7 ms·
Why Europe’s Trains Are So Much Better Than America's
- jbpritts 11y agoUtopic intercity train travel in Europe is a myth. In Germany it is good, but expensive and most under 30 are trying to find an affordable alternative, e.g., BlahBlah car or a bus. France is just prohibitively expensive: I had a group trip cancelled because people balked once they saw what the TGV costs were. In Czech republic inter city is cheap, but there is no AC in the cabins and dodgy heat, infrequent high speed corridors, no WiFi, and often it is standing room only (keep in mind this might be for a 2-3 hour trip). Intracity transport is much better than the us almost all over Europe, but don't by the hype otherwise.
- amalag 11y agoBecause Europe is older, smaller and more population dense.
- cylinder 11y agoNew York metro is very dense and all the commuter rail systems are pretty bad, or worse. Bumpy rides, delays, uncomfortable interiors, etc. I can't really work on anything on the LIRR or NJT because it's so wobbly. I got on a commuter rain in Geneva and it was so incredibly smooth and the whole experience comfortable.
- virmundi 11y agoTo harp on the American rail system: I could literally not type on portions of the ride from Palatka to D.C. The tracks were so wobbly and bouncy that my hands would jump all over the keyboard.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAll because we're reduced to freight lines, as the lines built expressly for commuters (with their welded rails and better maintenance) are long gone.
- Mithaldu 11y agoAs a german: This. Europe can afford to have better trains and public transit systems across the board because it's easier for us to have a consistent level of quality, since we simply have much less area to service and trains are a viable alternative for a massive portion of the populace.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoNot true, not true at all. The Boston-Washington Megalopolis is about the size and population of West Germany. But West Germany had proper rail service, and in the US it was always awful.
- rhino369 11y agoA big problem with the DC to Boston Amtrak run is that it subsidizes the entire rest of the Amtrak network, which loses money hand over fist. The DC/Boston line is profitable. But it's neglected and starved. If instead that money could used to revitalize that stretch, it could be much more useful. America rail went through each small town as it already existed and the track is too twisty to go very fast over a lot of the stretch. And it's all so we can have trains that go from DC to Chicago in like 12 hours + 0-3 hours of delays. That route is unnecessary. A DC to Chicago flight is 1:45 hours and is cheap as fuck. Plus we have buses that use the highways. Our rail sucks because we propping up useless routes.
- superuser2 11y agoTo be clear, these trains aren't empty. The Lake Shore Limited (Chicago <-> New York) goes sold out for days when winter storms take a shit on the Northeast air corridor and everyone's trying to get home from Christmas break. It's also $100 regardless of season.
- ghaff 11y agoMaybe I should take the Empire Builder and/or the California Zephyr while there's still time. To be sure, there are a lot of subsidies built into a lot of transportation options and, if you eliminate Amtrak outside of the Northeast, a lot of those passengers need to get from A to B somehow (which may well be sub-segments of the long haul routes). But, yeah, from a utilitarian perspective I've never found inter-city Amtrak travel to make a lot of sense in the US outside of the Northeast (nor, in many cases, Europe for that matter).
- cozzyd 11y ago* older: the railroad was invented in the 19th century, and I think the US railroad network circa 1900 was superior to Europe... * smaller: not really... depends where you count. * more population dense: nobody is expecting good rail transit in Wyoming or Montana (although, Scandinavia seems to do okay with low density). The Northeast, Midwest, and California are all very dense and still have much worse rail transit.
- ghaff 11y agoThe Northeast really isn't that bad for trains but it does suffer from the fact that there was a multi-decade exodus from many cities by both residents and companies for a variety of reasons. That didn't exactly encourage investment in rail infrastructure.
- ghaff 11y agoTo pick just one example from the article, there's the argument that successful high-speed rail has to go from dense city core to dense city core while simply passing through ex-urban locations. The ex-urban stops are one of the whole appeals of Acela in the Northeast Corridor in the US as they allow travel to New York City without going to downtown Boston. The article sort of went off the, um, rails when it basically suggested that if only US cities were bulldozed and re-engineered to the priorities of less land-rich continent then rail would make a lot more sense. I even like taking the train in general but it's hard to make the numbers work in much of the US.
- arethuza 11y agoThe continent of Europe (10.18 million km²) is slightly larger than the area of the United States (9.857 million km²). Yes, the EU is quite a bit smaller than the US - but there is an awful lot of Europe that isn't in the EU. Personally, I think it's about the distribution of population in Europe - where most population centers are reasonably close together and with the peripheries less populous whereas the US has populations towards the peripheries and a relatively sparsely populated center (roughly).
- duaneb 11y agoEurope is more than twice the size of the US in population, so even as a whole it is much more densely packed.
- revelation 11y agoPopulation density of whole countries tells us nothing. China: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cd/Population_density_of_China_by_first-level_administrative_regionsEnglish.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cd/Populati... USA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_population_density#/media/File:Map_of_states_showing_population_density_in_2013.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_populat... People concentrate regardless of land size. Feel free to quote population density when you are a russian farmer in Siberia brewing vodka, but chances are the argument falls utterly flat.
- duaneb 11y agoI'm not sure what you're even arguing. It seems pretty clear that population density has a strong correlation to efficiency of public transit. If nobody lives there, don't run rail to it.
- anonymoushn 11y agoYou could take a bunch of regions where it would be reasonable to build trains, and then you add a bunch of regions where it would not be reasonable to build trains, and count them together. The population density of that combined area tells you very little about whether it is reasonable to build trains somewhere in that area.
- sliverstorm 11y agoA nice map http://static.persquaremile.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/us-europe-high-speed-rail-and-density.png http://static.persquaremile.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/u... Wyoming, in particular, has a lower population density than Siberia!
- arethuza 11y agoBut that just shows how difficult these comparison are - Siberia has an extremely uneven distribution of population. If you chose one part of Siberia - Krasnoyarsk Krai, it is nearly ten times the area of Wyoming and has a much lower population density 1.21/km2 rather than 2.26/km2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krasnoyarsk_Krai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krasnoyarsk_Krai [NB And there appears to be an even bigger and emptier bit of Siberia next door but I haven't worked out what it is yet!]
- sliverstorm 11y agoPrecise comparisons are aside the point, which is simply that the middle of the United States is incredibly population-sparse, in the same ballpark as Siberia. Which, coincidentally, is not exactly known for its convenient commuter rail network.
- dagw 11y agoI'd take that map with a huge grain of salt. Saying that Norway has High Speed Rail for example is a bit of a stretch considering that the only high speed rail line in all of Norway is a short stretch between Oslo and the main airport. Saying Norway has high speed rail is like saying that the US has a monorail system.
- melling 11y agoI'm just going to copy and paste my notes here. This is sort of an FAQ that is incorrectly brought up. I need to add population for the U.S. cities but it's obvious that you're wrong? Los Angeles to San Francisco 400 miles Los Angeles to San Diego 150 miles NYC to Philadelphia 92 miles NYC to Boston 220 miles NYC to Washington DC 226 miles Chicago to St Louis 260 miles Dallas to Houston 240 miles Dallas to Austin 200 miles Austin to Houston 170 miles Tampa to Orlando 85 miles Miami to Orlando 235 miles --- Population of Rome: 2.7m Population of Milan: 1.3m Rome to Milan: 355 miles
- amalag 11y agoCherry-picking a few cities is not helpful
- Arubis 11y agoWithout having read the article: because we prioritize freight (CSX, etc.) over passengers. Freight liners own a lot of the rails; Amtrak merely leases time on them. There's a LOT of trains going through Denver these days--mostly laden with coal and petroleum. Who needs pipes when you've got rails?
- stevoski 11y ago"We" is who? Europe or USA?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoCSX is an American railroad. Amtrak is the national passenger agency in the US. Denver is in the US, not in Europe.
- KfZ 11y agoDenver and the Am in Amtrak suggest USA.
- iolothebard 11y ago"Also, the Milbrae and Burbank station locations will be in less accessible areas" Millbrae isn't a "less accessible area". You've got both BART and Caltrain. Do a little research author? Millbrae is actually the best place IMO in the Bay Area to stop, especially if they ever expand BART.
- ghaff 11y agoNot if everyone would only live in densely populated, walkable cities created by the wave of a magic wand because that's what the author would clearly prefer.
- x0x0 11y agoWell, it's what we can afford / are capable of making work, given the constraints in California: limited land area (particularly coastal land area with nice weather), large increases in population, an inability to scale freeways to move as many people as necessary, etc.
- ghaff 11y agoMy point is that doesn't describe the reality of California for all sorts of historical reasons so assuming that's the reality isn't very useful. Perhaps SF and the South Bay should encourage higher density and mixed use communities, but that takes a long time even in the best case. The bottom line is that not everyone can necessarily live in the specific locale they'd prefer. And just making things denser isn't the answer. Marin County isn't Marin County if you make it NYC.
- saosebastiao 11y agoLand area is only a constraint in CA because they have rejected density as a solution to the constraint. The city of San Jose could be home to 13M people at Manhattan levels of density, or 7M people at Brooklyn levels of density. Instead, it is home to 1M people, with freeways that are relatively overbuilt in relative comparison.
- x0x0 11y ago
- dogma1138 11y agoHmm European train rides tend to be quite bit more expensive than in the US, even if you take the craziness of the UK train system which is much costlier than mainland Europe (London to Newcastle costs more than London to Brussels), yearly train tickets in the Netherlands, Germany and France are also quite expensive...
- wozniacki 11y agoPareto optimally, perhaps the European train experience is superior to the American one. However, Bill Maher begs to differ on his recent train trip experience from Stockholm to Oslo which he equates to Amtrak [1] [1] Lewis Black and Bill Maher: Why we're bachelors http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8osINepuw8&t=2m43s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8osINepuw8&t=2m43s
- _delirium 11y agoScandinavia is not really where you want to go in Europe for good intercity trains (its commuter rail is another story). The connection between Sweden and Norway is especially notorious for being ancient and slow, with plans to upgrade it being discussed for many years. The modern lines are the Great Belt route east-to-west across Denmark, and the triangle in southern Sweden connecting Malmö, Gothenburg, and Stockholm. And even those are not up to French, Spanish, or German standards. Some maps: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sweden_railways.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sweden_railways.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Danmark_maks._hastighed.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Danmark_maks._hastig...
- cjrp 11y ago> even if you take the craziness of the UK train system which is much costlier than mainland Europe (London to Newcastle costs more than London to Brussels) Not if you book in advance; a single journey London -> Newcastle in 3 months will cost £29.10, vs. traveling today which would cost £121.00.
- Timmons 11y ago
- pothibo 11y agoThe difference is because in America, there's 2(3) countries. In Europe, you travel between ~10 countries. The budget/mentality is different since you operate in international level with international import/exports.
- chadgeidel 11y ago"in America there's 2(3) countries" - I'm curious what you are referring to here - Canada, US, and Mexico or "regions of the United States". The article appears to be merely talking about the United States.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- prawn 11y agoWouldn't the hassle in coordinating things across multiple countries be much higher? Not sure why anyone would make excuses for the US on trains. There are some great opportunities to get it right. Or ignore it and wait for automated bus services.
- DiThi 11y ago> Wouldn't the hassle in coordinating things across multiple countries be much higher? Not much more than across US states. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Agreement (although as someone else commented, it's not easy to get trains going through more than one border). > Or ignore it and wait for automated bus services. Buses won't reach 330 km/h (210 mph, speed of trains made in my country, Spain).
- 6t6t6 11y agoThe Spanish new High Speed train infrastructure is, except for the line that connects Madrid and Barcelona, a massive nonsense that has been build only for political reasons. Spain has more km of high speed lines that Japan, but some of the lines have only tens of passengers per day! It is an economical calamity, for a country already in a deep crisis, that the taxpayers will have to pay during decades. The AVE is an example of how infrastructures should never be planned and deployed.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fraencko 11y ago> And on German trains, the wi-fi actually works. That is a lie. Source: I'm German.
- nathancahill 11y agoI'd heard rumors, so I was excited to get some work done on a bus from Hamburg to Berlin a couple months ago. Was disappointed when the wifi cut out after 10 minutes.
- zobzu 11y agoI dont think american trains have any incentive to get better. it works sort of good enough and people pay, why care about speed or comfort? in "europe" and really they mean germany and france, switzerland in particular, not actual "all of europe" - there is a minimum coverage the company has to achieve ands it cant "get out of it". Same thing for cellphone coverage and internet coverage. Heck, France is starting to get a lot of FTTH everywhere (free install, less than 30e/mo for 100mit) because of these requirements. The bay area can keep dreaming on getting something else than comcast at 30mbit coaxial cable for 60 bucks/mo + have to buy modem and tech if not wired. Basically, capitalism-all-the-things don't work very well with monopolies and corrupted organizations/cities/countries. socio-capitalism isnt the greatest but it works a little better.
- 1971genocide 11y agoIts also got to do with culture. Americans have a deep love for car culture - and look at public transportation as social welfare [1]. American capitalism is also responsible for america having the most profitable multinationals in the world. Its just that it doesn't work very good for society but does allow money to multiply really well. [1] http://www.vox.com/2015/6/12/8764819/why-american-trains-are-bad http://www.vox.com/2015/6/12/8764819/why-american-trains-are...
- hannob 11y agoAs someone from Germany I find the description in the first chapter a bit idealized. The truth is: Trains in Germany are also notoriously late. And the Wifi quite often doesn't work as another commenter already mentioned. (that doesn't change the fact that of course the German rail system is much better than the one in the US - but one shouldn't overidealize it, it has lots of problems itself)
- ahh 11y agoI don't have data on this, but I am willing to bet your German definition of "notoriously late" is much more stringent than an American's. (Not that you're wrong to think that: we've just gotten used to extremely low standards in America because all of our public projects are run incompetently.)
- honest_joe 11y agoThe only rail system that works is the Koreans and that is because their country is so small. Good trains for relatively small price.