4 ms·
All this is good and fine, except darn near every other nation already fixes drug prices in one way or another, forcing the US to bear the costs of drug R&D. C
by alistairSH 11y ago
All this is good and fine, except darn near every other nation already fixes drug prices in one way or another, forcing the US to bear the costs of drug R&D.
Couple that with market forces in the US that prevent a text-book "fair"/"functioning" free market, and we (American consumers) get stuck with prices that are not just mind-bogglingly high, but also much higher than consumers in other 1st world nations pay.
- DanBC 11y agoDo you have a reliable source for your claim that the US bears the cost for R&D? (And this question is aimed only at alistairSH)
- melling 11y agoWhy only for alistairSH? We're a hive with collective intelligence that just wants the truth. :-) Search for the words "Much of the development cost of a new drug is paid by the US market" http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/03/15/drug-dealing-free-markets-and-price-fixing-just-dont-work-together/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/03/15/drug-deal...
- DanBC 11y ago> Why only for alistairSH? Because I'm interested to know if alistairSH knows what they're talking about or are merely parroting the same bullshit everyone else does. The op-ed you link to again parrots this, but does nothing to source it. Alternative explanations (US insurance companies keep the money) aren't explored.
- melling 11y agoProving that would be difficult because you can't track the money. The U.S. does pay more for whatever reason. Personally, I'd like to see countries like India and China, with a combined 2.5 billion people, invest in more drug research. A lot more competition can only help with prices, and more drug research.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoFreelance libertarian bloggers aren't generally considered a good source. A quote from your man: "I'm one of those classical liberal types with the libertarian mindset that sees the carbon-cutters as, in general, authoritarian, super-statist, quasi-socialist conspirators intent on bossing people around and interfering with their lives and liberties. Having confessed, I'm now going to prove that it's true, that it's not just my belief but a true reflection of the world"
- Frondo 11y agoWhat? You mean we shouldn't start with belief, and set out to prove it? What are the libertarians supposed to do now?
- shoyer 11y agoThis is a well known fact in the pharmaceuticals industry. For example, here's an article by the Chief Medical Officer of Merck in the Harvard Business Review. It took me all of 10 seconds to find on Google: https://hbr.org/2014/11/the-real-cost-of-high-priced-drugs https://hbr.org/2014/11/the-real-cost-of-high-priced-drugs
- DanBC 11y agoThe point isn't whether it's easy to find in Google but whether people are merely repeating what they've already heard. Again, this link merely repeats the claim but does not spurce it. Yes, it's very easy to find people saying the US pays more for meds; and that this extra money is used by drug companies on R&D. But none of these people source their information.
- specialist 11y agoThe notion of free markets sounds interesting. Can you point to a real world example?
- alistairSH 11y agoA real world example of a text-book market? No. That was the point. :) I frequently hear conservatives claim they want a "free market" solution to medical care - I don't think people who make that claim know how far from a free market we are.