8 ms·
What if there were really no signs of metaphor, and the boat trip was just a boat trip? How do you know you didn't just read a bunch of things into something th
by StavrosK 11y ago
What if there were really no signs of metaphor, and the boat trip was just a boat trip? How do you know you didn't just read a bunch of things into something the author didn't intend?
- arrrg 11y agoMaybe. But the cynical reflexivity with which such judgements are made immediately is … weird. Strikes me as laziness and a basic unwillingness to even engage with something, basically a defense mechanism. It would probably be better to just admit that it’s not for you and leave it at that instead of claiming it to be sucky always forever and for everyone.
- StavrosK 11y agoI think that's because the practice has many parallels with bad science. Ascribing a metaphor to the author without any evidence is pretty much an untestable, unfalsifiable hypothesis, and therefore has no value. If you tell me that author X said that the boat is meant to be a metaphor for the protagonist's life, I will be the first to be excited and read the text looking for all the little easter eggs that the author put in, but without any evidence at all it's just your opinion. This is also exacerbated by the lengths that people go to stretch their theory, which makes it even more obvious that they're grasping at straws in the face of evidence to the contrary.
- Karunamon 11y ago2 years in college leads me to believe that this allergy is acquired. A person can only "engage" with topics they find to be boring, pretentious, or otherwise time wasting, so many times before "once bitten, twice shy" kicks into gear. Also, don't forget, we inflict this process on people as part of basic education in the States. Ask 100 people what they think of classics like The Great Gatsby or The Catcher in the Rye, and more likely than not the answers will be mostly negative. Literary analysis is a subjective affair and turns quite a few people off, moreso when you are being graded on things like having the same opinion as the instructor. You can read something into a piece that may or may not be there, and in any case is more likely than not to be the product of your own experiences and biases, not the content of the work itself.
- guelo 11y agoIf the piece evokes some kind of emotion then it is fair game to analyze the piece to see how it accomplishes this. The problem is that there is no way to prove that an analysis is correct, but the reasoning of good analysis should be logical and plausible.
- StavrosK 11y agoI definitely agree, but the GP was talking about symbolism, which, as far as I know, isn't one of the main ways to evoke emotion.
- hluska 11y agoThat is absolutely valid and in some cases, that is actually true. In other cases though, literary experts are fairly confident that the boat trip was a metaphor because they have gone through letters where the original author talks about what he/she is trying to accomplish with a particular piece. One of the rules of studying literature is that you're always welcome to disagree, but that you need evidence if you want to go against the prevailing opinion. You're welcome to think that Howl is about an acid trip Ginsberg had where he thought he was a wolf, but if you want an A, you better have some letters he wrote to Kerouac about it. :)
- lsaferite 11y agoUnless the prevailing opinion can be backed up with evidence then both opinions should be taken at face value. Just because everyone claims pigs can fly doesn't mean that they can, not unless you can show me proof.
- hluska 11y agoExactly...and I think that only really bad people would disagree. Often in literature, the prevailing opinion is backed up by material published in journals or highly cited books. And generally to get published in a journal, you need some compelling evidence. So, if I want to venture that T.S. Eliot wrote The Waste Land as a response to his own struggles with mental illness, I can back that up with citations from journals, or published books. If I want to go even further (and get an even better mark), I can go into the letters where he first hand talks about his struggles. Just because I can back up my opinions with published material, it still doesn't mean that my opinions are correct. To reverse your metaphor, let's say that you think pigs can fly and I think they can't. You say that pigs can fly because you saw it happen. I say that pigs cannot fly because of these respected books on physics and pig anatomy. You might actually be correct, but I should still win an efficiently run debate.
- StavrosK 11y agoMy objection is that people come up with the metaphor without any evidence. Of course if you know that the author intended the metaphor, go ahead and say it, but I seem to see many more people reading things into a sentence just to have something to say.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoSuppose the author was just really obsessed with boats for some reason, and wrote lots of texts about boats that nobody cares about except him, because no one shares his obsession. It's possible that purely accidentally he wrote something boring about boats that causes readers to think interest things about things that are not boats. This will cause the poem to become popular by itself, without help from the author. From a memetic perspective, this can be worthy of study.
- StavrosK 11y agoThat's different. Of course a work of art should evoke feelings, memories, thoughts, etc to you that are personal to you, it's a big part of what art is supposed to be. What I have a problem with is ascribing these to the author without any evidence that they actually meant it that way.
- Nadya 11y ago>What I have a problem with is ascribing these to the author without any evidence that they actually meant it that way. I'll try to find the artist - but they wrote a song and the fanbase didn't "get their message". The lyrics were supposed to be face-value but people found metaphors where no metaphors were meant to be and devised an entire story around the song that didn't exist. How it related to his childhood growing up and the struggles of his teenage years, overcoming an addiction, etc. The artist said in an interview (Paraphrased) "That's not at all what I meant when I wrote this song - but it does sound better. So I'll take the credit."
- StavrosK 11y agoThat's interesting, do let me know if you find the artist or an article about what happened.
- Nadya 11y agoI was unable to find it. Although I did find a number of songs where the artist had to tell people what it was about because they were misinterpreted. :) Same thing, slightly different scenarios.
- avn2109 11y agoMy favorite Hemingway quote: "There isn't any symbolism. The sea is the sea. The old man is the old man. The boy is a boy and the fish is a fish. The sharks are sharks, no better, no worse."
- pluma 11y agoThe other day I watched Superman Returns and Man of Steel back to back. Spoilers follow, but I think I have a point. The symbolism in Superman Returns was pretty obvious. In addition to the patriotism carried by the colours of his costume, he's obviously a kind of modern-day Superjesus: he's a superhuman only son sent to Earth to protect (save) all of mankind. There's even the entire death and rebirth aspect: he is beaten, then stabbed as the final blow with a lethal weapon (like the spear of destiny), he falls (in a posture reminiscent of Jesus on the cross) and (nearly) dies before being rescued. Then he dies again, staying in coma (for days?) before rising again. The symbolism is there, it's easy to spot if you are looking for it but it blends in nicely enough that you can watch the film without paying any attention to it. It's subtle enough that you can argue whether it's symbolic or not and what is or isn't intended to carry a metaphor. After all the film is intentionally corny and mostly sees itself as a sequel to the famous Superman series that preceded it by a few decades. Then there's Man of Steel. It doesn't even try to hide its symbolism. Kal-El asks a priest in a church for guidance whether to surrender himself in front of a stained glass window showing Jesus asking Yahweh for guidance whether to surrender himself. Kal-El drops out of the spaceship to save mankind in a static Jesus pose. His father's hologram ("His" "Spirit") says that he sent his only son to save mankind. And so on and so forth. Not to mention the facepalm-inducing moments where Kal-El points out how all-American he is despite being an (immigrant) space alien. The American/Christian symbolism is so obtuse it was even used to market the film to Christian audiences. It's less of a hidden allegory and more of a religious pamphlet. What I'm trying to get at (other than Superman Returns clearly being the superior, if underrated, Superman movie and Man of Steel being a US-Christian circle jerk) is that there is a range. Some works of literature go out of their way to rub their symbolism in your face. In others it is present but more nuanced. In some it is subtle put still easy to find if you look for it. And in some any symbolism is merely a projection of what you are trying to find in it. I would agree that most of the symbolism students of literary criticism tend to spend their energy on falls in the last category where you can show a work to handful of critics and get a lifetime's worth of different interpretations. But as much as I personally despise the field as a whole, some works do carry intentional symbolism. And some works unintentionally provide symbolism when read in certain contexts. When you look at "old" literature (i.e. literature that has long outlived its authors), most of the literature that has survived to the modern day is literature that provided meaning across the various generations. It's a legitimate question to ask "why" and "how" -- even if literary studies as a field tends to be more obsessed with the "what".
- steveklabnik 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_the_Author https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_the_Author
- StavrosK 11y agoThat's an interesting argument. I haven't read the essay, so I don't have an informed opinion, but it doesn't especially convince me. The argument that the Wikipedia page mentions, for example (the one about Balzac), says that we can never know what Balzac intended. That's not the same as Balzac not knowing what he intended, so that argument is fallacious.