4 ms·
This article leaves out some important things. Google making the project non-profit would not have saved them from the lawsuit. The Author's Guild, separately
by jrochkind1 11y ago
This article leaves out some important things.
Google making the project non-profit would not have saved them from the lawsuit. The Author's Guild, separately, sued a non-profit partner in the Google Books scanning project -- HathiTrust. [1]
That lawsuit was not resolved until 2012 -- when, without a settlement, HathiTrust won on fair use.
The court decided that scanning books for searching was fair use. While the court did not say the same for displaying full text -- what the OP wants -- it is notable that the court's opinion was not primarily based on non-profit status of the organization (as is common in U.S. fair use case law; the non-profit factor has generally dwindled in court decision-making), but on transformativeness.
The OP mentions "Others argued that the settlement could create a monopoly in online, out-of-print books," but gives that opinion rather short shrift. This was a very real concern -- what if Google's use really would be fair use? If the court decided that, the opinion would apply as precedent to everyone. But a settlement really does apply only to Google -- no one else even had access to the terms of the settlement. Anyone else trying to do the same would risk being subject to a decade-long lawsuit of their own.
The OP should ask, why didn't Google go to trial?
"If Google was, in truth, motivated by the highest ideals of service to the public...." they should have gone to trial to establish the right for all. As HathiTrust did.
The Google Books project still exists, they did not take it down because of legal worries, even in the absence of the settlement. But it has indeed been allowed to languish. While I'm sure the multi-year lawsuit contributed to this -- Google starting ambitious projects and then allowing them to languish, without improvement, without fulfilling their original promise, slowly degrading and withering away -- is a pretty common Google practice even without multi-year lawsuits.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild,_Inc._v._HathiTrust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild,_Inc._v._HathiTr...
- magicalist 11y ago> Google making the project non-profit would not have saved them from the lawsuit. The Author's Guild, separately, sued a non-profit partner in the Google Books scanning project -- HathiTrust. > That lawsuit was not resolved until 2012 -- when, without a settlement, HathiTrust won on fair use. I think you're mixed up on some things. HathiTrust wasn't sued until after the settlement was rejected, meaning Google was getting sued simultaneously. It is good the original settlement was rejected, though I agree with the author that a modification to the settlement, similar to what the Internet Archive was asking for, was a much better solution than another decade of court battles and no orphan works for another century. > The OP should ask, why didn't Google go to trial? Google did go and the district court ruled that scanning, searching and snippets were fair use in 2013[1]. The case is still ongoing, the Second Circuit heard arguments last December[2] [1] https://www.publicknowledge.org/files/google%20summary%20judgment%20final.pdf https://www.publicknowledge.org/files/google%20summary%20jud... [2] https://www.eff.org/cases/authors-guild-v-google-part-ii-fair-use-proceedings https://www.eff.org/cases/authors-guild-v-google-part-ii-fai...
- jrochkind1 11y agoah, thanks!