4 ms·
In addition to the good concerns about exactly who has the power to run privileged code on your computer, I will also point out that: A: If you are serious abo
by jerf 17y ago
In addition to the good concerns about exactly who has the power to run privileged code on your computer, I will also point out that:
A: If you are serious about 'mandating', you just toasted alternative operating systems, and have grotesquely complicated server operators lives, among others; the world is full of more situations than could even begin to be covered by such a policy.
B: What you want won't work anyhow, as your first premise is false: "virus scanners prevent computers from being infected from this stuff". They aren't perfect. Mandating a monoculture of security software simply means that people have to use hacks that work against the current software. (Or a de facto monoculture brought on by a small set of legal choices, or a de facto monoculture brought on by a wide array of choices but one "default" choice. Note that "allowing people to opt out" is simply recreating the current situation, only with a lot more government for no apparent reason.)
Of course, quite a lot of those hacks will involve forging the presence of the software, making it look like the anti-virus is still running when it actually isn't. A task that is very difficult today, you made easy by "mandating" which software it needs to be, which is whatever the gov provides by default.
Even beyond the legitimate concerns expressed by the other posters, your idea is worthless from a security point of view. Security problems go well beyond "not everybody is running a virus scanner", or any other set of defined software, and you would actually make things worse, not better.
Of course you will disagree, because in your head security software is perfect and you can't perceive the massive problems that would result from your suggestion, since you're working with mental ideation primitives that don't correspond to anything that exists in the real world. There isn't much I can do about that, other than point it out.
- chrischen 17y agoPerhaps "mandating" is too strong a word. Simply subsidizing or allowing security software to be obtained free would achieve the same effect. I meant "to make into law" when I said "mandate." When I say "opt out", I simply mean that the security software is freely available, but not forced onto your computer. I'm not proposing some sort of communistic action plan. I'm simply suggesting that if the the government provided security software for free, more people would have access to it, and the effect of viruses on businesses can be curtailed. > Of course you will disagree, because in your head security software is perfect and you can't perceive the massive problems that would result from your suggestion, since you're working with mental ideation primitives that don't correspond to anything that exists in the real world. You're absolutely right. My suggestion is predicated upon the idealization of antivirus software. Which is exactly why I started out my suggestion with a question about whether or not virus scans can detect this stuff that cause botnets. And then I followed with an if this is true ... then take my suggestion seriously. I never meant to imply that I know much about the efficacy of a virus scanner. In fact, I use a mac, so my exposure to them has been limited. I don't know how you got a look inside my head, but you clearly need glasses. Second of all I think you, and a lot of other people who down-modded me may have jumped to conclusions when I used the words "mandate" and suggested the government do something for the greater good. I'm not suggesting something akin to the communist green dam software. My suggestion is probably less controversial than the healthcare plan, since it would be cheaper to implement. It's more like the government digital converter box subsidy program if anything. So assuming if everyone had virus scan, would it help? If it doesn't, then why did I waste money on Norton antivirus on my PC? Surely virus scan must be able to do something. Definitions can be easily updated across the installed base to counter the latest zombie virus. If you have evidence that this would all be futile, then I retract all my statements about giving this supposedly useless product out to everyone. You probably know more about virus scanners than I do, and I'm not here to argue with you about their efficacy. So unlike what you thought I wiould do, I am not going to disagree with you about their efficacy.
- alexkay 17y agoThere are already several free anti-virus software available (avast, clam, etc.) No, they don't catch everything.
- chrischen 17y agoHow are they compared to commercial ones and can't they at least be used as a vector to deliver the latest antivirus?
- thwarted 17y agoDoesn't Windows already come with a virus scanner, provided for free by Microsoft? I don't know for sure, since I only boot XP to play games, but it keeps nagging me about having all their security things enabled.
- chrischen 17y agoI'm pretty sure xp doesn't have one. But if windows 7 has one then that would be a nice group who can receive virus definitions to root out botnets right? I mean this potentially larger pool of virus scan enabled computers can be used to push updates to. Otherwise they'll be stuck to blocking out dns right?