4 ms·
This would definitely be classed as animal abuse today. To quote the article: > Reports indicate that Mike's beak, face, eyes and an ear were removed with the
by Someone1234 11y ago
This would definitely be classed as animal abuse today.
To quote the article:
> Reports indicate that Mike's beak, face, eyes and an ear were removed with the hatchet blow. But Smulders estimates that up to 80% of his brain by mass - and almost everything that controls the chicken's body, including heart rate, breathing, hunger and digestion - remained untouched.
So in effect the chicken was still alive and potentially suffering the whole 18 months. Lovely.
- vijayr 11y agoConsidering that we literally grind male chicks alive in factories, pump animals with a ton of chemicals to increase their weight and so on...not sure if anyone would think it is animal abuse even today
- rev_bird 11y agoI've seen those video clips: It's a horrifying glimpse at the consequences of our desire for low-cost meat products, and one of the (many) contributing reasons that I'm almost entirely vegetarian these days. But I've also thought about that grinder a lot: I'm not sure there's a lot of suffering involved -- that grinder thing is moving fast, and those chicks go from "la la I'm a baby chicken" to a red mist in, I'd guess, less than half a second. I reflexively object to the practice, but I honestly can't come up with another way of getting that done if it's necessary to do. Anyway, if I had the choice of being ground up nearly instantaneously or to have the front half of my skull removed with a hatchet, I'd have to pick the grinder.
- corin_ 11y agoI'm know nothing about the subject, and maybe the current way is perfect in its speed, but "I honestly can't come up with another way of getting that done if it's necessary to do" - using drugs to knock them out before killing them is surely an obvious idea, even if it might not (I've no idea) be practical for other reasons
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThe grinder is more cost effective, and is endorsed as humane.
- PretzelPirate 11y agoI would just say that it isn't necessary to do. That makes the problem much simpler.
- rtkwe 11y agoYeah, as bad as that image is it's pretty much the best ways to get it done. The only better way I could think of, other than somehow stopping male eggs from being viable somehow, would be to use nitrogen suffocation. Most animals and humans don't register a lack of oxygen but an excess of CO2 and actually get a bit euphoric (at least humans do and pigs that were tested would willingly go back into the environment for apples). That would have it's own issues with it being a more batch-y process than the grinder, and how to you keep them from just waiting in packed conditions before being euthanized. There's a BBC documentary on capital punishment and alternatives that explores this iirc.
- MrJagil 11y agoHere's a video if anyones interested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wajmdD97nk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_wajmdD97nk It's not safe for work nor kids and could be regarded as FUD (as I have no verification on the facts in the video). This is purely for intellectual curiosity; I'm not trying to start a heated debate on animal cruelty.
- yincrash 11y agoWell, yes. The chicken was definitely alive. None of us can know whether it was suffering. Once you remove parts of the brain, all bets are off. In a human, the front of your brain (such as the prefrontal cortex) is where a lot of what makes you "you" lives.
- trhway 11y ago>None of us can know whether it was suffering. you must be kidding. Until of course under "suffering" you mean a suffering of a Victorian girl who can't communicate her love to that fine Navy officer. > Once you remove parts of the brain, all bets are off. In a human, the front of your brain (such as the prefrontal cortex) is where a lot of what makes you "you" lives. if you google something like "brain pain perception", you'll find that the front of the brain is responsible for conscious reaction to pain, like planning action to avoid it. The pain itself is very primal, ie. like amygdala primal.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoPain and suffering are clearly very different things. I'd suggest that 'conscious reaction to pain' is a good working definition of 'suffering'.
- trhway 11y agoit already has definition : suffering - "the state of undergoing pain, distress, or hardship." Introducing new definitions like yours is just an implicit attempt to advance anthropocentric exclusivity, pretty much the re-worded equivalent of that religious dogma of "only humans have soul"
- cgio 11y agoAccording to your own definition, I think the GP argues whether there is a state to talk about without consciousness.
- 11y ago
- morley 11y agoI don't really understand; the images in the article show a chicken with its entire head and neck removed, which doesn't jibe with that description. Am I just mistaken about chicken anatomy, or is there something missing?
- recycleme 11y agoIt's probably not the actual chicken for one.
- yincrash 11y agoThat is the chicken[1] in the photo. According to the article, a lot of a chicken's brain is in the very back of the head / beginning of the neck. I believe in the photo, that's still got the entire neck there. Comparison photo of a full chicken[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_the_Headless_Chicken https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_the_Headless_Chicken [2] http://img3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130606165306/animalcrossing/images/4/41/Chicken.jpg http://img3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130606165306/animalcros...
- agumonkey 11y agoSo if self survival isn't required, the brain is of no use ?
- theophrastus 11y agoI believe the precision anatomical cartoon associated with this "The Straight Dope" article is closer to the actual head proportion left, "..he chopped off just the top two-thirds of Mike's head..": http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/991/is-it-possible-for-a-chicken-to-live-with-its-head-cut-off http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/991/is-it-possible-...