the healthcare in the rest of the world.
- dragonwriter 11y agoEven if that's true -- and people asserting that never support it -- I don't see what the point of that is in defense of the status quo US policy. If that is the reason that Americans are paying so much more for healthcare and not getting any more benefits, it would be better for Americans if the US stopped doing that.
- lmm 11y agoIf the US stopped doing that there's no reason to assume that another country would magically step up to the plate. What if, as is the point of the article, the US stopped doing that and the world simply stopped getting as many new drugs?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If the US stopped doing that there's no reason to assume that another country would magically step up to the plate. Another country, no, because that would be irrational and stupid (just as it would be for the US, if the argument atht the US is actually doing that is correct.) On the other hand, if the US is subsidizing the rest of the world, that means the US is substantially reducing the marginal benefit of expenditures in the subsidized domain by other countries, disincentivizing their own expenditures (direct or through policy which promotes drug development.) It would be irrational to expect the removal of that subsidy and the associate disincetives not to result in increased expenditures.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Every other country on the planet have lower health care costs than the US by a large margin. To put it in concrete terms, of OECD countries (comparable non-OECD data is harder to get), the #2 country in per capita healthcare spending (Switzerland) spends about 72% of what the US does per capita. > US public healthcare spending alone, excluding private payments and insurance, places the US in the top 20, possibly top 10, in government spending on healthcare. Again, to provide some concrete numbers, in the OECD, the US is #3 (behind Norway and Netherlands) in per capita public healthcare spending. It also has the second highest proportion (52%, just barely behind Chile) of total healthcare expenses that are private, rather than public.
- hugh4 11y agoThis is true, but on the other hand the US does have a much higher standard of care. In my experiences with the US hospital system I've been shocked by the way every single town seems to have all the fanciest, newest equipment. A scan that you'd wait days for in Australia you can get on the spot in the US. That money is going somewhere.
- DanBC 11y ago> That money is going somewhere. A lot of it is going on over diagnosing and over treating, both of which cause harm. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unnecessary_health_care https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unnecessary_health_care
- fredkbloggs 11y agoSo you're agreeing at least in part with my original assertion, then. Namely, that we probably need to be less willing to pay high prices for drugs (and by extension other treatments) because in many cases they are of much less value than other things we could buy instead. Right? I mean, overtreatment has negative value, so it's hard not to imagine that what was paid for it couldn't have been better spent on something else. Anything else. Throwing the money into a fire would have provided more value.
- specialist 11y agoNo. Over testing and over treatment is unrelated to the (initial) high price of drugs and other treatments.
- beagle3 11y agoJust this week I got a 2-month wait from a US hospital for a scan I got a 1-month delay outside the US. And that's a major, top ten US hospital, not some dinky place no one has heard of (but it's a non-standard scan setting, I'll grant you that). And the out-of-pocket (despite having insurance) is almost as high as the entire scan if I did it privately in the other place (which I pay zero for - it's all covered) > That money is going somewhere. Mostly to the pockets of the health insurance companies, which rake in ridiculous profits for providing services which are essentially non-existent and not needed almost anywhere else in the world.