5 ms·
It seems to me that Silicon Valley's unicorns are themselves turning into incubators for future spin offs. Uber is taking a ridiculous amount of funding and in
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
It seems to me that Silicon Valley's unicorns are themselves turning into incubators for future spin offs. Uber is taking a ridiculous amount of funding and investing in what can barely be called related technologies. It's not a conglomerate, it's not a global taxi firm, it's not a VC. It's ... Something new. And it's not alone.
Google, Amazon, AirBnB for heavens sake, all are placing bets on future innovations and models a long way from their core. I don't have a problem with this, but it's going to have a lot of knock on impacts. From traditional business valuation techniques to how to tax R&D globally, we are going to see a few decades where unfair and undemocratic could be the global theme, or, we could see better forms of governance emerge.
This, Uber going robotics crazy, is for me just a trigger to realise what has been going on for a while, from Pikkety to Varoufakis, tech has emerged from nice career to political engine of the next decades.
The boy has started saying the emperor has no clothes on. We the people need to know how to deal with a naked emperor and a new species of global something's. We the developers are not isolated from the political effects of the fun technologies we work with.
Gosh I'm pontificating now ...
- beambot 11y agoRobotics for Uber is not a "barely-related technology." For a lot of us, it was always obvious that the core operational model for autonomous cars was Uber-esque. The fact that every major automaker is investing heavily in autonomy should convince you that autonomous cars are an existential threat to Uber. (Not to mention that the driver situation is one of Uber's biggest issues at the moment!)
- ClintEhrlich 11y agoThat last point is really fascinating: The employment status of Uber's drivers could have a significant effect on the speed at which autonomous vehicles are introduced in this country. Uber may accumulate a tremendous amount of cash, only to suffer unfavorable legal rulings that jeopardize its current business model. One of the obvious solutions would be to devote that money towards replacing the drivers with automation, so that the entire "independent contractor vs. employee" issue becomes moot.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoThe employment status of Ubers drivers is a tiny proportion of the impact autonomous cars will have, and to be honest unfavourable legal rulings is factored into their model (Uber seems to be going after 100% of all taxi regiemes, but if they get locked out of only x % - where x is some unknown factor say around 60% - then they are still a vast global cash cow. But just look at the changes that autonomous cars will have apart from solving Ubers W2 and pension provision: - 1/3 of major city ground space is parking - replace that with new housing, or nice green parks. - we think drones will revolutionise delivery - but put a lock box into every cars trunk and add in clever routing software and see what happens - freight and passenger changed the railways. What happens when my commute is merely part of a longer freight haul. - social effects - an hours commute facing forwards and concentrating suddenly becomes ... Family time? Sleep time? Work time? Sex and drugs and adultery? - ownership - I own my car. I choose the colours. If Uber buys 1 million cars they won't ask me my opinion - or will I rent my car to them when I am not commuting in it? Will I part own with several others I am fairly certain will not be doing sex and drugs on the nice upholstery? - it's so big it's scary. PS - completely agree with the "it's out of the labs into the real world - great !" idea you wrote at top of the page. PPS A more useful answer would be that Uber developing autonomous cars to defend against regulatory difficulties is such a huge leap it cannot be defended as a business strategy and only as a VC style investment. These unicorns are not planning on surviving by growing their current business but by starting up totally new ones. It's as if Barclays Bank said, well, we don't need all you employees, we're moving all our assets over to that 12 line peel script over there
- deegles 11y agoIntroducing self-driving cars might harm Uber as well. Drivers might leave en-masse in protest since they're being replaced anyways. If Uber can't roll out SDCs fast enough (maybe parts shortages or whatever) they'll be screwed. Now that I think about it, Uber might have to stockpile the SDCs and release them all at once.
- harryh 11y agoThat's never happened before when industries have become automated. It's not likely to happen this time.
- lifeisstillgood 11y ago(I'm going to make some flat statements that are not meant to be inflammatory about Uber, but are there to be a bedrock to the next step in the logic chain I think is important - so read the next few lines with that in mind please :-) Uber's core operating model is to forcibly standardise taxi regulations in a huge number of regulatory regimes by appealing over the heads of regulators to the market in the hope that if they move fast enough all the regulators won't gang up on them all at the same time. It's probably going to work in much of the Western world (apart from France :-) Now this is a regulatory play - something that needs a very different core skill set to autonomous cars. Ubers recent purchase of Nokia (?) maps is a clear "related" area because right now today, having better maps than the opposition will yield benefits whether humans or robots drive. There is not much of a chasm to leap However autonomous cars are a leap. The technology is only "slightly" there. The legal, regulatory and business models over autonomous cars are nowhere like settled. Who owns the cars, what power source they will have, who will build them, who will even let Uber use them. These are all undecided questions - no way of monetising them on the scale to justify a billion dollar investment This is not to say I don't see a market here - it's going to be staggeringly huge, as plain as the belly found my middle. But it's not yet a related business - it's not a business yet. So what I mean is that all these unicorns are taking huge amounts of suddenly available private capital, and making R&D bets on vast new industries that have yet to become businesses. It's like building petrol garage forecourts because you see potential in the Model T. It's coming yes, but it's not your traditional way to invest billions. The traditional way is to find a repeatable process like "buy a shop on a corner and sell coffee at five bucks a pop" So, there is a new source of huge capital, feeding a new species of R&D company that have structures and (potential) business models that have not been seen before, thus not taxed, regulated or understood before. So, long winded, but the distance between Uber today and a potential autonomous car taxi company is enourmous, and that distance implies a lot more fundamental change to our society than just an investment decision implies.
- seiji 11y agoEverybody thinks Uber wants to make robotic cars so everybody will just use uber robotic cars. But, why won't people buy their own robotic cars and put them on day time "search" mode for fares that get directly paid back to the owner of the vehicle? Then the vehicle can still return home for evenings/weekends when real people need immediate on-demand driving without waiting to be picked up.
- deelowe 11y agoThat's lyft's model, no? :-)
- beambot 11y agoYou could do that... and Uber could be handle all the fulfillment in "search" mode. Heck, there is precedent with "normal" cars already [1]. [1] https://help.getaround.com/hc/en-us/articles/204371664-Guaranteed-earnings-and-30-day-free-trial https://help.getaround.com/hc/en-us/articles/204371664-Guara... Under this model, you're just providing capital investment in a depreciating asset in return for special privileges. You'd have to do a cost-benefit analysis to see how it would work out for you. Personally... I'd leave the capital investment in automobiles to others and just pay surge pricing in the few instances where I need immediate transportation.
- cowsandmilk 11y agowhy don't people have their home computers automatically join cloud computing clusters during the day so they can be used and paid for computation while the people are at work?
- robotresearcher 11y agoBecause the cost of moving the data to the computer is too high. Locality is king. My private car is parked, unused, near potential customers right now.
- untog 11y agoThe same reason relatively few people AirBnB their homes. There will be an administration overhead of at least some kind - who cleans the car? What happens when someone throws up in it? And so on. I'd say, why will people buy their own robotic cars at all? At least in major cities anyway - you could buy a membership to a program (ala ZipCar, car2go, etc) and just have "a car" on tap. The downsides of ownership (maintenance, etc) will be gone.
- Bartweiss 11y agoI think this gets to the heart of Uber's play. They're up against a seemingly endless string of employment-practices lawsuits, and it increasingly looks like they're not going to win. The way out isn't to become a cheaper taxi company, or suddenly overcome entrenched protectionism in a dozen nations. It's to keep pulling in funding and stalling legal battles for just long enough to render the entire argument irrelevant. Driver background checks? No drivers to check on. Driver insurance? No one to insure, sue the manufacturer if you hit something. Employee benefits for drivers? Fire all the employee-contractors. It's obvious that automation is a huge win for Uber. The question is whether they can live long enough to preserver their first-mover advantage, and whether they can find stop-gaps to cover the interim where autonomous cars still need drivers. I wouldn't be surprised if they let licensed passengers get behind the wheel to comply with laws before full autonomy hits.
- thesis 11y agoSerious question.. what is AirBnb doing that's highly innovative and somewhat speculative? Got any links?
- cbhl 11y agoIt's not clear to me that private businesses having research labs is entirely new. The mouse came out of Xerox Parc. Unix and C came out of Bell Labs. And so forth.
- rndn 11y agoAs someone who knows very little about economics personalities, could you explain how Pikkety and Varoufakis fit into this scheme?
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoThere is a (re)surgence of left wing politics detectable as we move away from the old certainties of 20th C. The right is mired in a religious spiral and the left has yet to discover a seam of genuine connection across class to unite over. However it is clear that economics is changing and that class divisions will likely align along wealth. Pikkety is French economist who claims he proves that returns to capital are increasing faster than incomes. The means the rich will get richer faster. The last time this happened was Edwardian era (staving children in London, banquets on the Titanic, massive unrest). The wars of 20 C removed wealth from rich and reallocated it more fairly as democracy and technology spread. However it's going back. Varoufakis is left wing Greek economist (used to work for Valve) and became Greek finance minister when Greece elected a left wing government in January. Greece has been the European gateway to Middle East and Russia - it spends ten times average on military and when it joined the Euro (effectively a gold standard) it joined at wrong exchange rate - really badly wrong. Their economy was shot - Germany for example is able to import Greek olives and export more Greek olive oil than Greece does (Greeks have not invested in automation, their farm subsidies are against it, German farm subsidies fuck up a different part of German agriculture) Anyway Greece economy collapses - but they are in the Euro, so they can't make Greek Drachmas cheaper to help exports - so the only option is to pay people less (it's called internal devaluation or something) it is clearly a shit system for balancing out productivity across Europe What should happen is a federal agreement to reallocate funds through tax and spend and bonds. But federalism is political death in Europe. So a well meaning elite has for decades been pushing a European project - stop war happening again by building trade links, then improve trade by harmonising standards, then improve finance by using same currency, then we will join as a political union and never kill 100 million people again. Unfortunately the Euro is a gold standard and will kill you at the wrong exchange rate - and you can either have federal reallocation of funds (sensible but politically impossible) or you can force the people to take pay cuts till their productivity matches their income. Varoufakis has been pointing this out for years, then got elected and stood up to the European project and said this is economic madness, the people have given us a mandate, you can't manage the structural change like this. He probably called the German finance minister a Nazi during heated discussions. This all went down like a lead balloon - either Greece toed the line and dumped it's democratic mandated and got fucked over, or European project (peace not war) had to end. The Germans held the debt over Greeks till Greeks blinked first. So we have a Western economic consensus of austerity and "fudging" the worlds second largest currency, a renminbi that is based on spreadsheets massaged by politicians desperate to look good while Chine goes from industrial to manufacturing, and a willingness to overlook 1930s level suffering to keep from facing deep political divisions over federalism. At the same time Russia is trying to foment a war or two in order to grab something just East of Greece. Sorry I seem to have lost the thread and scrolling upwards on iPhone textbox is hard. So two left wing economists represent the zeitgeist - we are seeing greater returns to private capital (do you wonder why all those unicorns funded by A16Z have not IPOd? Because they can get as much cash as they want from sovereign funds and banks.) Greater returns to private capital, no left wing intellectual consensus on what is happening and democratic outpourings asking for debt relief are forced out of the way. Now with a new set of massive tech companies, who are making bets on far reaching changes, not because they are white elephants but because the industries that will wipe out today's global stars are already visible on radar, those industries are going to reward tech skills highly (and increase returns to capital) for say 20% of us, and then will break the social convention of sharing in increased wealth through regular jobs because robots will be doing the jobs. So it's a perfect storm of technology taking away jobs, no political will to get behind legitimate democratic discontent and meet difficult decisions about the structure of society, returns on capital making class divisions wider, and new forms of global companies being created without Public company style scrutiny, and without a global consensus on how to effectively tax such structures. We can use technology to usher in a golden age - the economics of technology almost mandate another century of massive wealth creation planet wide. But sharing that fairly and in a managed way is the challenge - and that challenge is represented by those two economists. Sorry - wall of text, unedited. Will come back to it after my no-procrast timeout !
- tdaltonc 11y agoProto-'philes' a la "The Diamond Age"
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> It's not a conglomerate, it's not a global taxi firm, it's not a VC. Of course they're a global taxi firm. They're just a taxi firm that does their own R&D instead of outsourcing it to car manufacturers. Right now, they're investing in robot taxis.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>Varoufakis, tech has emerged from nice career to political engine of the next decades. Uh, he is universally regarded as a failure in Greek politics and a national embarrassment. He resigned in disgrace. If anything, Greece accepted terms worse than the original terms he fought against. He'll be forever known as the guy who hysterically yelled "terrorism" at his creditors and refused to look at Greece's spending, its tax cheats, and its over-abundance of social entitlements. Turns out his "Modern Marxism" is just as much of a failure as classical Marxism. Yeah, I think the blowback for "Revenge of the Geeks" started long ago. The mainstream long appropriated internet/geek culture, rules and regulations have long been in place, and ideas of some kind of tech-led political revolution are fairly silly. A different kind of taxi isn't a revolution. Its boring.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoI'm surprised by that assessment - my perception of his actions (well apart from the in person in the negotiation rooms which seemed to be beyond what even diplomats were used to) was a consistent planned approach - there is no way to pay back Greek debts, no matter how it came about. Reform is needed but first take the debt yoke off. As the yoke was used to effect reforms the EU thought were needed as opposed to any democratic slice of Greece, it's in no way democratic. And that seems to have been Varoufakis position all the way through too. Structural reform that deep is always going to be painful - but it needs to be bought into by the people - not imposed from outside. Britain still has deep divisions (North South, Labour Tory) from years of transferring manufacturing and heavy industry to cheaper off shore locations in the 1980s. But Greece will just hate Germany without any political tranche to explain why the reforms were necessary. This should have been a Greek decision - if they needed to leave the Euro to be free to make those decisions then so be it. No one learns from being forced to do the right thing.