6 ms·
From my point of view the whole H-1B process is a mess. What it boils down to is that companies are given the opportunity to hire foreigners who are used to mu
by btilly 17y ago
From my point of view the whole H-1B process is a mess.
What it boils down to is that companies are given the opportunity to hire foreigners who are used to much lower salaries under conditions where said foreigners will have lower job mobility. This means that companies have every incentive to hire people more cheaply than they can hire locals. But in order to do so they have to put up a pretense of having tried to hire an American and have to swear up and down that they can't find an American to hire.
In short we're putting pressure on companies to lie and everyone knows it. However it is difficult to demonstrate whether any given company has, and it is very much not in their interest to let accusations of it stand. Is there any wonder that we get conflict over this?
What I would prefer instead is a simple market based solution. Any company wishing to hire a foreigner can upon posting a bond for that foreigner. (To cover expenses if that foreigner poses a problem.) The foreigner has no obligation to their employer - if the foreigner wishes to leave a week after arriving for a better job they are free to, but the original company still is liable for the bond.
Under that system companies have no obligation to claim that they looked for a local. However they have a clear incentive not to hire foreigners. Any company that hires a foreigner regardless is demonstrating by their action that either this foreigner is exceptionally valuable (and therefore is a good addition to the USA economy) or else that there really is a lack of available locals to do this job.
- euroclydon 17y agoA bond, hmmm, well if the bond automatically went into the bank account of the local immigration attorney, this idea might stand a chance.
- pierrefar 17y agoA much better way are the points based systems found in Australia, Canada, and the UK. The details vary but it works like this: the government creates a system where each candidate is scored against. The final score needs to be higher than a threshold for the candidate to be granted a work permit and residency visa. The government decides what to score based on its idea of what's a useful addition to the economy. In the UK these include the highest degree earned, the last 12 months' earnings (weighted by country of earnings), English proficiency, etc. It also can add bonus points to professions it wants to attract - say nurses or doctors. The UK used to give automatic full points to an MBA holder under the HSMP visa scheme! PhDs didn't get this red carpet.
- anamax 17y ago> A much better way are the points based systems found in Australia, Canada, and the UK. The US has a points-based immigration classification. It's pretty much a disaster. I have no idea how well UK et all run their points based schemes, but it doesn't actually matter. The relevant question when proposing one for the US is how well the US would run one. Maybe this time would be different but....
- olegk 17y agoMy friend on H1B makes $80/hr, so not all of them are "cheap".
- btilly 17y agoNo, not all are cheap. The more interesting question is what a comparable skillset in an American would cost. For a random web developer, $80/hr seems high. It would be low for an experienced DBA. Furthermore the fact that companies have incentives to abuse the system doesn't mean that companies do abuse the system. Your friend may be a fairly treated example. But his existence doesn't change the fact that many cases exist where the system is abused.
- lhuang 17y agoTrue but most foreigners view the H1B as the first step to getting a green card - something highly highly desirable among the scores of white collar foreigners working in the US. From my experiences, I know quite a few who after getting their H1B feel "locked" down with the company that hired them. This in turn allows the company to abuse the shit out of them because they know that the only option for most of these people, especially in the current economic climate, is to stfu and keep on taking the abuse lest they want to return back to sweatshop call centers with 1/10th the pay. Then these guys get further screwed when it comes to the annual review & promotion process when their american counterparts (i.e. white males w/o fobby accents) get bumped ahead of them. A blanket statement for sure; I realize there are more nuances to this but Ive seen it happen ALL-THE-TIME.
- hga 17y agoPlenty of them are. Here's a datapoint I can contribute: Lucent in 2001 (yes, a very bad time). I'm 40 (although I look like I'm in my early 20s), making $80K. My best coworker is a brilliant native of a Caribbean island; he got a EE from a respectable US university and was getting his Masters at night (showed me his MOSIS chip at one point). For the job we're doing, in his own areas he's as competent and productive as I am. Immigration law requires the company to post his salary; he's making $45K. If he was just getting paid what I was at my second job, the first one at a market rate, he'd be getting $63K (that's adjusted for inflation, but you should subtract some for higher health care costs (they've risen faster than CPI inflation)) and he'd be worth every penny. He knew he was being exploited and wasn't happy about it, but it was useful experience and a good path to a Green Card, at least when he signed on (Lucent of course continued its decline and canceled the project we were working on, which was important enough that it canceled their future as well). The near indentured servitude aspect of the H1-B system is reason enough to seriously reform it ... but as noted, the necessary docility of those who have one is too attractive to too many companies.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoActually, I think the real problem is that H1Bs are given out via a queue rather than an auction. With a queue, there is no incentive to note apply for H1B's. Do the paperwork, you get someone to fill some position (often cheaper than a recruiter). With an auction, H1Bs will be given out to the employers who value the employee most highly rather than simply a random selection of whoever got their application in by Jan 1. As for job mobility, I think requiring the new company to pay off the pro-rated auction cost to the old company is fair (i.e., 1.5 years into a 3 year visa, new company pays old company for half the visa cost).
- btilly 17y agoI like the auction idea in principle. However the devil is in the unintended consequences of the details. If you transfer the auction cost around then you've effectively made an H-1B into a regular employee, part of whose salary gets paid to the government. This encourages underpaying H-1Bs relative to local competition, and as long as there is a significant market of low paid skilled people you're putting large downward pressures on American salaries. The version I suggested gives incentives to bring in good people, but also provides market incentives to pay competitive salaries to anyone who is brought in.
- anamax 17y ago> However the devil is in the unintended consequences of the details. If you transfer the auction cost around then you've effectively made an H-1B into a regular employee, part of whose salary gets paid to the government. This encourages underpaying H-1Bs relative to local competition, Nope. You forgot the money being paid to the govt. That increases the costs to the company, which is the number that they care about. If the auction price is reasonably high, that pretty much guarantees that H1Bs will not be used for low-wage occupations. Suppose that the auction price is $100k. If the going rate for a particular job is $120k, no company is going to hire an H1B for more than $20k. Even if said company finds someone for $15k, the cost to the company is only $5k below market. If they find someone for $30k, that's like paying a not-H1B $130k.
- 17y ago
- old-gregg 17y agoI disagree with a lot of what you said. First, the system is already "market-based solution": getting a visa for an employee isn't a rocket science. There's competition for good H1b talent. And H1b by itself isn't that strong of a chain that holds them hostage. Changing employers while on H1b is not terribly hard. Moreover, in my recruiting experience, you (as a company) have to compete pretty hard to get the best foreign CS grads - they know they're good and the fact that they need a visa after graduation doesn't make them less valuable. The shady part of H1b business is a bunch of "body shops" that bring in sub-par talent here (with poor english or/and poor technical skills) and abuse them until those workers improve their marketability on US job market and leave. In short, I see nothing wrong with the H1b system except for general slowness of the INS bureaucracy and poor enforcement of H1b abuse (just like with most immigrant-related laws, enforcement is a problem). Full disclaimer: I myself was employed on H1b by a 1-st tier US tech firm and saw absolutely no discrimination in salary or any other matter.
- btilly 17y agoYou are absolutely right that companies have the opportunity to bring in the best in the world as well as the opportunity to bring in people whose expectations are lower. We agree that the problem arises with the ones who go after people whose expectations are lower. My further opinion, which you might not share, is that those abuses are both widespread and problematic. And therefore I was focusing on that part of the issue. But you're right that I shouldn't tar all employers who hire H-1B people with the same brush. The solution I proposed is intended to address this by making resolving abuse cases resolvable by market pressures rather than government bureaucracy. Where the program works I absolutely want to see it continue. This country was built on immigrants, and I firmly believe that its ability to attract top talent worldwide is its greatest asset.
- rbanffy 17y agoThe auction idea is good, but there should also be some assurance companies don't get H1Bs for significantly less than the rate they would pay locals. H1B visas should never be used as cost-cutting mechanism. Perhaps a good one would be to fix the compensation of the H1B worker to the average local compensation for the same or comparable position. OTOH, that would probably drive some companies out of the US because all their competition is doing the same. One must measure the possible consequences carefully.