4 ms·
Actually, I think the real problem is that H1Bs are given out via a queue rather than an auction. With a queue, there is no incentive to note apply for H1B's.
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Actually, I think the real problem is that H1Bs are given out via a queue rather than an auction.
With a queue, there is no incentive to note apply for H1B's. Do the paperwork, you get someone to fill some position (often cheaper than a recruiter). With an auction, H1Bs will be given out to the employers who value the employee most highly rather than simply a random selection of whoever got their application in by Jan 1.
As for job mobility, I think requiring the new company to pay off the pro-rated auction cost to the old company is fair (i.e., 1.5 years into a 3 year visa, new company pays old company for half the visa cost).
- btilly 17y agoI like the auction idea in principle. However the devil is in the unintended consequences of the details. If you transfer the auction cost around then you've effectively made an H-1B into a regular employee, part of whose salary gets paid to the government. This encourages underpaying H-1Bs relative to local competition, and as long as there is a significant market of low paid skilled people you're putting large downward pressures on American salaries. The version I suggested gives incentives to bring in good people, but also provides market incentives to pay competitive salaries to anyone who is brought in.
- anamax 17y ago> However the devil is in the unintended consequences of the details. If you transfer the auction cost around then you've effectively made an H-1B into a regular employee, part of whose salary gets paid to the government. This encourages underpaying H-1Bs relative to local competition, Nope. You forgot the money being paid to the govt. That increases the costs to the company, which is the number that they care about. If the auction price is reasonably high, that pretty much guarantees that H1Bs will not be used for low-wage occupations. Suppose that the auction price is $100k. If the going rate for a particular job is $120k, no company is going to hire an H1B for more than $20k. Even if said company finds someone for $15k, the cost to the company is only $5k below market. If they find someone for $30k, that's like paying a not-H1B $130k.
- btilly 17y ago>> However the devil is in the unintended consequences of the details. If you transfer the auction cost around then you've effectively made an H-1B into a regular employee, part of whose salary gets paid to the government. This encourages underpaying H-1Bs relative to local competition, > Nope. You forgot the money being paid to the govt. That increases the costs to the company, which is the number that they care about. Read more carefully. I did not forget the money being paid to the government. Instead I was describing a net effect where employers would keep their internal cost the same and drop the salary offering by the amount of the fee. The net result is then exactly that part of what would have been the H1B's salary goes to the government instead. By contrast if the fee is only owed by the original employer then any subsequent employer can offer the same salary that they would for a local and have the same total cost for the employee. Market pressures will push them to do that. This will push the original employer to pay prevailing market rates or better to keep the employee around long enough to recoup their initial investment.
- anamax 17y ago> Read more carefully. I did not forget the money being paid to the government. Instead I was describing a net effect and ignoring the H1B holder, which is why I provided an example. Very few H1B holders who have skills that a US company values at $120k will take a job for $20k without some angle. You suggest one such angle, namely that such employees go to another employer who doesn't pay the fee to govt, and suggest that original employers will therefore pay more to avoid losing the benefit from paying the fee. Let's extend that example. Suppose that it takes $100k/year to keep an H1B holder from jumping ship. Add that to the $100k fee and that employee costs the original employer $200k. Since the agreed-on market rate for that job was $120k, the original employer isn't going to pay $100k year. Instead, they'll avoid the risk of losing the $100k fee and hire locally. That's why the fee will discourage H1Bs for low-wage jobs. If the fee is paid by all employers (and presumably refunded when an H1B jumps ship), there's no poaching bonus so every employer is essentially the first employer.
- btilly 17y ago