3 ms·
Useful to you != useful to others. That kind of generalization does no good. These companies don't have billions of users because they produce nothing of value
by manigandham 11y ago
Useful to you != useful to others. That kind of generalization does no good.
These companies don't have billions of users because they produce nothing of value.
If that value exchange doesn't work for you, just stop using it. But these strange posts about "slavery" and "liberties" just seem out of place. It's a corporation, like any other. What are you expecting?
- afarrell 11y agoYour second sentence isn't strictly shown to be true. Heroin has millions of users, but would you argue it provides value to people's lives?
- manigandham 11y agoIf you're going to bring it down to that kind of strange technicality then yes - those people are using it because it provides them value in whatever form. It's not up to you to judge what that value is and whether you think it's good for them.
- UnquietTinkerer 11y agoThis is just playing games with microeconomic terms. However you choose to define "value", using heroin is self-destructive and usually (always?) irrational. If you choose to include that kind of behavior in your definition of value then the word loses most of its useful connotations.
- manigandham 11y agoNo it doesn't - because that's the definition of "value". Anything beyond that is your subjective interpretation.
- adamlett 11y agoIt absolutely does provide value. Many (ab)users of illegal substances use them to provide relief from the emotional pain of traumatic experiences or mental illnesses.
- yuvadam 11y agoYou might not like to hear this perspective, but that doesn't make it any less true. Many corporations produce lots of value that is based on corrupt moral values: from companies doing arms sales in third-world countries (i.e. profiting from destruction and death in impoverished areas of the globe) to corporations selling animals parts as products (i.e. profiting from the ownership and abuse of sentient beings). I'm not directly comparing Google to other truly evil corporations, but I will damn right call out ethically and morally flawed business models when I see them.
- manigandham 11y agoMorals are a personal thing, not innate to a corporation but rather your subjective filter for the world. What you might consider moral, others can find opposite. Regarding ethics: There is nothing ethically flawed about what Google is doing. They aren't selling arms or abusing animals so where does this line get crossed for you? They are in it for profit and can provide many of these services for free through advertising. Necessarily this requires an exchange of your general data profile for all the utility of their tools. If you pay them directly, then the privacy rules are different (as it works with many such corporations). And you might not like to hear this perspective - but many really don't care. People share data about themselves at an exponential rate because the experience of sharing and the utility of the companies outweighs other concerns. But you are perfectly free to go do your own thing. There's no secret Google police out to get you. You are not revealing some big conspiracy here, it's a well-understood exchange and many are just fine with it and many like you aren't. And it's all ok.
- yuvadam 11y ago... except for when it's not all ok. It's not ok for a private corporation to play by its own rules and have total control over digital identities, about how you get presented online, about if you are or aren't allowed to be forgotten, about which speech is acceptable and which isn't (hint: when it doesn't line up with the corporations agenda). Monopolies are a market failure - capitalism says this very clearly. In the case of data behemoths, I fear we are losing more than just some extra $$$ each month, but some of the core liberties that make up how current modern societies functions. As you mentioned yourself, I am far from being the only one who notices this problem.