3 ms·
My objection is that people come up with the metaphor without any evidence. Of course if you know that the author intended the metaphor, go ahead and say it, bu
by StavrosK 11y ago
My objection is that people come up with the metaphor without any evidence. Of course if you know that the author intended the metaphor, go ahead and say it, but I seem to see many more people reading things into a sentence just to have something to say.
- hluska 11y agoI think this is an area where many English teachers need work. Many English teachers present literary analysis as if it is what they experienced the first time they read a particular work. That may be true in some cases, but often, that opinion formed because it's what the experts in that particular writer say. English classes, especially at the University level, would be so much more useful if, instead of saying "the boat trip signifies x", professors went into the reasons they believe that. In some cases, it is personal opinion. In other cases, it is personal opinion based on 30 published articles. And, in still other cases, it is their personal opinion because if they believed anything else, they'd be laughed out of conferences.
- StavrosK 11y agoWhat you propose is a great way to do it. Especially if the justification is "the author said so, I'm not making it up".