6 ms·
I have found the flat design incredibly difficult to use. In particular, the new Apple Music app was almost completely undiscoverable for me. It wasn't until I
by epistasis 11y ago
I have found the flat design incredibly difficult to use.
In particular, the new Apple Music app was almost completely undiscoverable for me. It wasn't until I was reading patch notes that I realized that it had a key feature that I had been searching the UI for more than a month. That feature was to show only the music available offline, and it's hidden behind a down arrow next to a heading label. (Rather than the ... that other menus have).
Apple has never been perfect at UIs, but they've always been better than this in my experience. Deciding to hide key information and be as cryptic as possible works great for designers that already know the UI, but it works terribly for users that are still learning it. This type of elementary mistake, all too common by those who are deep in the act of creation, is best corrected by stepping back from the problem and approaching everything with the mind of a beginner. That or giving the device to an outsider and observing them, good old fashioned trials.
That's what UX needs these days, not more fashionistas trying to remove data and UI cues. The industry needs a big wakeup call. Mobile and even the web (like Google Docs) are becoming a churn of bad experience.
- roymurdock 11y agoAgreed on the new iTunes and iPhone Music app. I had to re-learn how to shuffle songs, and how to pull up the album of the song that was playing the other day. Extremely non-intuitive and hidden behind 4-5 interactions. All for the sake of cramming in new paid features that I'll never use - "For You", "New", "Radio", and "Connect". Why Apple? You make enough money from iPhone sales already. Is Apple Radio really going to add that much to your bottom line?
- minthd 11y ago>> Is Apple Radio really going to add that much to your bottom line? They will try to use radio in 2 way: 1. Make it unqiue and hard to copy, to add one more reason for people to use their device. 2. When making content deals, it's hard to get good deals if you come without a large crowd of subscribers.So apple plan to to use your radio subscription as content negotiation tool, and than upsell you a tv service - and there's a lot of money there.
- bluedino 11y agoEvery iTunes is a mess. HOW THE HELL DO I GET BACK TO MY SONG LIST
- cheshire137 11y agoYou can make the 'Connect' button into something a little more useful. In the Settings app, go to General > Restrictions and turn off Apple Music Connect. The 'Connect' button will then be replaced with 'Playlists.'
- roymurdock 11y agoThanks for this great tip. Again, another totally non-intuitive way to make Music 10x better. Tangent: I wonder if people who work at Apple browse HN and see these kinds of complaints regularly? It would be weird to work at a big company that gets a lot of press on HN and stealthily get direct user feedback from a tech forum.
- sbuk 11y agoSorry, I don't follow. It's unituititive to have a settings change under settings, where settings for built in apps have always been?
- ScottBurson 11y agoYou have to have some reason to think a setting might exist before you'll go looking for it. If it's unintuitive to think that a particular piece of functionality might be controlled by a setting at all, the fact that it would be easy to find the setting if you knew it existed is of little help.
- sbuk 11y agoThere is an obvious line between being non-intuitive or unobvious and reasons to think something exists or not. A UI cannot rely solely on intuition alone; investigation must be encouraged too.
- roymurdock 11y agoFor me - yes. I had never needed to use "Restrictions" before, and it would seem much more obvious to be able to customize the display of the application from within the app. It also doesn't make all that much sense that by turning off one of the tabs, it would be replaced with an actually useful tab - playlists. I don't work in UI/UX and I'm not an iPhone power user, so perhaps it's just me.
- saturdaysaint 11y agoYeah, the thing I miss most from Spotify is the "Recent" menu, which was basically just a list of the last 20 - 30 albums you listened to. It really clicked with how I (and a lot of people) listen to music - we tend to repeat a certain subset of our music depending on the mood. This is the rare case where I feel like Apple has barely tried to look at how customers use the thing.
- CamperBob2 11y agoI probably spent 5 minutes trying to disable shuffling in iTunes the other day. The icon appeared in several different contexts where clicking on it did nothing. It's just incredible -- stunningly, unbelievably incredible -- that Apple allows this turkey of a Windows application to ship with their name attached.
- wyclif 11y agoiTunes is a real trainwreck. I cannot understand why a company like Apple, that makes so much noise about design, would let it languish.
- siphor 11y agoWow, I thought adding music to your library made it available offline - just realized it didn't (I probably should've noticed) Even with your cue it took me awhile to find that setting, which is included with the sorting (Under My Music/Library, Arrow is next to the default sort of 'Artists')
- mtgx 11y agoPrecisely why I think "Metro" is the worst of the three, and Material Design is the best, because at least it allows for some hierarchy in design. I've always thought Metro was terrible, but others seemed to love it for its seizure-inducing animated colors splattered over the whole screen. Apple's design is bad mainly because it's inconsistent and amateurishly done in its mission to be "flat like the cool kids". Metro is bad on purpose.
- rancur 11y agowhat about Holo theme? The action overflow on the top left, and row'd list of features and options was clean, intuitive, consistent, and was by no means confusing.
- codyb 11y agoI've had a lot of trouble as well. A constant source of frustration is the seemingly unnecessary split between contacts and messages. I don't understand why they're not under one roof and instead frustratingly claw myself around to get to the right section. If I want to send a message to someone why do I have to exit messages to scroll through a list of my contacts? It's ridiculous. Another one is that for the life of me I couldn't figure out how to access the search for app feature until recently. I knew it existed, and I guess it's a downwards pointing tap in the middle of the screen but it took me forever to find it again and then to actually figure out what I had done to trigger it. Then there's the loading my phone with apps I have no use for such as Music, Playbook, and the Apple Watch app. I understand these have useful features to people but I don't understand why I can't at the very least hide the damn icons and instead have to either create a folder for "Shit I don't use ever" or delegate them to some far off slide screen. It seems like it goes on and on and while the old iOS's did look a bit clunky, everything was very clear in my opinion in terms of functionality and I'm not exactly sure why there was a move away from it. And this is all a shame since Apple's hardware software integrated and closed source environment is a terrific way to make a phone in my opinion where I barely have to worry about malware since apps are checked by their App Store team, everything looks standardized and decent because of the components they provide, and things run really fast (at least until your phone is two generations old) because of their language support and hardware integration. It's frustrating.
- rendezvouscp 11y agoWith regard to “why do I have to exit messages to scroll through a list of my contacts”: are you aware that you can start a new message and either start typing in the “To” field or tap the + button to bring up your list of contacts? Is there something else you’re looking for?
- BurningFrog 11y agoSounds like a textbook case of a feature that is not discoverable enough. It is essential to understand that a feature is worse than worthless to the extent that users are not aware of it.
- bobwaycott 11y agoWorse still, since the latest Music update, if there's a way to play through an artist's entire discography, I can no longer find it. And I've been hating for so long the lack of ability to sort by ascending album year so I can match my laptop's iTunes organization. I cannot tell what kind of repeat is on, or if I hit the target at all. There is no button feedback in Music to indicate my touch actually registered. Hell, it may be my iPhone touch sensors are fucked, but I usually have to hit the play/pause, backward/forward buttons multiple times to register a tap. It feels like the hit boxes are smaller since iOS 7—never had any problems playing/pausing or executing prev/next song actions. Now, it ignores my taps at least 50% of the time. Curiously, the new heart button likes to swallow all my taps meant for the prev/back button. Music has become the biggest piece of shit since 7 landed. It gets worse every release.
- agumonkey 11y agoSame for Android 5 over 4.4. It was an awkward pivot, many regression, many gains. A somehow different way of doing things. I'm less and less fond of the generic and design trend, it takes few, yet far too much interactions to use my phone to... phone. But I forgot, these aren't phones.
- jobu 11y agoThe Maps app has been a miserable experience as well. Fortunately it seems a bit improved in iOS9, but it's taken 3 years! It wouldn't be so bad if there was a way to set an alternate app as the default handler for maps/directions.
- sbuk 11y agoThat's great! It took Google and Microsoft at least as long to go from nothing to having useable and useful mapping.
- rancur 11y agoI call Google's the Messy Desk Layout because it forgoes the function, order, and organization offered in a digital system to emulate the messiness of the real world. Stacked cards, the paper-layers-sliding-motion as you scroll down an app's page in the Play Store on your Android, and especially shoving all your Chrome tabs (my friend [...has problems, ok, but still...] regularly rolls with >50 chrome tabs open on his phone) into the Recents switcher (and poor guy isn't smart enough to figure out how to disable that feature in Chrome)... anyways, my opinion is that tacit knowledge trumps nearly any level of design you can come up with. Users never look at the label or the picture of what they're interacting with, they remember it's spacial location in relation to the screen borders. For that reason, a good design should be chosen, and iteratively modified-- occasionally, but things should roughly always be in the same spot as before. This business of rewriting the entire presentation layer every year (Youtube app for example) is very mentally taxing and I have given up trying to learn how to use the new one. I suppose I'll figure it out eventually, but I can more productively spend my energy learning a new language. It is, literally, too hard for me to relearn everything to care about figuring out whatever the hell their UX engineers most recently pulled out of their ass. The thing that really, really angers me is I used to have a keen perception of how a fluid, clean, efficient UI behaved, but as I've been forced to interact with poor designs I've lost that talent. It's not just google, other products aren't designed as well as they were when I was younger, either. About half of my suggestions for usability improvements in google apps ('Send Feedback') have been implemented after I suggested them, and several within 2-4 weeks. This makes me cry at night. I had no idea what I had, and lost... So anyways I basically don't update any apps anymore (they're always removing features or moving them anyways, why would I update if this one works fine?), and if I do and find the new interface too confusing I just track down an older APK online and make a mental note to never update that until I have the time and energy to learn the new layout. bonus mentally-stimulating material: Windows XP's Explorer (likely back from the NT->2k days, and probably entirely thanks to IBM's role in NT development) had a great feature. You changed cursor focus in Windows Explorer with F6--but there were so many panes, so you would hold down F6 till you hit the one you want. Inevitably you were using List View, your hands were on the keyboard, and you were ready to start typing the name of the folder you wanted. The problem? There were so many panes that you'd always miss what you wanted due to the keyboard repeat rate. IBM's (or some other hero at MS) solution? Focus goes to main folder List View pane, to Link bar (ctrl+F6) above the folder List View, and then back to the List View pane. But why? ...because whoever made that decision knew that you were always going to miss it the first time, so they placed it twice so that you'd always hit it...genius... As far as I can tell, these people don't exist anymore.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- carsongross 11y agoThe problem is that UX is mixed with and influenced heavily by (often simply dominated by) design, and design comes from the creative arts world. The creative arts have, since the end of the Edwardian period, and especially since WW2, stressed stripped down minimalism and originality. A lot of this comes from an innate hatred of the bourgeoisie, some of it is simply fundamentally anti-humanist Platonsim. It worked fairly well for a lot of industrial design, but has been a disaster for the built environment and, we are learning, software.
- shripadk 11y agoExactly this. Also trying to find the "Search this Page" feature in Safari needed me to Google and figure out how to do so from a blog post: http://heresthethingblog.com/2014/11/04/ios-8-tip-search-word-web-page/ http://heresthethingblog.com/2014/11/04/ios-8-tip-search-wor... Apple's interfaces were really user-friendly until the movement towards flat design. It was more of a step backwards than forwards.