3 ms·
> I'll err to the side of caution and assume they are ultimately harmful to people and not use them. Which is what you are advocating in other forms of speech
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
> I'll err to the side of caution and assume they are ultimately harmful to people and not use them. Which is what you are advocating in other forms of speech
Myself, I'd consider the side of caution to be continuing to use them. Since they're warning people about something potentially a problem, I'd rather be careful in case people are relying on them. (That's for places where they're already used. Your approach might be better for new places.)
> Speech is fluid and always changing. If there isn't an alternative, you're free to create one.
Oh sure, I realise that! I could say 'straw person' or maybe 'scarecrow fallacy'.
> On a tangent, I'd like to tell a short story about a female leader of an all-female group. She begins speaking to the group with "Okay guys". I think any reasonable person would accept that the term "guys" has lost its masculinity over the years and is used as a gender-neutral.
Wiktionary's page on 'guys' is interesting here (see: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/guys https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/guys) - it's gender-neutral... sometimes. It's not always. It's a weird case.
> Ultimately - policing speech is a waste of effort. New words will always come into existence as euphemisms of the "wrong" words and knowing that speech is "bad" allows others to use it for power.
I'm not sure this is always true. Insults against gay people being proscribed doesn't seem to have created new ones, but I may be wrong.